Glad to see you're back.

im really getting tired of the Hermione centric view... they're looking at brooms and she's asking herself questions intelligent questions? would have been great to flesh out harry as a character here... harry is a side character by now. if your wold building wasn't so amazing, I'd already have dropped it several times over... im really tired of stories where Hermiones faults are lovable, while she really is just a bag for knowledge dumping.

I’m loving this story. It’s a great twist on the norm. The letters seem so natural and organic it’s like you have actually embodied both people, I’m obviously started reading when it’s compleately done (45 chap) or dam close too. Keep this quality up and you’ll be come a pro writer in no time if that Is your goal, of not keep thus stuff coming it’s amazing

I have really enjoyed this story. All the different threads weaving together to make a whole cloth has been fascinating to watch. I look forward to the next update!

Thanks for a great read so far!

This Dumbledore's deluded religious lack of self-determination is awful! He reminds me of Sybil's schizophrenic mother, "Have to do it! Have to do it! That's a book you don't need to read more than once. And I say that as a person of faith! Freedom of choice is an important facit of my religion though... so that whole predestined- to- follow- the- path- laid- out- for- you and that you must be purified by pain Puritian speal doesn't resonate with me. It makes me more and more uncomfortable with this Dumbledore as we go along. I hope I can finish, the book is great but I have the squicks!

You can't just rip our hearts out and leave a simple "thanks for reading" AN afterwards! x.x I've been killed and revived many a time by this story, and yet it's just began.

Oh, okay, nevermind. You said insane. That makes sense, like I was so confused for what angle you were trying for a moment, I was absolutely trying my hardest to see the way you tried to portray him, but nah, yeah he's just insane. That makes much more sense hahaha. I freaking love this story already, though I just started reading it today.

or insane, to my last review. Oblivious, insane, or pacifistic.

Okay, tell me if I'm wrong, but you're making Dumbledore out to be either extremely pacifistic and or senile, in such a way that he's doing more bad than he is good? Please explain, bc you say he's misunderstood in an earlier Author's Note but all I'm seeing is someone oblivious to their own wrongdoings, which doesn't make him misunderstood, it makes him still in the wrong. I don't mean to be rude or anything, I'm just really really confused rn.

per bio page update 6-23-20:

I'm not saying a word. I wouldn't want to seem impatient.

Oh my goodness! He is Puritan! Next thing we know he will be flogging himself!

Aargh. I know it's not your fault but it drives me up the wall. It is the Philosopher's Stone. The holy grail of alchemists from time immemorial. That American publishers renamed it the Sorcerer's stone is a decision I still can't understand over twenty years later.

You had me at Tim Minchin and Matilda the Musical :) Groundhog Day the Musical has some great music as well. Also by Tim Minchin.

But seriously, I really like the beginning of this fic, and I'm looking forward to reading the rest of it. It looks like there's a lot of it.

Mipsy is adorable, I shan't fault her for anything and hope she'll be great friends with Dobby