Reviews for Mary Potter 2: the Heir of Slytherin
PrincessMagic chapter 9 . 10/13
okay loving this Mary Draco camaraderie and Cammy is so awesome!
PrincessMagic chapter 5 . 10/13
AHHH! LOVE! ABSOLUTE PERFECTION! Slytherins know how to cause chaos in the most satisfying way!
WirelessW chapter 22 . 9/6
How does a 12-year-old girl from very boring and ordinary parents in 1992 know what anime even is, let alone specific tropes like catgirls?

Bear in mind she's not looking anything up online. Maidstone has a comic shop and a games workshop, but it's hardly nerd central.

And I'll repeat an earlier review but I do think it's worth saying - if Lily Evans is descended from Voldemort, then the blood purists are right. You've written the equivalent of a WW2 story where the Holocaust is presented as justified and based in sound logic.
WirelessW chapter 21 . 9/6
Surely if Voldemort really is Lily's father and Mary's grandfather then the pureblood-supremacists were right all along.

This is like reading a piece of WW2 historical fiction where it turns out the Jews actually were all evil.
BlueFin314 chapter 23 . 7/30
Okay, that was definitely a Hitchhiker’s reference, so was having 42 people in the ritual also one?

So, as the daughter of Tom Riddle (she’d have been born before he rose to power as Lord Voldemort, which I suppose is a good thing), wouldn’t Lily be a parselmouth? How could she have hid it, without even knowing? I suppose she may not have encountered a snake, especially in Gryffindor, until she knew enough to know a: Voldemort may have been her real father and b: it’s considered Dark, and therefore she hid it but made the most of it.

Of course, it is also entirely possible that the result of Tom Riddle was a false positive that’s something to do with either the Scarcrux or the Ritual in the Chamber, but without information to support that, I probably can’t assume it.
YuriFan5 chapter 9 . 7/15
A teacher doing magic on a student against her will? A *male* teacher doing magic that disables the wand arm, the means of self defense, on a *female* student? In broad daylight with witnesses? I smell a law suit against the school.
YuriFan5 chapter 3 . 7/14
In this universe Mary has competent legal guardians who actually care about her. Couldnt she sue the prophet for harassment or profiting off her likeness without her permission?
Matthias von Schwarzwald chapter 1 . 11/5/2019
So, there are two independent alignment axes, each with two opposing ends and neutral in the middle? I assume you're geeky enough to know what that reminds me of.

P.S.: I really, *really* like ritual magic.

P.P.S.: And worldbuilding. And the cosmology you're using here. And I'm rather partial to Dark!Fem!Harry, though I prefer *Harriet* or a flower name.
RandomBlondeChick chapter 9 . 8/9/2019
Is it weird that I kind of ship MaryXDraco and MaryXTheo?
Keradeus chapter 14 . 7/20/2019
Aww, Tommy made a friend.
ALRYM chapter 14 . 10/16/2018
I really like this chapter!
Katarok chapter 22 . 9/19/2018
Did Dumbledore ever told you what happened to your grandfather?

He told me enough! He told me that you killed him!

No I am your Grandfather!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! It is not truth it's impossible!

Search your feelings Mary you will know it to be true! Join me and together we can rule the Magical World like Grandfather and Grandaugher!
mes1066 chapter 9 . 8/3/2018
I really like your house elf backstory, internally consistent and satisfying.
walking-on-thunderclouds chapter 9 . 1/18/2018
I think this is actually a pretty good take on the house elves, it actually tries to go into why house elves would stay essentially slaves instead of just being 'oh, they like it, they're all cool with it,' and nothing else like most fics I've read.
walking-on-thunderclouds chapter 5 . 1/18/2018
Gilderoy Lockhart gets put in his place, lmao, fave scene so far.
88 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »