Reviews for An Unlikely and Rather Odd Visitor
Guest chapter 6 . 7/25
Angrod is Finarfin's son, not Feanor's.
Guest chapter 2 . 7/25
Well it's a fair guess, I suppose. How many would guess half-Vala, half-human? 'Cause that's the best approximation of what Percy would be in Middle Earth - a daughter of Ulmo.
Guest chapter 23 . 7/25
I wonder what Glorfindel would say if he knew that even Eru is inclined to spread the gossip when it comes to him?
- QueenCarlton
David12leca chapter 24 . 7/24
THE HOBBIT my guess
JessSlytherin chapter 24 . 7/22
Shame that you didn't get the results you wanted, good luck with your studying and your SAT's ! Now, to the chapter... Loved it, shame she couldn't kick glorfindel's ass... I'm i right in assuming this is just at the start of the Hobbit, and Gandalf wants het help for the dwarves?
Falconress chapter 24 . 7/21
Umm...
Maybe this is back when Aragorn was just still with the elves?...
Don't worry, my siblings are doing SAT too, so I know how time consuming and hard it is!
Guest chapter 24 . 7/21
Please tell me they aren't climbing out of the Valley, or worse, climbing to one of the passes (most likely the High Pass) in the Misty Mountains.
Gandalf has no business taking Percy to Goblin Town!
The only place worse would be Isengard or Moria!
Well, not the only place but Mordor ts supposed to be warm enough to not get snow and the stronghold in Mirkwood is not a hill from what I remember of the movies.
- QueenCarlton
Guest chapter 23 . 7/17
I forgot to ask earlier, does she have the Greek god form that turns mortals into ash if they see it? And if she does, how does it work on Middle Earth? I thought they might burn up like the Hunters of Artemis but then I remembered that Elves don't usually stay dead and that EluThingol was married to Melian who might as well have been a lesser god and surely she didn't spend centuries around him and his people without ever slipping up?
- QueenCarlton
Guest chapter 23 . 7/10
On behalf of our race, I'd like to point out that unlike Elrond we weren't actually around during the time of the ancient Sumerians.

Glad to see that you're back. Can I hope that the next update will be a trifle sooner?

Also, does she or does she not understand the concept of discretion? If she proves herself to be good enough to beat Glorfindel then that'll make her a person of interest and gossip and the fact that there was never any warrior elleth by the name of Persephone in Mithlond will come out easily enough given the implied, albeit largely one way, traffic between Rivendell and the Grey Havens.

- QueenCarlton
David12leca chapter 23 . 7/9
thank you for the update its awesome work i love that its continuing
JessSlytherin chapter 23 . 7/9
Oh I'm so happy you updated! I certainly missed your wonderfull story and great writing skills... Btw the exam went well, tot my marks yesterday, i'm almost a university alumna for the second time!
helkil chapter 23 . 7/8
glad you are back
Falconress chapter 23 . 7/8
Hello! Glad to see you back! I wonder what time frame she's in?
Kyle chapter 22 . 6/21
Please finish this story.
Guest chapter 22 . 6/15
I forgot to ask earlier - what are Percy's domains? I mean like, does she have the exact same powers as Poseidon? 'Cause flying ain't exactly a Poseidon thing. But maybe it's a God thing? Wasn't there something in the Battle of Olympus book about the divine teleportation thing being a form of air travel? Also, if she has the exact same domains as her dad then what does that say about her position in Earth's pantheon? Is she a minor God in Poseidon's court in Atlantis or is she something else? Is she still a member of the quest? Like maybe their own tagalong God so they don't have to worry about looking for a deity everytime they need to kill a Giant? Does she have Greek and Rman aspects or is she purely a Greek deity? Or does she have 3 aspects - Greek, Roman and Middle Earth-ian? What's her status in Middle Earth. Like is she Eru's equal or a lesser God. What are her relations with the Valar and the Free Peoples going to be like? Will she get caught up in the Elf-Dwarf rivalry or will she rise above it 'cause she's a goddess to all of Middle Earth and not just the Elves? Is she a Goddess to all of Middle Earth?
-QueenCarlton
P.S. That's my AO3 username. I got tired of guessing which reply is for me, specially 'cause I've a bad habit of leaving multiple comments.
116 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »