OK so I was originally only going to do this as a one shot but you all normally want sequels so I made it its own story. I hope you like it and let me know if I should continue writing this. For those of you worried that i have too many stories going, there are like 10 fics that only have a few chapters left so ill have more time for the others.

Also I have a wattpad account Spobyfanfiction3 now and I am working on putting all of my stories on there as well, so for those of you that have an account if you could vote and comment on there as well I would really appreciate it. Also I will be using it as a back up if I am unable to post on here (which has happened before)

"You must give up the life you had planned in order to have the life that is waiting for you"

Toby was on his first date in what felt like forever. Caleb had met a nice girl and introduced them. Her name was Yvonne and she was pretty and smart, she was definitely his type. They were going to the grocery store to buy food and then cook a meal together. The date sounded like something a guy that hadn't made any plans did to try to seem romantic. It had been Caleb's idea and Yvonne had loved it. So here he was pulling up to the supermarket. Yvonne was in the passenger seat talking about how she had wanted to be a ballerina until she was 9 but had given it up for playing the violin.

"I'm still pretty flexible though" she said giving him a wink. That was the kind of thing Spencer may have said inadvertently not realizing the connotation, but Yvonne knew exactly what she was saying. Toby disliked her for it. As cheesy as it sounded he wasn't that kind of guy. He'd just met Yvonne and he hadn't gotten over what had happened with spencer enough to let another woman in like that. It was unavoidable like a train he couldn't stop. He thought of sex, which lead him to spencer, which lead him to the idea if things had gone the other way they would be together now raising their child. So many times he had just wished she'd been pregnant. He also wished he hadn't been a complete bonehead about the whole pregnancy scare. Instead of making it about Spencer and what she was going through he had made it about their relationship. Yvonne was still prattling on about what toby didn't know he felt bad but he'd stopped paying attention to her. He walked by a Pringles display and grabbed his favorite kind Cheddar and Sour Cream.

"Don't get those" Yvonne interjected "They are so bad for you"

"Ok mom" he said jokingly putting them back but secretly he was annoyed. He wasn't a child that needed scolding.

"So what would you like to cook for dinner?" he asked "I make a mean lasagna if I do say so myself" he instantly regretted it. Lasagna was on the list of things that always reminded him of Spencer.

"Caleb didn't tell you?" she said her brow furrowing "I'm a vegetarian"

Toby made a mental note to kill Caleb the next time he saw him. What in his right mind had made him think setting him up with a vegetarian was gonna work.

"Well I've been known to make a mean salad in my time too" he said trying not to be the jerk that ends the date early for a lame reason. He was beginning to think he wasn't ready to date at all. It had only been a little over 9 months since he and Spencer broke up.

"Do you have anything against ice cream?" he said half-jokingly.

"Only not having any in the house" she said with a smile.

"Great!" he said "you pick out your fave veggies and I'll get all the fixings for my world famous ice cream sundae."

"Ok" she agreed and he darted off. He had a little basket with cherries, caramel, butterscotch, hot fudge sauce and cherry sauce. He was scanning the freezer aisle looking for his favorite kind of French Vanilla ice cream. Out of the corner of his eye he saw a baby in a car seat in a cart. The baby was in a pink striped onesie her hands covered by the sleeves. She couldn't be more than a few weeks old. The baby started to shake her hands and cry. Toby finally found the ice cream he was looking for.

"Amelia Grace" a familiar voice cooed to the baby.

No it's not possible he thought to himself you just have spencer on the brain. Spencer doesn't have a baby. Spencer is in Europe studying abroad.

He had to know for sure.

"Spencer?" he said and the brunette turned around. It was her!

She looked at him.

"Oh crap" she said in spite of herself.

Oh crap? He thought angrily she is literally standing there with our secret love child she said nothing about and her response is "oh crap"?

"How could you do this to me?!" he cried not caring who heard.

"Toby, I didn't intend to I was going to get an abortion" she said.

"What?!" he cried this new information making it worse.

"But I couldn't go through with it" she added "and then I had no idea how to tell you"

He had a flurry of emotions coming out.

"How old is she?" he asked

"She'll be a month old tomorrow" she said calmly.

"How could you do this to me?!" he said tears coming down his face now. "You knew how badly I wanted kids, how badly I wanted to be there with you, and you cut me out. I missed your whole pregnancy, building her a crib, decorating her nursery with you, her birth, naming her, did you give her my last name or yours, bringing her home from the hospital"

"I was hurt and scared, the longer I waited the harder it was to try and explain." She said wiping tears away. "Do you want to hold her?"

"Can I?" he asked and she nodded as he picked her up and held her. "I can't believe you kept her from me, who else knew?"

"Hanna, Aria, Melissa, and…."

"Spence, I found that cream my mom recommended for her diaper rash." Caleb said walking around the corner. Toby put the baby down feeling anger course through him.

"You knew!" he fumed at Caleb "you've been lying to me this whole time?!"

"No, Toby" Spencer insisted "I ran into him 3 months ago in Boston"

"I told him I was going to put her up for adoption, so he didn't say anything but she came out so quickly and the nurse didn't know and when she put her in my arms that was it"

He was raging on the inside it was twice that she had tried to get rid of their child.

"So you just decided that you and Caleb were going to raise my child" he fumed again "without me"

"Hey Caleb" Yvonne beamed as she walked up to the group. "Oh is this Amelia?" she cooed "She's so cute! She has your ears"

"No she doesn't she's not his she's mine" he said not caring now that he was ruining their date. Before he could stop himself he'd hauled off and hit him square in the jaw knocking him on his ass.

"You think you could just raise my daughter and screw my girlfriend?" he fumed.

"Toby stop, we aren't screwing, one I haven't been cleared by the doctor yet and two I don't have the time for a decent shower let alone a little rough and tumble." She said.

He shook his head. "I'm sorry Yvonne, you're a nice girl but the date is over"

She nodded having put two and two together.

"You call me tomorrow so we can set up visitation, or I'll be calling my lawyer." He said turning and storming off before she could reply.

Let me know what you think so far and if you want me to continue this story.