"What happened Spencer?" Toby asked as he locked the motel door. On Spencer's instruction he'd driven out to a motel two towns away that was both cheap and secluded.
"I don't want to talk about it I just want you to make love to me. Here. Now." she said tears streaming down her face.
"Ok but there's something I have to tell you first, it may change your mind."
"Nothing you could say would change the way I feel about you."
Toby was about to speak when Spencer turned her face towards the light and he could see the discoloration of one of her cheeks.
"What happened?" He asked intently.
"Noel pulled this stunt at my house"
"He hit you?!" Toby near spat.
"No" Spencer said quietly "he made a scene in front of my parents acting like a love sick puppy. Said he hadn't been able to think about anyone but me since the first time we made love."
"Ok?" Toby said not understanding how that lead to a growing bruise on her left cheek. He sat on the bed waiting for her to continue.
"My parents were livid. My father ranted and raved about me losing my virginity to Noel. I just wanted him to shut up so I told him I'd lost my virginity long before Noel and he smacked me so hard I fell on the floor. My mother just stood there, didn't say a word. When my father left she told me how disappointed she was in me. She said I'd ruined myself and no one would want me now."
"I'm sorry Spencer" Toby said not sure how to respond.
"It's fine, just my parents being my parents. This isn't about them. Tonight's about us."
Toby reached for Spencer pulling her into his arms and kissing her. Spencer kneeled to get closer to Toby as they kissed.
"I need you tonight" Spencer breathed as they parted lips.
"I need you too" Toby panted
Spencer pulled away from Toby so she could stand and pull him to his feet. Spencer pushed off his jacket and he unzipped her hoodie as it fell off her shoulders.
"Let's take it slow" Toby said pulling her to the bed.
"Ok" she whispered before they were kissing once again. Toby kissed her, caressing her body as his cock throbbed in his pants getting bigger by the seconds. Toby pushed the bulge in his pants against the crotch of Spencer's jeans and she moaned as she felt it.
"I can feel you" she whimpered as she pushed their bodies closer together, "you feel so good"
Toby pulled Spencer's cotton tank over her head and saw she was wearing a black lacy bra. He kissed her as he grabbed her breasts.
"Toby please" Spencer cried in frustration.
"Trust me princess" Toby whispered in her ear between kisses, "I'm gonna make you soak these sheets"
"I want to" she breathed. She was ready for Toby, desperate for him.
"I told you, we're gonna take this slow" he said as he reached to unfasten her jeans, "I'm gonna enjoy this."
Toby knew all the ways to please a woman, though he wished he didn't. He'd give anything to be a bumbling virgin, Spencer showing him the ropes, teaching him exactly how she liked it. Jenna had held him captive and made him learn.
"Toby?" Spencer called bringing him back to the present, "baby what's wrong?"
"Nothing" Toby lied as he slid down her body, kissing her breasts and stomach, "I can't wait to taste you." He said as his lips brushed along the hem of her panties. Toby grabbed the waist of her jeans and tugged them off her body. Once he had rid her of everything but her lingerie, Toby knelt back to look at her and his dick throbbed again.
"Touch yourself" Toby ordered, "I want to see you rub your clit."
Spencer slowly let her hand move south. "Toby, I need you. I'm so fucking horny."
Toby pulled his shirt off and undid his jeans pulling his pants and boxers down in one fell swoop.
"God, you're so big!" Spencer said with genuine surprise.
"This what you want little girl?" Toby asked stroking his cock.
"Yes" Spencer panted.
Toby climbed over Spencer kissing her as his erection rubbed against the outside of her panties. Spencer whimpered desperate for release.
"You're gonna be mine" he said undoing her bra with one hand as he pulled her up so that she was sitting in his lap, his throbbing dick flush against her center as he lowered his head to suck on her nipple.
"Toby!" Spencer breathed as he skillfully moved their bodies together. Spencer let out a moan, not wanting to let on to Toby that she was about to cum lest he stop the delicious stimulation.
She strangled a moan as pleasure burst through her core and Toby laid her back down. He traced slow kisses down her chest and stomach until he reached her panties. He gripped her hips and kissed her inner thighs before finally pulling her panties off and tossing them aside. She cradled his head.
"You don't have to" Spencer said even though she really wanted him to.
"I want to taste you" Toby looked up at Spencer so she could see the sincerity. "I want to taste you as you cum."
Toby licked her clit first running his tongue up it and then around it. He broke it up with wet kisses. Spencer screamed and begged for orgasm and Toby decided to let her have it. He rubbed her stomach as his tongue circled her clit and brought her to orgasm. After Toby had tasted her salty cum he began his slow kissing ascent finally ready to take the pleasure he'd been denying himself for the sake of pleasing Spencer. He kissed her spent body as he climbed over her.
"You're a real man" Spencer moaned "you've made me cum twice and you haven't even been inside me yet. That's a real man."
Spencer looked like she was about to fall asleep as she came down from her orgasmic high. Toby brought his hand to her center as he gently kissed her cheek.
"You ready?" He whispered in her ear.
"Huh" she asked sleepily.
Toby pushed a finger into her and his thumb rubbed her clit to keep her aroused.
"You ready to be fucked by a real man?"
"Oh yes" Spencer moaned as she pulled Toby to her kissing him.
Toby let out a satisfied groan as he pushed into Spencer's wet hole.
"You feel so good princess" he said as he pumped into her slowly, kissing her face and neck as much as he could while the pleasure mounted. He thrusted harder as the orgasm grew closer, "I'm gonna fucking cum" Toby growled in her ear through his teeth. He shook the bed as he pumped into her furiously.
"Come on Spencer" he yelled "cum for me" Spencer came with Toby's final push before exploding inside her.
The two were breathing hard coming down from their high.
"Can you take it hard?" Toby asked after a few minutes.
Spencer looked at him perplexed
"I'm still horny. I need to fuck the shit out of something."
"I can take it hard. Fuck the shit outta me."
"This might hurt a little"
"I've been fucked hard before Toby" Spencer said.
Toby hooked Spencer's legs up by his arms as he slammed into her hard the way he wanted to, with an unforgiving pace. Pleasure tinged with pain as Toby drilled into her.
"You're amazing" Toby said as buried his boner in her still pumping into her relentlessly. She felt like a rag doll folded up under him as he railed her pussy. Everything below her waist screamed for stop.
"Toby please" Spencer cried. The tone was enough to make Toby slow and unhook her legs as he hovered over her worried.
"I'm stopping. Did I hurt you?" He asked looking at her desperately "you told me you could take it hard."
"I don't want to stop" Spencer said reaching for him to reconnect their bodies. "I can take it hard. I can take it hard for you."
Toby pushed back into her slowly before starting a slow rhythm in and out.
"It won't hurt so bad next time" Toby said as Spencer reached for his waist as he moved in and out. His words made Spencer realize this was how he liked to fuck and she was gonna have to let Toby do it and get used to it.
"Give it to me harder Toby" Spencer pleaded as Toby speeded up. Spencer took deep breaths as he pounded into her.
Toby groaned as he got close. The big one was coming.
"You're my fucking princess." He moaned in her ear. "I don't cum until you do. Cum for me princess."
"I can't cum" Spencer cried
"You can because I'm not gonna stop fucking you until you have."
Spencer forced herself to be in the moment ignoring that rough sex she had not been ready for, and enjoy the steady pumping Toby was doing. She remembered the amazing head he'd given her and almost came at the thought. Finally Spencer succumbed to her orgasm and Toby followed right after.
The next morning Toby woke up first and went to get coffee for the two of them. Spencer was awake when he returned.
"Good morning" Toby smiled as he set Spencer's coffee on the night stand. She gave him a weak smile and he couldn't ignore the wince as she sat herself up in the bed.
"You're sore" Toby stated sadly.
"Yeah" Spencer replied flatly.
"I'm sorry. You said you'd been fucked hard before."
"I have or I thought I had. But you're so big, bigger than any guy I've been with and it hurt."
"I'm sorry. It won't happen again."
"It needs to happen again. Again and again until I can take your dick anyway you want to give it to me."
Toby just kissed Spencer at a loss for words.
"I love you" Toby said when he pulled away.
"I love you too"
"What do you want to do today? We can do anything you want."
"I just want to spend the day loving each other"
Toby kissed her bare shoulder as he climbed onto the bed.
When the coffee was gone Spencer began to rub Toby's crotch waiting for it to stiffen under her hand. Toby relaxed against the pillows as Spencer gingerly moved to pull down his pants. Toby let out a groan of pleasure as Spencer wrapped her mouth around him.
"Baby" he moaned "oh baby"
"Take it all" Toby cried
Spencer grabbed Toby's hands and put them at the back of her head as if to tell him to make her take it all. Toby couldn't imagine that's what she actually wanted so he just gently cradled her head. Spencer pulled away from Toby looking annoyed.
"What's wrong?"
"I want you to shove your dick down my throat when you cum." Spencer said gasping for air.
"Spencer I don't thi..."
"If you want your dick to feel my pussy today, you'll do it."
"Ok" he agreed still cradling her head as she went back to sucking on him. As the pleasure mounted he grabbed the back of her head. He wasn't sure about this but he was going to do what Spencer said. He had several plans that involved his dick feeling her pussy. She was gonna learn to enjoy rough sex. When Toby knew his orgasm was close he pulled Spencer towards him pushing his dick down her throat.
"Oh fuck yes!" Toby screamed and it seemed the sound of Spencer gagging on him made him cum harder. Spencer pulled up kneeling on the bed.
"Lean back Toby" Spencer whispered as she crawled to him, "I'm gonna ride you like pony."
Spencer straddled him wincing as she slid onto him.
"Deliciously sore" she told Toby as she began to move over him. He tried to relax as Spencer rode him but all he could think of was being able to fuck her brains out the way he wanted to. Hard.
"Spencer...oh Spence...baby I'm gonna cum."
"Cum for me" Spencer moaned as she continued to ride him.
Spencer screamed as they both came.
"You're amazing" Spencer said as she flopped down on the bed next to Toby. "I just want to be fucked by you all day"
"The feeling is very much mutual" Toby said with a smirk. He let his eyes roam over her body's as he thought of what they would do next.
"Let's take a bath together" Toby suggested after a few moments
"A bath?" Spencer asked wrinkling her nose at him. Toby chuckled at her response before getting off the bed and walking to the bathroom. He used his index finger to beckon her into the bathroom. Toby turned the water on and climbed in motioning for Spencer to follow. She hesitated standing motionless.
"If you want to feel my dick inside you you'll do it" Toby said mimicking her earlier threat. She smiled and climbed in so she was sitting between his legs.
Toby kissed her shoulder as he let his hands rub her body. Spencer moaned at the feel of Toby's hands caressing her breasts. Toby let his hand dip under the water to find Spencer center.
"I'm gonna make you cum harder than you ever have before." He said fingering her clit. Spencer moaned at the contact, ready for more.
"You like that?" Toby teased.
"God yes" Spencer breathed. Spencer gripped Toby's thighs as she cried out in ecstasy as Toby brought her over the edge.
"I want to kiss you" Toby whispered in her ear. Spencer turned so their mouths touched.
"I meant here" Toby said fingering her clit.
"I don't know if I could take it" Spencer panted.
"Bring it to me" Spencer shakily stood up and turned toward Toby.
"Let's see if you can take it." Toby said pulling her to him. Spencer braced herself against the shower wall as Toby tongued her clit.
"Let me cum, please let me cum" Spencer cried as Toby teased her.
"It's time for me to stretch that little hole of yours some more." Toby said not letting Spencer cum "go lay on the bed face down. Let me see that ass in the air."
Spencer stepped out of the tub and went to the bed following Toby's order. Toby followed Spencer back to the bed.
"You look so beautiful like that" Toby said as he took in Spencer on all fours. Toby pushed himself into Spencer from behind pushing her down on the bed as he pounded her hole.
"Does it hurt?" Toby asked when Spencer pushed her face into a pillow.
"Yes but I want it." Spencer cried.
"Say it again" Toby ordered:
"I want it. Make me cum." Spencer panted.
"Cum for me." Toby demanded.
Spencer cried out in ecstasy as Toby made her cum over and over.
"I love you Toby" Spencer said when the waves of pleasure finally stopped.
"I love you too Princess" Toby said kissing her forehead "rest. I'm going to want you again soon."
The flickering of the tv flipping through channels woke Spencer from her peaceful slumber. She turned to Toby as he sat beside her searching the channels.
"Can't sleep?" Spencer asked reaching out an arm to snuggle up to Toby.
"No" he said kissing her forehead. Spencer looked up at Toby before pushing her hand under the blankets to rub his dick.
"What are you doing?" Toby asked with a playful smirk even though it was obvious.
"It's my turn. I'm gonna show you how good it can feel."
"A hand job? It feels good but I'd rather fuck you."
"I know you want to fuck me and you want to fuck me hard, but before you do you're gonna make slow love to me."
Spencer straddled Toby's lap.
"Rub my breasts" Spencer ordered as Toby's member continued to stiffen. Toby caressed her boobs bringing each nipple to his mouth to suck on.
Spencer slid down the bed and began playfully nipping and licking his manhood.
"Please" Toby pleaded to Spencer. Spencer returned herself to Toby's lap finally sinking down onto Toby's cock.
Spencer began moving herself over Toby. Toby tried to turn so that he could be on top but Spencer resisted.
"No, no, no." Spencer said teasing "slow love making, I'm going to make you do it slow."
"This is torture" Toby pouted as they continued to move slowly.
"When you cum, you'll be happy you listened to me" Spencer insisted. Toby rubbed Spencer's body as they continued to move against each other. "You ready to explode inside me?"
"Yes" Toby begged "I'll do anything to cum."
Spencer wrapped her arms around his shoulders as she bounced and grinded against him.
"Right there" Spencer cried as Toby's dick hit her sweet spot "hold me right there" Spencer shook as her orgasm took control of her body.
"FUCK!" Toby screamed as he finally came. Spencer moved against him extending both of their pleasures.
"I'm gonna milk your balls dry" Spencer said continuing to move. Spencer pushed him down on the bed and rode him.
"No, it's too much" Toby said trying to pull away from her.
"You want me to stop?"
"No don't stop" he yelled. Toby screamed as he and Spencer came again. Spencer climbed off of him, collapsing on the bed.
"That was amazing" Toby panted.
"I know" Spencer said sleepily "I'm glad you liked it."
Spencer had almost fell asleep when she heard a banging on the motel door. Toby got up and answered it. At the door was a guy Spencer hadn't seen before.
"Toby, look, I don't want any trouble and you've always been a good customer but I think the two of you need to leave in the morning."
"I'm sorry Seth. Were we being too loud?"
"No, it's not that. Turn on the TV."
Toby grabbed the remote off the night stand and did what he said. As the tv came on they saw a red banner with white lettering that read:
BREAKING NEWS
"For those of you just joining us, the town of Rosewood is still in shock over the disappearance of sixteen year old Spencer Hastings."
Photos of Spencer flashed across the screen.
"We're coming to you live where the police chief is going to give a statement."
"Spencer left her home, without her phone, without money, and without her car. At this time, we believe Spencer was abducted. Anyone who has any information on Spencer's whereabouts as well as any leads on who may have taken her please notify the authorities."