Glee: You always want what you can't have

Puck had finished his lunch and was checking out some girls in the cafeteria. His eyes spotted Rachel, who had been going out with Finn. He couldn't betray his friend twice. He moved his eyes elsewhere and found Santana. She was too easy; he could get her in a second. Puck's eyes focused onto Brittany. She had already been taken by Artie. His eyes trailed over to Quinn. He already got her pregnant once, he didn't want that again. Besides, she was going out with Sam. Puck turned his head to Mercedes, not his type. As Puck continued to scan the lunch room his eyes kept glancing at one person, Quinn. He couldn't point it out, but she seemed different in his head. She seemed hot, extra hot. His eyes finally gave up and he just started staring at Quinn. He hadn't had this feeling in a while, not ever since middle school. Maybe, possibly, Puck had a crush on her. He quickly shook his head and glanced around. Puck got up and walked over to her table. Sitting with her were Finn, Rachel, Sam, and Mercedes.

"Hey," Puck greeted. He looked around at the table and Finn and Rachel were giving him awkward looks. "Can I sit with you guys?" Puck asked.

"There isn't any room, sorry," Rachel smiled.

"No, it's alright," Quinn said. "I was just leaving." Quinn stood up and walked away.

"I better go with you," Sam commented. He shot a look at Puck. "Finn's told me about you and Quinn before." Sam stood up. "I'll make sure it doesn't happen to me too." He walked away. Puck made a glare at Finn.

"Dude, it happened decades ago, when are you going to let it go?" Puck asked. Finn looked at him. Finn got up. "Rachel, let's go. I don't want him moving in on you too. He already ruined me and Quinn." Finn took Rachel's hand.

"Let's go," Rachel got up and Finn escorted her out of the lunch room. There was an awkward silence between Mercedes and Puck.

"Well, I'm not staying," Mercedes finally got up and left. Then, the school bell rang.

(DURING FOURTH PERIOD)

Puck and Santana decided to ditch and have another make-out session in the hallway. They were leaning against a locker and Santana was on top of him. About halfway through fourth period Puck and Santana heard crying followed the sound of footsteps running down the hallway. They broke apart and saw Quinn fly right past them. Finn was trying to chase her and finally ran out of energy. He stopped next to Puck and Santana.

"What with her?" Puck asked. Santana stepped back and gave him a glare.

"Why do you care?" Santana wondered. Finn turned his head.

"Sam…dumped…her," Finn tried to regain his breath. "Then…he…made her…look like…a bitch," Finn could finally make more words come out of his mouth. "So now everyone…hates her guts," Finn swallowed.

"I already hated her," Santana scoffed. Puck and Finn both shot her a glare.

"Get to class," Puck grinded her teeth. Santana's mouth dropped. "Leave, now!" Puck demanded. Santana stormed down the hallway. Puck turned to Finn. "I'll help chase her down with you." Puck started running down the hallway. Finn finally stood up.

"Alright let's find her." Finn agreed. The two broke apart, Puck took the left side of the school and Finn took the right half.