Now that was great. Gory but great. I’m good with the idea that Ben’s a cop.

That makes sense for me. I kinda figured Ben was his brilliant.

I thoroughly enjoyed your story! The characters were spot on and I loved how you wrote Sam and Dean! Seeing Ben grown up was a special treat. Your torture scenes were intense and painful to read but I loved them (I'm a sicko, I know). Thanks, and I look forward to more stories from you!

I love this ending. I love what outdid with the characters throughout the whole story. I felt like I was actually reading a supernatural novel and not just a short story. Thank you for sharing keep writing and we'll keep reading them

Love from one of the Guinea Pigs.

I am very impressed with this story the characters were true to themselves and the reactions were classic. The story was vivid and I could "watch" it unfold while I read. The torture was just that torture to read, the tears flowed freely as they did when Ben hugged his dad,uh Dean. Congradulations and keep them coming.

Is this really your first long fanfic? Because it's awesome! There's so much to love here. You built the story very well, keeping it interesting from the very beginning and never losing momentum. I loved adult Ben... he's just as I would have imagined him.

You actually brought tears to my eyes in the final chapter.

Thank you for sharing your talent. I hope to see more from you!

Had me glued to the page! I'm a huge Supernatural fan and this author knows the brothers Winchester! Loved the whole story line of Ben turning out to be Dean's son. Loved all the "like father / like son" moments with Uncle Sammy getting a kick out of how much alike they were, even before he knew the full truth.

The torture was a bit much for me. I have a very vivid imagination and the author made it feel real! I prefer to watch horror stories as movies or TV shows. My own imagination is so much more grim when I read a description, than if I watch the same scene on film.

Looking forward to the next work by this author!

That was a really sweet ending to an awesome story! I love the idea of Ben finding out about Dean (or re-finding out) later in life and I love what you did with it!

What? What is going to happen? This is so damn good, I am almost in tears over this! Please update soon!

I'm shocked this doesn't have more reviews - I'm really really loving it.

This is really good!

Nice, but it happened in the 90s not the 70s. John wasn't even hunting then yet and Adam was born in 92 I think.

Wonder if Ben will be able to keep his dinner date with Amber or if he'll run into a certain full of himself, untouchable felon?

I really like! Is this a one-shot or a multi-chapter fic?

I love that Ben is a cop. Who could this mystery dude be? Great first chapter.