Wow, you definitely have my attention! Love your stories so much,

Another fun chapter with Casey and Bennett being all girly. The only thing that made me a little twitchy is the whole thing with Casey seeing something more than just a bond of friendship between Bennett and Sam, and then Sam getting weird when he saw her all dressed up. She's just a teenager, not even late teens. She's a kid (and a confused one at that) and Sam is over 30 by now. Why would Casey even vaguely think that's okay? really hope that's not going to actually turn romantic. Sam would think that her like a little sister but not romance. Fingers crossed on that one as I go forward, lol.

Nice transition chapter. Pissed about Cas still lying to them. That's not going to go over so well when the guys figure out what he's up to! But something occurred to me - Dean mentions he can see the resemblance between Casey and Cas, but back when Casey was conceived, Cas would not have been using Jimmy Novak as his vessel. Jimmy would have just been a kid himself. Not really important, but just something that popped into my head.

Ha! So I had partially hit with a few of my guesses - purgatory and angelic powers. The whole Cas being Dad thing I definitely did not see coming AT ALL. Still want to know about her mom and how Crowley is part of her family, but I'm sure that will come with time. Not sure how I feel about Dean being "in love." Never liked romantic entanglements for the guys, but I'm invested now, so I guess I'll have to see how that plays out, LOL. (For me, the guys' are first and foremost in each others lives - whether in canon or in...other fan fiction - and if there is then a romantic love affair going on, it totally messes with that dynamic, in my experience. But you're good, so I'll give you a chance and see where it goes, LOL!)

Okay...more convinced than ever now that it's something angelic. Either one is hiding out in her or she actually is an angel and doesn't remember. GREAT action sequences here. And look at Crowley being practically heroic! And Casey is not the only one more powerful than previously imagined. Bennett - Wow!

New possible theory about Casey and Dean...MAYBE POSSIBLE PERHAPS, Purgatory. Not likely, but another time when Cas was around and Sam wasn't. (But still doesn't explain why Casey is calling Crowley "uncle".)
And so now we know about Bennett. Interesting backstory there!

I don't even know if you're still checking your feedback on this, but I'll keep commenting, LOL.

Guesses, huh? Well, it's obvious Casey and Dean hunted before - a Wendigo, or Wendigos. Not much of a guess there. The fact that they were together with no mention of Sam means it very possibly happened while he was at college. Or, possibly, while Sam was running around soulless with the Campbells. Actually, since their memories were wiped and I'm guessing Cas had something to do with it, the later time frame is more likely.

As for her telekinetic power, we know from the flashback, it's happened before in a time of danger. Not unlike Sam's back in the day. Could she have been one of the psychic kids who survived and her power stayed dormant? Or, is she harboring an angel unbeknownst to her? Will be interesting to see what's going on.

Oh, man! Great chapter! So much happening and I love Winchesters in near-death danger and pain. (Does that make me a bad person?) Thoroughly enjoying this story even though I'm slow at making my way through it!

Ah...so it WAS in hell after all. And I think Sam now has someone very dangerous upset with him! Not good. The professor's relationship with Crowley is certainly nothing I ever would have expected. WTF is going on THERE? Both in terms of his relationship to her family and her and whatever the heck it is she's holding over him or he owes her or whatever. Hmm...yes, the stakes have definitely been raised here!

Just found this after reading your recent story. Wow! What an intriguing start! I'm a little surprised the guys didn't consider the possibility that the girl was in heaven with Bobby, since they know that's where he is now and she was talking about the pretty lake. I mean, that's MY guess, anyway. But LOVE the whole setup. Very mysterious and compelling!

This was such a great story! I'm sure you could tell from my various reviews, but I really enjoyed this. It really felt like it could be part of the show, in a way that not many fics are able to do. And I've read a lot of fics, so that's saying something! ;) I'm definitely going to go read the sequel now and anything else I can find in this verse! Nice job guys!

Cool fight sequence! And haha, that little note at the beginning about if they would all come out alive? They're Winchesters! Like they'd stay dead!

Lol good luck? For the Winchesters? Maybe in the last possible second, but I'm sure everything is going to go wrong first! As usual, great chapter!

I love Casey and Bennett's growing relationship! Female power for the win! And yay for Bennett showing her spine some more! I like that she only puts her foot down when she really needs to, it makes each time really impactful. It's a great character trait!

THIS WAS SUCH A GREAT CHAPTER! First of all, the romance stuff with our two couples was all so cute! And aaahhhh we finally know why Pestis wants Casey! So Bennett is /a/ vessel, but Casey is /the/ vessel, kind of like archangels. Very cool!