Bloody hell I cried my eyes out in the end... omg you write w so much feel and passion... the end of their lives was so sad and yet so beautiful...the way Killian follows her even in her death was so hard to read but it just felt right...
You take us back to the Roman Empire and makes us believe that Killian and Emma WAS from that time periode... I LOVE Henry's story in this...
I really loved how you wrapped up their story and gave us a glimpse of what happened to them.

now I'm looking forward to dive into your black sails stories... if they have been writen just as much feel and passion I KNOW I'm going to love them... have been saving them for the last M rated fics to read w captainswanthen I'm off to read every T rated fic w my favorite ship)

I read When in Rome and this fic in 24 hours, couldn't put the phone down until I was sleeping ! Honestly one of the best fics I've read ! Very well written and I felt like I was sitting on the edge all through them ! Thank you for providing this fandom with such an amazing fic !
Fun fact : just after reading the last chapter I accidentally pushed a button on my phone and the Bay City Roller's Bye Bye baby started and it felt so appropriate !

good lord I hate you for making me feel like this

This story and When In Rome are riveting. Their longing for each other is beautiful, and I am happy they found each other in the end. This last chapter had me sobbing all over my phone. Good feels.

Ok, I am crying and can't think to type, but this was a wonderful story with such a perfect ending. Thanks for sharing. - RA

I'm crying right now... such a heartbreaking ending... really loved this story!

A wonderful story-thanks so much for posting!

A great story but a very sad ending. But I suppose it was fitting, just... Ouch.

Wow. Just wow. I can definitely say I didn't expect it to end quite like that, but I am still thoroughly satisfied with how it did.

Thank you so much for both writing and finishing this sequel. It has been well worth the journey and the wait. I sincerely hope you continue to write, and I look forward to seeing you in those stories. Cheers.

Welcome back! So excited to finish reading this story. After all that pain and heartache, it's good to see that (maybe) they have an actual future together.

That was a specatular story with anheartbreakingly beautiful ending. I feel lucky to have been able to read it. Great job.

My heart \3 that was such a beautiful, heart-wrenching story. You have amazing talent. I can't wait to read more from you!

I am crying right now. The ending was beautiful, powerful, and heart-wrenching. Thank you for completing this epic story of Killian and Emma.

Jesus Christ. I've read a lot (A LOT) of fan fiction and that's the first time I've cried. What have you done to me?

.god- that was amazing and beautiful! I'm sorry I found this story only today because it's truly amazing and this epilogue really moved me and almost made me cry! You really should write more of this universe, I'd love to read more about Emma & Killian's adventures with Henry on the other side of the wall. Great work, well written and intriguing!