Sniff. This is so sad and - and just... The comparison between Fili and Kili, and Merry and Pippin had occurred to me too, and I love the way you've woven it into this fic.

I thought them similar too! I'm glad someone else noticed

AMAZING. This is perfect! Incredible job, thank you for writing!

Gandalf's pain and sorrow here are ageless, endless, as he sees the same story playing itself out again with nothing he can do to stop or change it. You can feel his weariness and it fits so perfectly with what shows on the screen.

Poor Gandalf. Poor Kili Fili. Poor Dis.
Wow, so many sad feels-in a good way(that sorta doesn't make sense:'))
Thanks for a feelful story!

If you hear a little cracking sound in the distance, don't worry. It's just my heart.

This made me very sad! I sobbed when Kili and Fili died! Like it was bad!

what an amazing way to blend the stories of LOTR and the hobbit.

There are tears in my eyes. TEARS.

This is a nice fic and quite abstract (which is good!). It hit me right in the feels!

It's a very good one...very sad too

Damn feels... and i am now even more convinced thar Merry and Pippin are the reincarnations of Fili and Kili.. how could they not be..
Wonderfully written!

I cried while reading this. This has been my headcanon ever since AUJ was released.