Reviews for Who's To Say He Did It
nightpurr1 chapter 18 . 3/22
The story was good but I wish I haven't read it.
Snape is my favorite character and he died!#
I know it's silly but I really hate it when he dies.
Thanks for your stories but I will not be rereading this one.
rowenasheir chapter 18 . 11/23/2019
I would love to see what happens to what happens to the Know-It-All.
If the horcuxes exist could a sympathiser resurrect LV using the right books?
Would Hermione do it just to prove a point?
Caydence chapter 14 . 4/3/2019
Remus was a halfblood
DemeRain chapter 18 . 12/9/2018
Thanks for sharing.
phoenix-rob chapter 18 . 11/24/2018
Nice story
spnfan2005 chapter 18 . 11/14/2018
love it please write more
Jannafrancine chapter 18 . 10/19/2018
Great story.
Deleteaccountplease11254237 chapter 18 . 10/13/2018
Good story.
Grinsekatze chapter 18 . 9/20/2018
Yup, that's right... Harry doesn't like his teacher, so it's proper to kill him. You know how many teachers would die if that was appropriate? Your Harry -is- a cold-blooded mass-murderer, make no mistake! Boohoo, mean old Snape doesn't treat me fairly so let's just off him! Hello? And you are okay with this shit? Would you also be okay with it if your own children murdered their teachers for this?
Miranda chapter 17 . 9/20/2018
You have been told countless times to watch your "he's" and "his" (and related ss), and that an apostrophe is no substitute for quotation marks. At this point I have to assume that you are too uneducated, or stupid, to understand that concept! Sorry, but your stories are not interesting enough to wade through all your mistakes!
Guest chapter 10 . 8/8/2018
Oops... sorry about my previous review. I ranted in the first chapter about sirius. Im just a little annoyed because people actually try to bring it up when trying to show that sirius didn't care about harry. Sirius has done alot and wasn't always the best thing, but he genuinely cared about harry. Although im still sticking to my point about lupin. I simply cannot forgive a man who puts innocent children in danger because an old mans opinion mattered more to him. Not to mention the fact that when he found out about Pettigrew being alive, he immediately helped sirius against the Trio. I mean, shockingly, there COULD be more than one spy. How was he to know that sirius wasn't a spy as well? I mean, he should have at least tied him up and questioned him. Luckily he had been innocent or 3 students would be dead
Guest chapter 1 . 8/8/2018
Wow. Harrys pretty ungrateful...sirius WAS STUCK IN AZKABAN. It was unthinkable to even think of trying to escape, let alone escape. Plus, he thought Pettigrew died in the explosion and when he found out that he was still alive, WAS JUST BARELY ABLE TO SLIP THROUGH THE BARS and the first thing he did was to VISIT HARRY. plus, after the third book he wrote to harry and EVEN LIVED OFF OF RATS JUST TO BE THERE FOR HIM. besides that though, I agree with what you said about lupin and hermione. Hermione was a know nothing know it all regarding the wizarding world and lupin was a coward who should have honestly never been a teacher. He put his students in grave danger and STILL only cared about dumbledores opinion. I mean, thankfully Sirius was innocent or lupin would have been an accessory to at least one murder, harrys, his supposed "friends" son. When asked about why he didn't tell anyone about sirius being an animagus, he only said that he didn't want to disappoint dumbledore. WHO CARES ABOUT DISAPPOINTING SOMEONE?! A SUPPOSED MASS MURDERER WAS ON THE LOOSE AND ACTIVELY AFTER A STUDENT!
Fallow55 chapter 18 . 7/31/2018
xxxx Kudos xxxx : )
Inu-bitch chapter 18 . 7/27/2018
This is a great story. I was hoping that Harry would tell Dobby not to wash Hermione's clothes or bedding for a week or so to teach her a lesson. All well great story
dhamann7878 chapter 18 . 7/13/2018
Interesting though I think Harry was a little too manipulative
49 | Page 1 2 3 .. Last Next »