This is one of the best stories I've ever read! It's really amazing and I love how you paid attention to every little detail.

Wow! I'm so sorry that I wasn't able to follow this completely through the end, I was last no excuse. You've come such a long way. Wow... I'm speechless. That plot twist with Maglor. It gave me goose bumps even the vision's in the palantir in this chapter. I love it! I love love LOVE this story so much! In fact I might go over this story all over again and then review/pm all the things that I loved here. If I don't, well then I'm going to tell you very sincerely that I enjoyed this wonderful story start to finish.

~JulsaIthil

This took me 8 hrs it was phenomenal I only got three hours of sleep because of this storyLol . It’s not often I find something so well written, funny, and characters were amazing and I loved how you changed the story but still stuck to the books. I’ve read close to a thousand fan fictions but this is one of Mabey five reviews That I’ve left. So thank you for a wonderful if fairly sleepless 8 hours, I enjoyed it immensely :)

Incredible and epic writing!

I hope the crew ended up safe.

Risky and rather foolish strategy not killing the pirates. What’s to stop them from going back to pirating and killing people.

This is interesting. Never read anything about the Khand or its culture before.

Thank you.

Of all the things there are to say, that's the first thought I had and the most important. Thank you. You're an excellent writer with a wide imagination. I loved your Middle Earth. Please take us back there again ... soon.

Stay well. Stay safe. Stay creative.

Thank you.

I am both happy and sad that it’s over. Thank you for a wonderful story!

I’m quite mournful to leave this beautiful story behind now that it has reached its end. Though I do recall being told one time that our favorite stories never really do leave us and that they live on even as we forget, they stay within our hearts and souls.

Given that, I’m extremely happy to have found this wonderful tale and find honor in having read it and go along this journey that held me in its tight grasp and refused to let me go without seeing it to the end.

I am so immensely grateful for this story. I’ve never reviewed anything before but it only took a few chapters of this before I knew I had to say how great this was. I’m blown away by your skill and the story that you wove, so thank you a million times over! Now that this is over, I’m going right back to chapter one to start again, because I’m just not ready to say goodbye!
Thank you Sigebeorn, you’re a wonder! Stay well and keep writing for the sake of all of us! And as you like to say, “catch ya”!

I... I just... yes. I left my real review on the precious chapter. I’m under too much emotional duress to form a proper review. I’m going to lay down and cry for a bit now. My heart is so happy. I’m going to be overjoyed for a while. And later, when I’ve moved on and calmed down, I’ll sit down and read it all over again. And my heart will cry again and I’ll be happy again. Until then, Sigebeorn

Thank you for a lovely story! I'm a sucker for happy ending! Now... to the next one!? Thanks for sharing!

Thank you for writing until the end and sharing it.
I am stuck with a smile on my face after reading this ending :)
Your story has been very creative, which was always exciting to not know what was going to happen, and has a very coherent storyline.
You have a talent for worldbuilding. All that culture you created was brilliant.
Closing it with the palantir was a nice touch. It did bother me a bit that you made it like Galadriel's mirror, but well, it made a good tool to develop the epilogue and it was very emotional.
Thank you very much for all the good moments. Take care.

CRyinG in the CLUB, I can't believe this is OVerR! AGH! But it was satisfying. :)