Omg! i love it! please keep updating the story!

Yay, welcome back! Cas, for heavens sake, slow your roll. Sam’s going to throttle you for even talking to her like that. Pretty sure she’s not the only one feeling the connection there.

*Heavy sigh of relief*
Okay, good. It wasn't Sam-Sam. But poor thing, he's still gonna feel the guilt of it. But gotta love comfort Dean. He's the swetest. Cas...just, easy there fella.

Loved seeing the new domesticated way of life for our group. It's especially nice to see Zoe adapting. But then the ending with Sam came up and it was like 'oh...Ohhhhhhhhh!' and I'm not sure how to feel. I can't decide if I think this is really Sam-Sam or if he's under the siren's influence somehow. Dann cliffhangers.

Whoa! Now that just got a whole lot darker than what I was expecting. But I love the lore you're going with. But my heart just breaks for the poor girl :(
I can't even imagine. But Dean trying to cheer her up with pie? That makes it easier to bare :)

It’s been a good while since I read a new SPN fic but this one has a lot of potential. I’m a sucker for plots that involve the whump but with an OC being the one who’s looked after or nursed back to health. I think either of the brothers could be good love interests in due time. Or hell, if you decided to do a love triangle I’d be down for that too. I love Castiel but at this point I’m not so sure since he’s pretty blunt and sort of hard on her. They’d have to get us to each other a lot more. Anyway, happy writing~

*snorts*
Awww, that was cute that she thought she could outrun them. I like her spirit! And comforting Dean! Gaaaaah, my feels! Gets 'em every time. So she's run afoul some witches eh? Now that definitely makes things more interesting.

Yessss! I’ve been wondering why someone obsessed with occult objects would have her in the basement. And Sam. Such a good guy, so sweet. Love those moments between him and Zoe.

The intrigue is real so far. The curiousity of who/what she is is being played out nicely so far, the pacing over all, so far, has been nice. Also, so far, you seem to have a pretty good handle on the personalities of our known characters. Plus I'm like dying to get updates on your Supernatural watching now because if you're already a Destiel believer and you've only SEEN clips of later seasons...Girl. Not that I would really classify myself as a Destiel shipper [romantically, that is] per say, but...yeah, it's totally there :)
As for what I would enjoy seeing personally, I'm pretty vanilla when it comes to the guys I'm afraid. I like my clear cut angsty Whinchester brother bond, and familiar bond with Cas. As couplings with Zoe go, I've been a Dean girl from the start. I'm a sucker for the whole classic bad boy, 'let me fix you' type. And then big brother Sam with all his gentleness and protective Cas are always a fine choice as well.

Love it! can't wait to see whats next!

I like it. Interested to find out more about Zoe. And I feel like there’s already a sweet little connection between her and Sam. Excited to see where you go with this!