Reviews for You call me Neville, I call me a crappy SI
Corrupteddrake chapter 1 . 7/25
You have it backwards, the Christmas tree was a Yule tradition that the Cristians stole and put for their holiday that they decide to make on the same day Yule was held. Jesus was not even born on the 25th of December and the Druidic tradition worshiped around that kind of tree during that time, because it is a special kind of evergreen, and so one of the green trees at that time of year. Also the whole presents and feasting thing was also taken from Yule. The original Christmas holiday tradition was basically go to Church and pray for the whole day and don’t do Yule things. They did the same thing for all saints day on November first which used to be the day of Halloween, however for that day they just moved the holiday one day forward or one day backward which is the day of the dead on November 2. They threw Easter right on the spring solstice. I am pretty sure the egg thing was a spring solstice thing as well, because eggs sure didn’t come from Jesus. Even summer solstice didn’t get away from the Christians they made a holiday called Midsummer that we don’t celebrate anymore. That day was a dancing plus feasting day.
TheTower1 chapter 1 . 7/25
Noun: wright
a maker or builder
There is no verb form.
So you cannot wright a SI fan fiction.
You mean to write.
Katt31257 chapter 1 . 6/10
Story was going great until he sent Dumbledore his reply letter, so no, I'm done here.
youflesh840 chapter 1 . 4/2
It may be poorly written, but its actually pretty good.
redHussar chapter 1 . 2/27
I stopped reading when MC decided to reward Tonks for being a creepy stalker that thinks that she deserves to know about him.
Mimeomia chapter 1 . 2/14
I liked it but the pace was a bit off by the end.
Some things didn't make much sense like hermione not killing the MC or him conveniently getting those stolen memories. (I was kinda waiting for a house elf rescue or something)
The reasons for the MC to want to go back to his world are a bit weak, sure they made sense in the beginning but by they end it just sounded like 'I want to go home because current entertainment suck balls'
I approve not going for tonks or fleur. Or anyone really.
I kinda wanted at least a one liner regarding tonks like 'we tried but it didn't work out'

Anyway, I liked this enough to read it in one go.
I hope the next one's better
aboulhosncc chapter 1 . 1/22
I think you are a depressed dude man. From what you described there is no reason why you would even want to go back to your own time. There was no family friends or anything. Maybe the idea that you were in a fake world was an excuse but if so then why were you experimenting.

It seemed like you just had these ideas that went nowhere at all All the stuff you could have been doing just meh. I don't see how albus couldn't have done what hermione and take the knowledge either if he was a bad dude, or if he was good guy he would have forced you to have friends etc.

Overall it was a one shot and I read it so you had your purpose. I think you should get help though
karuma012 chapter 1 . 12/19/2019
I kinda liked it...soooo...l will be looking forward for its next update. I wonder what universe he'll end up in? Will his Harry Potter knowledge of magic be any use in the new universe? or will he even be able to keep his Harry Potter type magic in the new world I wonder?
hitesh90 chapter 1 . 12/16/2019
I am with Sanford guy. telling dumbledore was a turn off
quickraziel chapter 1 . 12/16/2019
Well, who could have imagined that preventing the rise of Voldemort would lead to a world wide genocide. It was a good story and look forward to next dimension. Thanks
Doctor Doofenshmirtz chapter 1 . 12/15/2019
I read a tenth of this word wommit and gave up on making any sense of it.
a guy1013 chapter 1 . 12/15/2019
Damn your story is weird and sad and extremely lacks details and you wanting to go home is okay but still not trying bang tonks or a veela is like are you asexual or something ,eh anyways story is okay but not that great cause it lacks any aspect of what a real person would do as you lack fun stuff there and other things
Sandford9687 chapter 1 . 12/15/2019
Got a god bit into it was going great but I had to drop it as soon as I found out your going to have your Si Neville tell Dumbledore everything he knows not even going to bother going any further but for what it's worth I did enjoy what I did read.