Reviews for The Moonlit Samurai Archer
SoraROCK chapter 1 . 8/4
Really good chapter. Are you is gonna update?
guest chapter 1 . 4/6
honestly i also didn't understand why you killed Kirito off when you didn't have to focus on him?
it was a lazy move on your part, Sao comprising 10,000 players (or even more if you decide to increase the number of players?), enough to exploit different characters without Kirito taking all the spotlight.

and why did you replace Klein too? did you kill him off like for Kirito?

this chapter was let's say pretty average I must say, Kirito was a generic Mc, Naruto was far too modeled on him as if Naruto became his clone in some way.
not really what I could call a good start.
Guest chapter 1 . 1/13
Interesting story, I honestly don't care if Kirito is dead, I hope Naruto is paired with Asuna (my favorite waifu)
Louis XII chapter 1 . 1/13
If Naruto is a double champion of kendo and archery, shouldn't he attract attention and be popular with girls?
it looks like you modeled his personality on that of Kirito? Kirito who would be both kendo and archery champion but would continue to remain unsocial or shy?

Shouldn't Naruto actually know Suguha? the beginning seems extremely rushed.

Kushina who pushes Naruto to play in Sao to have grandchildren? really?
what kind of mother would push her son to play videos just to have grandchildren? it seems odd, not very credible.

I find it hard to understand why I replaced Klein with an oc?

I find it unfortunate that you killed Kirito off for an unknown reason? why not have chosen as pairings Naruto x Asuna and paired Kirito with another girl of his harem: Suguha, Sachi, Lizbeth for example?
you could have introduced Kirito but without focusing on him, apart from time to time, there are 10,000 players you know. I don't understand why or even the interest besides of having killed him off.

but I sincerely hope that Kirito's death isn't a half-hearted and lame excuse for Naruto to steal his harem from him.

not much to say about this first chapter itself, apart you have switched Kirito and Klein with Naruto and an oc, too copy-paste on the canon for it to be interesting.
in less good, just like Kirito, Naruto is much more focused on the idea of farming and completing the first floor than anything else.
thor94 chapter 1 . 1/13
yeh! Really surprised to meet each other, especially when they use their real name in the game.
emiyaryo chapter 1 . 1/13
Interesting story, I honestly don't care if Kirito is dead, I hope Naruto is paired with Asuna (my favorite waifu)
Angron chapter 1 . 1/13
I don't particularly understand or accept the fact that you killed Kirito off!
why did you do it? To paired Naruto with Asuna?
Why kill Kirito when you don't have to focus on him or pair him with other girls? like Sachi? Sinon?

I can be wrong but as I think it would not be rather ... for the harem?
if this for this sole reason, it is lamentable.

Naruto is a kendo champion, does he know Suguha who also does Kendo? Suguha also doesn't exist in your history?

who is Clyde? why did you replace Klein with an Oc?
this chapter seemed to be plagiarized from the original novel.

this is only the first chapter but it is average, extremely average.
you just switched an Kirito op to an even more Naruto op. it's as if Kirito before Sao had become both champion of Kendo and Archery! as in the Prince Of Swords where Kirito never gave up kendo and became champion!

dark past? no childhood friend? his mother who pushes him to play only to have small children? this must be the most ridiculous reason I have ever read.
everything leads me to believe that Naruto is only an ersatz of Kirito and gets Kirito harem later.

not what I could a great start, and I don't think it will get better with future chapters.

rather disappointing that the majority of Naruto crossovers are at Mc's expense.
kistunenaruto chapter 1 . 1/13
Interesting to see this take on the crossover can't wait to see more.