This story made me cry my heart out. Minerva is my favourite character and nothing will change that. Amazing story. Albus and Minerva are so perfect, and i love them both, to see them die, breaks my heart

That’s SAD that’s just SAD. Good writing though. Only a good writer can write like this

I have been reading this story all day, cried about twice and I can honestly say I have never been so captivated by a fanfic in my entire life! I absolutely loved this story it is beautifully thought out and beautifully written! thank you so much for this! It was a great read! (and a tear jerker for sure!) Bravo!

I read it all and at first I disliked it greatly but in the end I couldn't help loveing it only a good writer can proke those type of emotions

the story is nice,,really,,it made me cry,,
i just hope minerva didn't die that early. :'(

Quit making me cry!

I don't want to think of my dear Professor McGonagall doing everything for the last time. It pulls my heart strings. And to know that she won't be able to give the next generation her death stare? Why, I think it's cruel.

Yes, I cried.

I can't believe it. My favorite character is dead. *Sob*

Please stop making me cry! I have horrid red eyes and wet cheeks.

I feel just like Crystal and T'ari right now. Someone catch me before I faint.

No! No! NO! Minerva McGonagall cannot be about to die!

No, NO! Mnierva can't die, she just CAN'T! NO!

Thank you for writing that. It was beautiful! The plot was well thought out and the story was well written. I usually don't cry when I read, but this made me. I loved the ending and I thank you for giving me hope through this. My sister was hit by a drunk driver almost a month ago and though she's still alive and in a coma, this is a story that will help me if she moves on. Thank you again!

Aw! That was an amazing story, one of the best fics I've ever read ) the only problem I saw even though it doesn't matter too much, is when hey got married, you said Minerva's middle name was Athena, and when she died, you said it was Katherine. Like I said, it doesn't make much difference. This story made me cry so much that my mom asked me if my boyfriend broke up with me when I went downstairs after reading it! Fantastic story; I can't say enough good things about it. ;) great job !