Sad.

I know this is old, but I had to tell you that its beautiful.

Hauntingly beautiful 3

Whoa. Just, whoa. You almost made me cry... But also you inspired me to write something. Sorta...well, kinda. I mean, the thing I have in mind is nothing like your story, but I thought it up while reading your story.

Whatever, I gotta go write.

That was simply amazing. I started to cry when Sirius died and Remus was so sad. I usually hate stories when Sirius is killed, but this one made it fit. If you hadn't killed him it wouldn't have made the story the same. I am in awe of your writing skills.

Oh!

Oh, you made me cry. That was so bittersweet and beatiful.

that was.

Amazing.

Moving

By far the best one-shot I have ever read.

Thank you for writing it

That was amazing. So beautifully written; like looking into the lives of real people, rather than characters.

And also, you made me cry. That hardly ever happens, so I hope that's enough of a compliment.

Really though, it was perfect. That kind of sad that feels good. Or something.

I wish I wasn't in school so I could cry.

that is the sweetest story ever. you made me cry. you, my friend , well i dont know you, but still, you are gifted with this !

sirius: calm down

me: ah! okay! good story

Very beautiful. Very sad. Good, quiet, understated ending.

I kept reading angsty fic today and though it make me cry and my heart break for Sirius and Remus, I really love this fic ...

"There is another world behind there" ... it got me thinking so many possibilities and I dunno ... it may be just my dream or hope & I got the meaning wrong ...

You are a brilliant author!