What an incredible epos. i enjoyed reading it very much, thank you for all this work. you mangaged to have an amzing story while still showing personality and depth of character in your characters. that is something i really admire, i have the feeling that many authors often choose to focus on noe or the other. i am going to check out your other stories right away

one of the best fanfiction I've ever read. kudos to the author and more powers

I really like this but two things are bugging me (not finished the whole story) a: king Thorin? Hes supposed to be dead. He died at botfa. And b: at the start of the Quest Harry tells a hobbit he doesn't eat, yet at the start of this chapter hes eating cherries...

Wait, so Alex and Lex are two different people? Was Alex that had a wife or Lex?

Umm... the elf meeting was clunky and inelegant. Nice chapter. Though, how can Harry understand the elves?

I could see maybe passing Westron off for English, hence how Harry understood the people of Bree. but the elves are most likely speaking Sindarin amongst themselves. So, is Harry snatching the language from peoples brains?

I'm not all that familiar with Middle earth history or cannon for that matter, but I would think that a village like Bree would not have existed for 2000 years before the LOTR events. But I have no idea regarding this.

A few inconsistencies. Why was Harry wearing night vision goggles in the previous chapter if, as mentioned in this chapter, he has "vampire" vision? Oh and why add "vampire" before everything? "Vampire vision", "vampire-fueled kicks" and so on most likely in the upcoming chapters.

Good story, a few inconsistencies, but I'll read on and see how it turns out.

Simply incredible. Really. A beautiful ending. And the DETAIL, the races and descriptions and everything! Loved it.

Let us all know if you make a sequel or an edit! Maybe even a prequel!

Super histoire.
Grand merci.

Amazing work and lovely plot. I felt bad for Ronald to have fell so low, but I was also happy for Harry to have joined all the races of Middle Earth. And how EPIC were all the battles
This was incredible :)

OMG, Thorin's alive! How did they survive?! What happened to Smaug?! WHoa, I need to know if someday the dwarves will be able to visit Dras Arget and what will their reaction be XD

I'm reading this 10 years after you finished it, can you believe that? I love this story!I only wish that the finial battle between Ron and Harry was a little longer or in more detail..I'm hoping you made a sequel or are thinking about it, because this is one of my favorite stories!You did a fantastic job with it!

Kindly state of this is slash or not

An interesting tale. A sad end for Hermione. She was a faithful friend toHarry for the most part. Ron? I am not surprised.

I figured the enemy was Ron Weasley. Ron was always a jealous git.

I like the story so far, the only thing that im a bit annoyed about is that gay people r always the bad guys, evil mastermind or dark creature in fiction... it kinda makes me feel uncomfortable because its as if everyone by doing so believes being gay is bad...

Anyway the story is interesting so far, i look forward to seeing what they will be doing in middle earth and what itl mean for the battle between sauron and lotr factions