As a native born, and resident, Scot and native Scots Language speaker all I have to say about Hugh McGillion's "Scottish" accent in Stargate Atlantis is that he may have been born in Paisley but the accent he puts on is certainly not any Scots accent that I've ever heard and is frankly kind of offensive to those of us who actually speak Scots!

nice fic, great nietzsche quotes. comparing paul simon as a philosopher was a bit much, but the song fit well enough..

That was so sad and heartwrenching. Great writing

That was such a wonderful 'Sunday'-tag for John and Rodney, very sad but also very true.

This piece was extremely well-written, had excellent characterizations as well as a tremendously true and touching toast for our favourite Scot at the end. In fact, your story sent me sobbing all over again for the wonderful and loveable character of Carson Beckett.

There will never be the like of him again! *cheers Carson*

Oh, this is wonderful. The Simon, the Neitzsche are just perfect. You always seem to be able to channel John and Rodney so well. This is truly needed in an episode, Carson left a great gap in the fabric of the character dynamics.

I always look forward to your work, your viewpoint.

Thanks for sharing.

Amazing... wow.. just... great...

~Red~

Oh, nice. Very well done. I love the quote about a day having a hundred pockets. I've had a few rare ones! They are fantastic.

Thanks for this. It's lovely. :sob:

Wow. Just...wow. That was amazing.

Damn you! You made me tear up. Seriously. That's rare for me.

Thank you for this wonderful fanfic.

It was awesome. :D

And beautiful.

simply loved it (sniff...)

A fitting tribute.

'Tears' Carson will live on and I'm sure that he was watching the pair of them. Excellent.

This is a really nice finish for the very sad episode. Thanks.

OMG I'm still in tears as I write this review! That was beautifully done, just beautifully done! I too am still in morning over Carson and TPTB deciding to kill him! I just well never forgive them! Thank you for this story!

This is an excellent farewell to the character of Carson Beckett.