yeah, so um. I might be sobbing my eyes out.

Sam is and always will be selfish

Loved the fic! I especially loved how u portrayed bobby explaining it's no one's fault but it is hard. U deserve a pie for this one 3

This fic was very well-done and I think you got the characterizations down! It had good writing and I enjoyed reading this!

This was fantastic! I think u really got into their thoughts and i just absolutely loved it.

Great fic!

I just want to say, these lines:

"If you'll always answer, then I'll never call"

is such a powerfull line.
Kinda explain why Dean never call and Sam wont answer in the pilot episode.

Thank you for the great story. and ofc, the interesting afterwords.

Can I just tell you how much I hate this? I hate how it hurts. I hate how they're broken. I hate how it makes me feel broken, too. I hate that it ends without a happy ending, but with the only ending possible. I hate it, and the only reason I can hate it is because it's so good! So good. Your characters and their pain and their heartache and the impossibility of their situation come alive through your writing and its amazing. Wonderful work, thank you for making me bleed ;)

I notice you haven't been writing (or posting) for a few years but whatever. I just wanted to drop some lines to tell that I appreciate the fic unusually much. H/C too often comes without a deeper theme, and tends to be the just-for-kicks variety. It's not wrong, imo, but so often I find myself missing something and wishing more. In this one, "the more" was there.

I may have sobbed, just a little bit, right at the end there.

Every time he calls you, call me.

that was one of the best story i hv read in while.. simply loved it.. all d characters are well written and end was splendid.. enjoyed it a lot..

Just wanted to say this is an incredible fic... The whole "if you'll always answer, I'll never call" was one of the best lines/concepts I've ever seen in fanfic.
Btw, I also loved the part about the toothpaste and shampoo lasting longer... I remember that from when my sister went to college, it was very relatable!
Nice job on this!

This story is friggin' great! It fits perfectly in Kripke's Supernatural. My favorite line is when Dean confessed he can't even look at the food and he can't finish it without his brother, it just represent how they share and been there for each other all their lives. But dude the conversation between Dean and Sam was something else, it's so Dean and Sam especially the promise part! Thanks for sharing! Great Job!

By far one of the deepest Supernatural fanfictions I've read, if not the deepest. This story will stay with me forever...

I just wanted to let you know, this is utterly beautiful. I wish I had something more coherent to say, but everything was great. You captured the characters really well and the whole story was just really heart-wrenching. Breathtaking.