I read this over several days, even during classes. It was so good. And then, suddenly, I realized I wasn’t going to know the end bc the remaining chapters were too few. Truly saddened. I hope you’re ok and someday, I hope we hear more

I read this several years ago and felt inclined to reread it. I wish it was completed, or at least that we had a summary of how you intended to conclude it. Your writing of the characters, the complexity of the politics and strategies, and a compelling plot make this one of the best LOTR fan fictions I have read. I hope to someday know the conclusion to the tale.

I don’t know if you’re even writing fanfiction anymore, but if there’s any chance that you are and you do see this, I absolutely love your story. The emotion you put into your characters and the plot and world you create around them really brings the story to life. I really hope you decide to update this at some point, the cliffhanger you left us on was very suspenseful and I am on the edge of my seat waiting for more!

I'll confess that a lot of the political stuff is going over my head, and at times it does seem to drag on, but the story is amazing. And you have such an amazing cast of OCs.
You have me terrified for poor Legolas and Gimli... I'm really hoping they'll be found soon, though I'm not so sure that that will be the case. And poor Legolas getting cut off from the song again! (Of course the elven name is going to elude me when I need it lol)
Only three chapters left and this hasn't been updated since 2005... somehow I doubt everything is going to be resolved in those last chapters. An update would be greatly appreciated.

I should have known it was too much to hope for that Eomer would remember what occurred a few chapters back, but regardless I'm glad Legolas has his senses back.

Well... I certainly hope Eomer remembers what happens when he wakes up.

I like how you brought in Legolas' longing for the sea, even though it's kind of sad to think about.

This is an excellent start. Your writing style is truly captivating.

If that's not a cliffhanger, I don't know what is. Great job!

I fell in love with story you have captivated me with the way you have written the characters they appear real.

I love your fic so bad
Hurt gimli is so rare and I love it. The plot with the tribes too. It is all so good

My heart breaks that this story os not complete, please as one of your fans, i begyou yo complete this!

This story is a masterpiece of words. My one sadness in this is seeing it has been left undone. This was a wonderous tale and I should have liked to see how it was meant to end.

WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT? WHAT DID YOU JUST DO? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, C'MON, PLEASEEEEEEE, YOU CANNOT DO THIS TO US! HOW DOES ONE END A STORY LIKE THAT? PLEASEEEEEEEE! PLEASEEEEEEEE UPDATEEEEEEEEEEE! :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( I am going to follow this story in hopes that someday it will be continued, but I will not be at peace until that day comes :'(

Now I am afraid to read this fanfiction. As far as I know, it was last updated in 2005, where I was barely 3 yrs old myself, and its not completed. It would kill me to not know the end. I will read it, but I will save it for later...