It's nice to read a story with characters who have depth

awww soo adorable...

I like it a lot

loved your story! i also liked how you ended it! you did such a good job .

Wow, I actually don't normally read LJ but you're definitely converting me! It was perfect, I loved the way he attempted to made her jealous. James's description of the girl he loved was stunning. I love how you compared James to the tree aswell. Very creative! I adored this, and the plot was brilliant!

YOURE SUCH A GOOD WRITER :D

This is soo cute! Ugh! I love it! SO! MUCH!

Wow. This is one of the best JL oneshots I've ever read. So cute! And poignant. And so very... real. Kudos ta you, hun!

Its so beautiful!

i really liked this..the ending was very unique...it didnt end with a kiss like they usually do! Keep up the excellent work!

Wow, I really liked that. Comparing James to the tree was an incredibly creative idea. AWESOME job on this one (:

Oh, and another thing. Not that I think you're ever going to, but if you ever stop writing I will hunt you down and END YOUR LIFE. ;D

~M.

That was great. It was one of those stories that just make you go "aw" at the end and wishing there was more. I loved it and I'll continue reading your other stories.

aw...that was sweet!

i so thought they were going to kiss, and was a bit angry at lily for giving in so easily! but she held her own...:~D

that was one fricken awesome story! i really LOVED it!

I liked this. It was very cute. I'm not going to lie though, I found the part where James was like, "Let's talk about Death Eaters!" kind of funny. I'll admit I laughed. It seemed very random. Good job though!