Reviews for When The Moon and Potter collide OLD VERSION
Remote chapter 6 . 12/16/2016
When you rewrite this, please consider following: The Champions needs to signate contract. When they are under-age that act must been done via their guardians (parents, godfather). When Ministry with Dumbledore puts the age-line before the Goblet, they also silently accepts the selected ones are adult by magical meaning. So for Harry and Serenity when they are forced to compete, it's necessary to declare them magically adult with all duties and more importantly rights. Or they are still underage and then they cannot sign that act themselves and they are opted out. I highly doubt Ikuko/Kenji or Sirius will contra-sign the contract. Dumbledore could sign, but for him it's more headaches than good. Or they could swear an oath before whole Great Hall they didn't put their names inside or asked someone else to do (right to deny) and then prepare for the battle of the raw magical force. Mrs Rowling didn't use this great hole in cannon, but several more aware fanfic authors did and results were funny either for Ministry and Dumbledore.
Harry is the last heir of the Perwell and Potter houses, so when he became more aware of that fact he couldn't been dependent on the Ministry anymore. Let Hermione re-read the rules of lordship and the ancient houses of normal and magical Britain.
FoxyNeko08 chapter 12 . 11/14/2016
What's the name of the new rewritten version?
Sakura Lisel chapter 1 . 10/29/2016
Could you PLEASE put the original first chapter back up? There is no reason for the rewrite to be here, especially since you seperated the two versions into seperate stories already. The original chapter 1 should stay here where it belongs.
shadowhuntersdiva chapter 11 . 10/26/2016
I love the rewritten chapter better than the first few chaptersD _PLEASE UPDATE!
M.v.j.M chapter 11 . 10/26/2016
It's a good start for the new version
giorgosth128 chapter 9 . 10/19/2016
its great stroy pls contine i canot wait for more
DALEKP0N-3 chapter 10 . 7/31/2016
You last updated this a day before my birthday!
Akanemosoa chapter 10 . 6/11/2016
If you feel that what you already have isn't good enough then one thing at a time. Stick with Harry Potter for now and maybe if you manage to finish off Voldy early maybe have a sequel or a filler if you don't that involves Sailor Moons nemesis.
Kathryn chapter 9 . 6/10/2016
ano...where will u be posting these updates...? on a new story or starting after this A/N?
moonchild310 chapter 9 . 6/4/2016
I think the story is fabulous.

I like Serenity I don't like that she has reverted her name back to Usagi. I don't like Ginny but I didn't really like her in the books either. Draco is interesting.
What ideas would you like to see included?

Never any such thing as a chapter thats too long
ScarletEyezInfinit chapter 7 . 5/28/2016
this story is good I hope you still update.
AceStarKnight chapter 9 . 5/26/2016
Ive been reading this mostly because of the high reviews and the promise of breaking the Serena x mamoru meta by pairing her with Harry, so I say fulfill that promise, and do something like expand on the wizarding world around the sailor scouts. Don't focus on them and Harry and their friends, like they are some marry sues/plot bunnies.
M.v.j.M chapter 9 . 5/25/2016
I thinks it's great your re writing this story
The chapter are just long enough and personally I don't like Serena ending up with mamoru I think she should be with Harry and I think that Cedric should not die in this

I hope you get the new version up soon I can't wait to read it
Sailor Tala chapter 9 . 5/25/2016
I don't like Serena with mamoru. I love her with Harry
BiGDeal chapter 9 . 5/25/2016
Probably not the best person to comment on this. All I can say is that the intent of this site is to showcase your abilities and your personal story development and plot. Having a story that you write from your own inspiration is much preferred to trying to write it for other's opinions. Don't be a MarySue or a plot bunny. Satisfy yourself first.
118 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »