What about shelby

I know it's been several years since you updated but just had to say that Rachel's b-day is dec. 18 1994

amazing writing... the best rollercoaster ride... only wish you'd write the Navy arc! you have me wanting more

Please please come back and continue this

Love this story! Wish you would start it up again.

Please write more or a sequel I wanna know how puck does in the navy and how Rachel reacts to the distance.

Just finished re-reading this story again, it’s one of the best Puckleberry stories out. I hope you still plan on completing this even though it’s been about 5 years since an update

I have reread this story so many times and keep finding myself wishing that I knew the ending

Would love an update!

Please write more!

Please please please come back and continue this and other glee stories

Hi - I'm liking your story and I will enjoy reading the rest. Good job.
Just an observation of this chapter I feel like we are losing Puck/Noah's personality. I understand he is growing up and changing but it just feels like he is allowing too many others to push his mind this way and that way.

Like Finn and Rachels opinion on his Dad, their longing/guilt/desire felt too transferred to me. Their situation is not his, their regrets are not his. I understand the missing Dad coming back is added drama but it felt unnecessary and as though there is something being taken away from how strong Noah is and his desire for the baby.

Also like Rachel being upset about him driving away, it seems selfish, it's about his pain and turmoil not having to apologise to Rachel for wanting to cool off in private without an audience. I hope we see more independence and strength from Noah going forward.

PLEASE UPDATE MORE!

Awesome chapter and plot and amazing idea

As I read: lots of thoughts came to mind. Suddenly I thought about how the differences between a fan fiction and a book that is published. I like reading books but fan fictions are more wordy and a lot more freedom. Just a random thought. That slap was epic! :O seriously though. A part of me wonder if Noah told her at that moment because he wanted her to be all mad at him as much as he might be mad at himself for having that moment with Quinn. Her dads are cool :) Out of the Blue List: 1. The baby 2. Getting together 3. One of her dad is dark skinned. I feel bad for Punk having to deal with all that stuff. THe struggle is really. I get trippy about the W (Wedding) and the U (University) word. Rachel is so cute, I just want to her to be in a chibi form and just squeeze her really tightly.