Perfect exactly as I imagined

I know this is old, but the characters feel out of character. The summary also feels like "two guys who are oblivious they are gay suddenly realize they are gay", but plays into the idea that things like bisexual doesn't exist either - Julian I mean.

Is this the oldest fanfic ever?

This fic was posted 11 months before my birth. whoa.

it's funny because when this story was uploaded I was just 2 months old :3
I dont know if you will ever see this.
but I have to say, great writing!

My review on some weird X Files story was incorrect, as far as I can tell you are at least close to the very first story on here! And it's Star Trek, something I actually really like! That's so cool! I wasn't alive when this was published, that's really awesome!

Linley :)

I loved it! But you shouldnt stop here continue it, add some smut.

*hopeful*

Lol. I don't even watch StarTrek and I enjoyed this very much. Not just because it was a yaoi, but also because it was nice and sweet.

Great job! :D

Really, nicely done. A difficult scene written in just the right voice. I enjoyed this very much.

You really captured them. Most people have trouble getting their voices just right, but it was brilliant.

Story #6!

Must read #7!

~s7

this is a very good fic hope you make another chap

Good continuation into the Bashier Garak relationship but the plot was a little weak

Very nice. Good characterization. The lines interfaced very strangely, though, so it's not that easy to read. If you want a beta-reader for this, let me know.

Unlike some of your other reviewers, I don't have any trouble imagining either of these characters being gay. I also like slash, but I wasn't looking for slash when I found this; the reason I read this is I was just thinking about what a good character Garak had been on the show, and I did a search on his name.

Wow, that was just wrong, for so many reasons. Still, it was well-written, for the most part. Certainly interesting. But just oh so wrong. But then again, I hate slash. I just read this story because I was looking for the earliest fics on here.