I cried so much. This was beautifully bittersweet. Thanks for sharing.

Omg this story is so great. It definitely deserves more attention. :)

You write about heartbreak so authentically without all the cliches and melodrama, amazing.

I really loved your story but it just left me wondering what happened 3 years later.

gah! you ripped my heart out. this was lovely. i loved how you had the two time frames, moving in opposite directions. debby, meena, and sully are amazing. i love your ocs. biff seems like a moron and i can't believe that kurt's dating him; however, he was tipsy and we are viewing through noah's eyes and i am predisposed to hate this man.

wow. just wow. seriously, heartbreaking but it did end hopefully. i wonder what kurt was coming back for. to have a real relationship or to see each other but not change anything. and i suppose the point is that it wouldn't have really worked anyway. noah needed to live for himself a bit. seriously, wow. this is amazing. you two are a fantastic team.

Amazing. It's like watching a car crash in slow motion: You just can't look away. That ending was just wow. It's so heartfelt just... I can't describe it.

omg, that was incredible! the format and style of your fic was completely inspired! i normally hate open ended fics (i'm a total sap, and i want my happy ending, damn it! lol), but this one just seemed so...appropriate. fantastic job!

I just wanted to let you know this story in incredible.

Like, super sexy. Which, from me, is a huge compliment.

Thank you.

.Kyle.

I admit it, I cried. It was so beautifully written that I couldn't help it, it really touched my emotions for some reason. Very heartbreaking. I really liked how you carried both parts of the plot at the same time, and also how you included Puck's drawings on Kurt. I especially liked the ending where you gave us a little hope after the total breakdown at the end of chapter 9. Very captivating.

Cheers.

OMG! AMAZING! I totally love this fic. I dearly hope that theer is a sequal where they get together!

(Ok, so this chapter felt big to me)

The tattoo. On his shoulder. My goodness, I had to sit for a few minutes and let it all sink in.

Meena love curiosity

This chapter was intense. I like that blondey's name is Biff! The blonde buffoon. I have to admit, in my head I changed it to blonde Biffoon, and laughed for like, 5 minutes...

Oh cliched Kurt - could be worse, it could have a B instead of a K.

Again, I really liked the plot.

I probably won't keep reviewing every chapter though. Unless something huge happens. But I'm really enjoying reading it, Puck's pride is so endearing, and his peace is well-earned.

This is fascinating, Puck with the markers, and the tattoo parlour and everything...

I wanted to tell you all the plot points I liked, but my brain is melting, so I'll just settle with saying I'm very intrigued - and both anticipating and dreading the next chapter. Poor Noah.

That was great, loved the flasbacks but I always get an uncomplete longing feeling when things are left hanging, so I really hope there will be a sequel to see if that 3 year promise is fufilled.

That was great! It was so much fun to read and you could really feel the emotions. I loved that Puck has a dog named Max just cause Puck needs love.