Reviews for Old Souls
ApoloniaSona chapter 50 . 7/13
This has always been one of my favorite fanfics — I used to check daily for updates.

I saw you started another story, which I've been really excited to read! But I also hope that someday, you'll come back to this one :)
AverageFish chapter 50 . 5/1
This has been awesome. I am in awe. Thank you. Hope you are well.
AverageFish chapter 44 . 5/1
Well done.
Thank you.
AverageFish chapter 35 . 5/1
This chapter is amazing. It made me want to write again.
Your characterisation is wonderful. Your meandering plot is perfect and the pace is perfect as-is. This is human and magical. That is the highest compliment I am capable of giving.
AverageFish chapter 34 . 5/1
Every now and then you write these throwaway snippets that just blow me away. Like eating the chocolate frog heart, or Dippet's head not fitting through the door,
Albus' self-pity after the explosion in Fortescue's.
Tom sat down and ate everything, even the things he didn't like.
Not the tallest pole in the Quidditch pitch.
Your writing is amazing. I hope you still check on your reviews occasionally, and I hope you smile for a moment. This story is a gift, and I am so grateful.
AverageFish chapter 28 . 4/30
I really enjoyed The Vampire Birthday Party. Your characterisation and politics are really really good. Thank you again.
AverageFish chapter 26 . 4/30
Excellent characterisation and development. You don't disappoint.
AverageFish chapter 24 . 4/30
Oh well done. Fantastic chapter. I love the canon world-building and the little details.
AverageFish chapter 22 . 4/30
All of this is amazing but I am too riveted by the story to pause and leave you the deserved review. Just, this is the best fight scene I have ever read. The tension, the madness, the pain and the creativity. Your punctuation (random apostrophes abound?) isn't perfect but your story...
Your story is astonishingly good. I'm glad I stumbled across it.
Thank you for writing. Thank you for sharing. Thank you for publishing in English even though it's not your first language.
Guest chapter 43 . 3/24
why does he have to put up with the little shit time riddle? as if he could do something to help him if he knew the entirety of Charles. anyway, is it because Charles wanted to prevent him from becoming that stupid Voldie moldie?
Guest chapter 18 . 3/23
an arrogant Tom as usual. the little shit thinks he can handle the truth when he can't even handle his abandonment issues. no wonder he got offed by a mere teenager with much less experience and knowledge than him
Guest chapter 17 . 3/23
that's a stupid legend of the house elves. a race condemned for the fault of a few. what about the witches and wizards, they must have been cursed a million times for their mistreatment of all the magical creatures, yet nothing seemed to have happened to them. in my opinion, wizards and witches are similar to the mundanes. their arrogance and pride make them believe they're at the top of the food chain, so they destroy and fear anything different and more powerful than them. probably, that's why they came up with this legend,to cover up their insecurities because they're actually inferior to other magical creatures.
Guest chapter 50 . 2/1
I love this fiction. Please update soon!
Guest chapter 49 . 1/11
Loving the story so far! Just wanted to point out that in this chapter you may have miscalculated the amount of people, it says "only 58 enemies" when they are having the conference thing towards the end, but if I'm not mistaken did you mean 48? (331548). On another note this story is awesome and I hope that you decide to come back and finish it. We will all be waiting patiently for your return.
Guest chapter 50 . 1/11
This is honestly one of the best-written stories I've read in a long time. Just- wow! I absolutely loved it; the characterisation is amazing, the plot is amazing, the writing is amazing, just, simply, amazing! I know that it's almost been 4 entire years, but I sincerely hope that you eventually complete this masterpiece of a story.
1,483 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »