Reviews for Deadliest Warrior
NarniaAndMiddle-Earth chapter 5 . 8/10
I really liked this chapter, even if I didn't think Joan would win; I was very much rooting for her. And looking back, I can imagine Joan's Knights, with better training, vastly superior morale and possibly being willing to die, would overrun the Conquistadors.
One tiny thing stood out though. Cortés was basically a high-functioning psychopath with a gold obsession, commonly known as 'dragon sickness' for fantasy/Hobbit fans or 'gold sickness'. Sure. But how on Earth did he lose the Psychological Health category to a teenage girl who entered a war zone at 17 and heard voices in her head? I looked it up, and apparently based on historical evidence there's been possible diagnoses including: epilepsy, schizophrenia (fairness commands me to concede she probably didn't have schizophrenia, or at most benign schzophrenia), migraines, bipolar disorder (this one was even mentioned on the show), brain lesions, or even bovine tuberculosis (which can cause seizures and dementia). On top of that, she is noted to have had a short temper, which could be explained by any of the factors I already mentioned or come on top of it all.
None of that is to discredit Joan of Arc! She was simply amazing. Just... questioning the wisdom of rating her as healthier than Cortés mentally.
Other than that, fantastic chapter and I enjoyed it greatly!
Guest chapter 60 . 7/17/2019
a guy (George Washington) who lost almost all the battles he has been in which werent many. With his leadership not military strategic might led the continental army to free 13 small colonies with the help of Spain and France, specially with the siege of Yorktown. vs a guy who won most of the 100 battles he was engaged with less men, covering twice the size of alexander the great's military campaign, using strategy freed half a continent with very few british volunteers . and your result is the dude who lost almost every battle he was involved in... I sense extreme bias or an enormous amount of hallucinogenic drugs. Simon Bolivar was 5'6 as described by his doctor, military leaders that met him, and European aristocrats he met. Still shorter then GW, but 5'3 ?, where in the world did you get that from lol ?
DragonTamer01 chapter 29 . 7/12/2019
Really feel like you did not give Richard due justice. After Reynald Of Chatillion, it was Richard the Lionheart who was the man that Saladin feared most. Both Christian AND Muslim sources agree that Richard was the PERFECT foil to Saladin.
Batshark chapter 100 . 7/29/2018
Yeah I know I am super later but this was one of the first fanfics I ever read back when I was a little kid so I just wanted to say thank you for writing this.
Theusgaming chapter 95 . 6/30/2018
Shaka Zulu vs Hamehama the Great
Theus chapter 1 . 6/30/2018
I would like to point out that Hannibal's elephants were given a drug to keep them from running away
Guest chapter 11 . 5/5/2018
you're trying to compare 120 AD Roman Centurion (rankedexperienced) vs a 480 BCE Standard Spartan Hoplite. Fuck you, of course the Hoplite will lose. Because you're fucking retarded to compare it to a ranked soldier with a weapon well ahead of the time of 480 BC. and still behind of that. Roman Centurion must be experienced to get in that rank and a spartan is just a militia called upon by their nation when , fuck you
Guest chapter 100 . 1/27/2018
I can't believe Hannibal hasn't died in any of these battles he's a legend never forgotten
Guest chapter 81 . 1/27/2018
Hannibal got lucky their
So your a fan of Hannibal?
Humberto Gil chapter 60 . 7/9/2017
Bogus, inconsequential analysis. The author needs to analyze how many battles how many victories ... etc etc.
D.J. Scales chapter 16 . 6/13/2017
I'm not surprised with Hannibal winning.
D.J. Scales chapter 3 . 6/13/2017
I'd rather deal with Ivan than Vlad. Still good episode.
D.J. Scales chapter 100 . 6/13/2017
Well this was the best match and Hannibal pulled it off. Well done.
D.J. Scales chapter 23 . 6/6/2017
Well done.
Guest chapter 52 . 5/22/2017
Type your review for this chapter here...
242 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »