Great job on this fanfic, I really am looking forward to an update. :D

Sure would love an update. We still don't know who Shadow is.

You are postivley a gem thorough and through , this story is so wonderful . I adore this story so much and can not wait until you update.

Not quite my cup of tea, but I really don't mind reading more. Your writing has been enjoyable. I'm kinda bothered by the lack of a visible crossover between SW and LOTR, the changed map of the Grey Havens and Undying Lands, the addition of that new kingdom and the change of the history, but Shadow's all right, sort of lovable even, though the deference people put him somehow didn't sit well with me. Don't let my personal preferences stay your hand, though. It was my choice to continue reading, and my choice as well to drop you a line. :) A rather good job on this, I'd say. - Rey

Excellent story I hope that you continue with it

A brilliant story line as well as a good relationship between the characters, I hope the next chapter comes soon! :)

unimaginable power the elves say, gets his ass kicked by a tree I say.

I'm reading Lotr for the first time, too! I'm going to third grade next year. My self-assigned Summer Reading Challenge is to finish it.

Nice story, update soon.

Yay! New chapter! It's wonderful as usual! I'm still dying to find out who shadow is, and what he really looks like! Thanks for the chapter!

Oh, oops! I made a review, but forgot to log in! Wonderful chapter as always! Thanks!

YEAHHHH! You updated! Although to don't blame you for life catching up. ;)

I love Shadow so much... And the Legolas moments were cute. *giggles maniacally*

Please update as soon as possible and this was an awesome chapter! Congrats again. XD

I look forward to more :)

Oh my. Awesome chapter as always! I absolutely love it! Thanks for wanting to beta my new story, hope you like it! I really like shadow, despite that not much is known about him.. You think you know him by now, and then he does something you never expected.. 0.o can't wait for the next one!

You are amazing! I mean mixing Lord of the Ring and Star Wars! ) I love fanfiction, but it is hard to find stories which are book based and where the author actually dares to make changes from the beginning and not only from after Boromiers death. Except for one or two instances the "modern" side of Shadow didnt clash with the tone of the story. I adore Sam and like how you made him a main character. Cant wait to see how the story unfolds and to see if I'm correct with my assumptions on who Shadow is... But it is definitley better that you make us wait!