Very good it makes me so when I can see what is going on, on the page in my head. (excuse grammer & spelling)that's awsome that your learning Japanesse. I'm a sllow learner but am picking up on it. Your a great author I tell all my freinds about you. sorry for not reviwing sooner or with a different story [I just found out how to get it to pop up, yeah] K bye I'm certain you'll be hearing from me agian soon. _ (that's the good smiley not a bad one)

*sniffles* Oh... that was nice... Poor Frodo! *wails* We shall miss him, won't we Sam? *talks to action figure* *low voice* Yes! We will! *grin* Any-woo, this was beautiful...so sad, though. I loved the eyes...thing... *daze*

Aw... SAD story! But it's definitly one of your best! (BTW, dittoes out to Elbereth for the best review ever! Tell Gollum hi for me when ya get the chance, okies? Righto!) Anywayz, the part about Elly and the wagon and loveing Frodo the same way was so good! And no, I don't think that Rosie had an affair with Frodo (although I'm sure there are plenty of sickos out there who would love to write a story like that) and no, I don't think that Frodo and Sam were gay (although there are plenty of sickos out there who already have written stories like that.) This has got the be my longest review here ever, so I'm going to stop ranting now, and if anyone is still reading this, you are now my officially new best friend! lol I'm not even gonna say keep up the good work, cuz I know ya will!

How in the world was this HUMOR? I was near tears when Sam started explaining about Frodo...VERY well done ::bows:: Keep up the incredible work!

I love it again! The stuff you write is so touching...and it was so sad when Frodo left Middle-Earth! I'm glad there's a little Frodo still left...

*ugh* I so know what you mean, I'm sick of all those people thinking there is more than friendship between Frodo and Sam. Sure, in the books, Sam does state that he loves Frodo dearly, but that is not what Tolkien was implying by that statement. People have to stop putting their own gutter-thoughts into Tolkien's work.

Anyway I don't think it implies Frodo had an affair with Rosie to say that Frodo Gamgee looked like Frodo Baggins. Elanor looked like an Elf; doesn't mean Rosie had an affair with an Elf. :-)

Good story, and very cute. I think Sam is very sweet.

awesome!

Aaaw... wow. Very nice. And as usual (I'm beginning to see a pattern in your work!) a perfect ending. Bravo.

This is a very good story. I liked it alot. One thing that doesn't really matter, Sam told Frodo that he was going to name his kid Frodo, I believe, right after he had Elanor, or right before. (I'm not exactly for sure.) But anyway, in the book Sam was like "I was going to name her Frodo, but she's a girl..." (I know, it's pry not even close to what the book said.) And then Frodo suggested Elanor after that flower. So Frodo already knew. Sorry,I just felt like saying that... to make myself sound smart, but I don't think I succeded in doing anything other than annoying you with this review. But I througly loved it and I don't have one problem with your story at all,for the record. Continue your superb writing, please!

Well Phoebe, I agree with you. Who in the world could ever think that hobbits are gay!

Gollum:Let me find them my precious, let me eat the sickos who ever thought such a thing!(crawls on the top of the computer) Sickos! Sickos! We hates them forever, my precious!

Me: Down Gollum. Anyways wonderful story!

Gollum: Great story but sickos write bad reviews. WE WILL EAT THEM! ALL OF THEM! (runs to the door, opens it and runs away screaming ''EAT THEM! EAT THEM''

Well I should leave. Gotta go catch Gollum before he does something.

-Elbereth

YAY! _ I loved it, of course! I'm gonna try and start catching up, so I thought I'd start with one I'd already read. It flows nicely now, and it was great! As always! Keep it up!

~EC

Awww, how sweet... Frodo.

Frodo: what?

Phoebe: The kids name.

Frodo: Ah, that...

It was kind of funny that Frodo didnt understand that Sam was going to name his child after him. I just kept giggling and giggling. And I am glad that there still was some Frodo Bagginseness left in Middle-Earth. The world wouldnt be the same without him.

And damn! *covers* We know that Frodo and Sam are not homosexual. Grrr... let me kill every singel human being who says that your stories are slash! They are not and that is what makes them so beautiful.

Hugs Phoebe

thats good, but you do know of course that Sam's second child IS called Frodo. Frodo Gardner. Ok good. so anyway, cool.

*Sniff* I Think I'm going to cry!

That is SO Sweet I love it! I love Frodo and Sam and no I don't think they are *Cough* homosexual *Cough* So No I won't turn you into anything Unnautral...lol

Bye Tilly

That was so cute! I loved it! It was just so adorable...just my kind of story. ;)