Aw,so cute and sad ! I love it though ! ( Not like in a mean way though if that makes sense?) :-D , Well Done And Thanks .

I CRIED SO HARD this is amazing 3

It's so sweet, but then sad when you think about it. This was very well written. Great work.

I don't normally go for OC fics but this is really cute. It seems quite plausible actually and I love the mix of the honourable, courageous Captain Nicholls with a cute, sweet side that is very realistically woven. The sap in me really enjoyed reading this. It is wonderfully written. Thanks for the squishy feels overload.
A. Hatter.

aw this was beautiful, i loved it !

What a lovely oneshot! :) It was very sweet yet with a underlying sadness as well. Now whenever I'll hear that song by Maroon 5, I shall immediately think of James Nicholls :')

Thank you for such a great read!

Wow! I enjoyed this a LOT! I actually haven't seen War Horse and don't know anything about it, but this was amazingly well written. The descriptions were vivid and definitely painted a picture in my mind. :) There was the perfect amount of sweetness and smut in this. Hehe, I loved the ending bit where James pretended to need directions to Barbary lane to get to talk to Georgiana. xD Great job on this! You're an amazing writer.

read this on my iPod an hour or so ago.

Can I just say "Awwwww!" ? haha I loved this. It was so sweet and loving but with a nice and dark undertone to it. I never really thought of James as a married man in the movie but this was such a cute little insight to his character from a family standpoint.

You have succeeded in giving me a dose of feels. Thank you! You have reawakened my love for the character that is Captain Nicholls. xD Off to work on my own fic now...

-Sirius

this was really cute and yet so sad because we know what happens to James :'( and there was a baby too! *sobs* I liked this, well done :)