Ben was standing outside. The air was frigid, even though it was in the middle of summer. He was about to be found out for his crimes.

Lilly glared at Carley first.

"You know what, we shouldn't kick you out. We should here what everybody else thinks."

"I think you should chill out." Ben blurted out.

"There's no way it's Carley," Lee butted in, "It's someone else. Maybe even someone who's been sneaking into our camp!"

Ben looked away.

"That's ridiculous," Carley responded, "That's what you think?"

"Yes."

"Alright then. Kenny?

"I don't know! Fuck! Just stop!" Kenny said.

"Well your vote counts for you and Katjaa." Lilly decided.

Ben was finally losing it.

"We don't need to do all these VOTES! What do I need to do for you to trust me? I'll do anything!" Ben panicked.

"Stop panicking. Seriously Ben, you need to stop and take a breath." Lee told him.

"Do we need any more evidence that THIS?" Lilly showed.

"FUCK EVIDENCE! Stop treating him like this!" Carley yelled at Lilly.

"Shut up Carley! I've heard enough out of you! Kenny, what's it gonna be?"

"Just give me a damn minute!"

"Ben, you have until that walker is dealt with to tell me it was her and not you!" Lilly instructed.

"Stop it, your torturing him!" Carley demanded.

Lee sighed.

"Tell her, just do it Ben." He told Ben.

"Lee, Jesus! Who are you right now?"

Ben understood that Lee wanted to stop the argument, but he didn't want to risk getting kicked out, or even death.

"Tell her what? She'll kick me out of the group!"

"We won't." Lee reassured, "We'll understand."

"Tell me. NOW" Lilly commanded

"There. I got him." Kenny sighed.

Ben's time was up.

"Please." Ben begged, "Let's just back in the RV."

"That's not happening."

"You think you're a tough bitch, don't you?" Carly began to insult Lilly, "Like nothing can hurt you, but you're just a scared little girl. Get the fuck over it. Take a page from Lee's book and try to help someone for once."

Kenny killed the walker and strolled up to the group.

"Now, what the fuck's the problem?"

Before anyone could answer, Carley turned around and was shot in her head. Lilly looked at Carley's dead corpse and turned to Ben. He froze. Why did it have to come to this?

Lee slammed Lilly to the RV before anything else could happen.

"DROP IT." Lee directed.

Lilly obeyed.

"Holy fuck…" Kenny muttered.

All sounds drowned out from Ben's mind. He crouched lower towards Carley's body. Ben knew Lee was fond of Carley. Now she was dead, and it was his fault. Ben covered his mouth, and a single tear fell onto her corpse.

"I'm sorry…" Ben whispered.

Ben stood up, regaining his hearing and looked at Lilly warily.

"What are we gonna do with her?" He asked.

"You're not coming with us." Lee said.

"I'll die out here." Lilly pointed out.

"I don't care." Lee frowned.

"You're a murderer Lilly, you can't have you with us!" Kenny supported Lee.

"I'm a murderer?! You've been with Lee this whole time!" Lilly objected

"I don't care what he did before!" Kenny retorted.

"You know?!"

"Yeah, he told me. I don't give a shit."

Ben heard small portions of Lee's crimes when he told Clementine.

"If we keep you with us, how long until you get me?" Kenny demanded.

"I was trying to protect all of us. I don't have anything left." She sobbed.

There was a long silence.

"Get in Lee. Let's go you guys." Kenny said.

Ben looked at Lilly one last time before entering the RV, now a vehicle of shame.

[Trans.]

Ben had the same dream again. His sister's screams, the voice. It was all there. Ben had been awake all night. When the RV stopped, Ben lugged himself out of there. He was shown a freight train. It didn't seem to have any damage on it, hopefully it still worked. Ben turned to Lee for distraction.

"Why don't you and I have a look around?" Ben asked Lee.

"Yeah. Everyone else, relax. Clem, stay close to Kenny and Kat, okay?

Ben walked over to the train's ladder.

"Lee," Kat asked, "If there's anything to drink, a dining car or something, I think Ducks a bit dehydrated."

"It's a freighter, hon." Kenny replied.

Ben sighed, and tried to climb up. Guilt seemed to weigh him down, because he struggled to get onto the platform. Lee walked up to him.

"What would you have done with Lilly?" He asked Ben.

"I don't know. Left her. I've never seen anybody kill someone like that before."

"You've seen a bunch of other stuff by now." Lee stated.

"Yeah, but not like that."

Ben's real answer would have been that he wouldn't do anything. He would be dead.

"Was it you?" Lee suddenly asked.

"Not this again…" Ben whined.

"Was it?"

"NO."

"Okay, then. You happy you stayed with us all this time?"

"Yeah." Ben happily said.

"You sure?" Lee questioned.

"It's with you guys, or dead. I woulda died out there in the woods, just like my classmates."

"You think this is better?"

"Yeah, of course!"

Lee sighed and walked into the boxcar. Ben slid open the door and saw the remnants of a bedroom.

"Whoa." Ben breathed.

"Somebody's been living in here." Lee said as Ben climbed in.

"Yeah man. Shit. Think they're gone?"

"I hope so, but this looks recently used. Keep a look-out and have your guard up."

Ben jumped out of the boxcar, examining more of the train.

Soon, Ben saw Lee walk to the engine room and followed him.

"We got one." Lee whispered, "Walker. Sitting the chair. We got him."

Lee slowly crept up to the walker and hit him on the head with a wrench. It limply fell forward. Lee and Ben sighed.

"Suppose we ought to look him over." Lee said.

"Yeah."

Lee grabbed the walker and pushed him off the chair. It loosely fell onto the floor. Ben noticed a hole in the window next to him.

"I don't think this guy came back…" Ben suggested

"Christ…"

Lee looked over to the control board.

"That light is flashing." Lee observed.

"Push it!"

"Push it?"

"Why not?"

"Are you fucking serious?"

"Here, look." Ben said as he pushed the button.

Ben heard a hissing noise coming from outside.

"It's just the brakes." Ben concluded.

"Alright, I'll give you that one." Lee said.

Ben smiled. It was the first time he smiled in months.

"This fucker works?" Kenny asked as he walked in.

"Seems like it." Lee replied.

"I'll be damned." Kenny stated. "How the hell do we get it moving?"

"I don't know, ask Mister Amtrak over here." Lee teased.

"No clue." Ben answered, dragging the dead body out of the control room.

Ben walked back into the room.

"Ben, if you could keep an eye on the girls and Duck, I'd much appreciate it. I'm gonna make sense of these controls." Kenny told him.

Ben merely nodded and went outside. At least it seemed like someone was trusting him now.

[Trans.]

Ben had been sitting quietly on a log for a long time. Some guy named Chuck gave him some candy. Ben only ate a little bit. He couldn't muster up the appetite to eat anything, even though he didn't eat for days. Chuck exited the train, Lee following him.

"You met Chuck!" Clementine said as she ran up to Lee.

"Yeah…I did." Lee said back.

"It's so nice to meet someone normal for a change." Katjaa added.

"He gave us candy, Ben too!" Clem revealed.

Lee looked at Ben for a brief moment. Then looked a Chuck.

"What's your game, man?" Lee asked.

"Keeping alive" Chuck answered.

"That's not bad."

"I like it."

"You've met Kenny?"

"Sure did." Chuck sat down, "Man shared my love of the road."

"That's for certain."

Chuck walked over to Katjaa and Duck.

"I'm sorry your son's not feeling good."

"I appreciate your concern." Katjaa thanked.

"Well, with a little TLC, I'm sure he'll be fit as a fiddle in no time. And I could offer y'all whatever I got, although it ain't much."

"Thank you. We'd like to do the same." Katjaa said.

"Why don't we hold off on…" Kenny began.

"Stay with us. We'd like the company." Katjaa finished.

Kenny didn't respond and walked over to the train. Lee followed him. They talked for a while before approaching the group.

"We don't have much left, so just gather what you have." Kenny told them, "Let's go."

Ben was the first to jump on the boxcar and sat near the door. When the train started, everyone looked at Katjaa and Duck, wondering what to do. As usual, Ben was the probably the only one who felt scared.

They all sat silently for an hour.

"Got to be hard on ya, eh?" Chuck said. "Three adults, taking care of three kids; no disrespect son." He turned to Ben.

Ben just frowned at Chuck and turned away. He hated being called a child.

"There were more of us." Lee stated.

"Dead get them?"

"Yes."

"…Shame."

"Lee come here please, get Ken!" Katjaa said.

"What's-" Lee began.

"Would you get that off his face? My hands are full here."

Lee wiped off some blood off of Duck's face.

"He's out of time." Katjaa said, "We need to stop this train."

"Okay." Lee replied.

"Please."

Lee walked out the train and towards the control room.

"This is all my fault." Ben confessed again.

"Don't say that Ben, it's nobody's fault." Katjaa said.

"But I-"

Ben saw Clem looking at him, as if she was pleading that it wasn't him. Ben sighed and buried his head in his hands, sentence unfinished.

Everyone sat quietly for a long time, before the train slowly skidded to a stop. As always, Ben was the first one out.

Kenny climbed off of the train, looking down.

"Ken, I think it's time." Katjaa said.

"The boy's been bit, in case you haven't figured that out." Kenny told Chuck.

"What do you need?" Lee asked.

"I…I…" Kenny trailed off.

"It's time to…" Katjaa sighed, "This is not possible."

"What are we gonna do?"

"We can't allow him become one of those things."

"But what if he doesn't?" Kenny asked.

"Kenny, I love you very much. I love our son more than life itself. I need you to hear me. What are you saying, about him not turning, is foolish."

"But-"

"No."

"There's…Come on Kat."

"If you think of one, you let me know."

"Isn't there some sort of pill, something we can just give him, something-?"

"Stop."

"He can just drift off to sleep, right hon? I mean Jesus, this is our son!"

"I KNOW. But it's…here," Katjaa pointed at her head, "or nothing."

"Well…fuck…just…who then?" Kenny said, "You want me to?"

"You don't have to."

"I'll do it."

"No. You don't have to."

"I'll do it." Lee jumped in.

"No," Katjaa disagreed, "It should be a parent."

"No parent should have to do something like this." Lee argued.

"Lee's right, Kat. We can say our goodbyes and…just let that be it"

"I don't know…Lee, you'd be doing this family a great service." Katjaa looked at Duck for a long, sad moment.

"Why don't we take him into the woods. So Clementine doesn't have to see." Katjaa finally decided.

"Yeah." Kenny whispered.

"Give us a moment to say goodbye?" Katjaa asked Lee.

"Of course."

Kenny and Katjaa walked away with Duck, and Clementine walked to Lee.

"What's happening?" She asked.

"I'm going to take care of Duck."

"I thought he was going to die." Clementine replied.

"I'm going to make sure he's okay."

"How…he's bitten."

"By making sure he doesn't come back."

"Oh."

"Look Clem-"

A gunshot rang from the forest.

"What the-"

"No!" Kenny yelled.

"Ben! Take Clementine into the train! Go it'll be fine!"

Ben carried Clementine into the train, Chuck following them.

Ben knew Katjaa was another person that he killed.