Author's Notes: I'm going to be changing certain things with the storyline. You can think of this as starting in the 5th Season right around the time that Katherine is about to die from old age.

Damon Salvatore's eyes were silver blue.

Bonnie had never noticed any of these things before. She was too busy glaring at him to actually take in how peculiar his eyes were. They were not as bright blue like Matt's were. They were different. A unique blue that you didn't see on just anyone. Only Damon Salvatore carried those eyes.

But there was something different to them now.

When Damon opened his eyes after his body laid for a week decaying, she expected them to still have that haughty humorous glare in them that made the beauty of his eyes disappear. Haughty and humorous were gone now.

Bonnie felt herself be pushed slightly and watched as her best friend, Elena Gilbert, run over to Damon, her vampire boyfriend. Elena grabbed Damon everywhere. Touching his body for wounds that couldn't be seen and grabbing at his face.

Bonnie let out a sigh and glanced over at Stefan who had a small smile on his face. He gave her a nod and Bonnie finally let the smile form on hers. Today was a good day. She brought Damon back and even though she didn't like him majority of the time she was actually happy to see those eyes again. Elena's cries and denial after his death hurt her. She could no longer watch her friend be in pain. She also thought Stefan was close to going off the deep end and she did not want to meet the Ripper.

She let out a laugh and smiled when Damon looked at her. His pale blue eyes looked at her curiously. Bonnie frowned. She expected quirky eyes or humorous eyes. Maybe even a glare. But curious was not something she imagined.

Something was wrong.

"It's good to have you back, Damon" Stefan said. Damon glanced over to him and gave him a quick smile before looking at Elena who continued to hold his face.

"I missed you so much, Damon" Elena cried out with shiny eyes.

"Hey, little bro" Damon called over to Stefan and but continued to stare at Elena strangely. "Katherine?"

Elena stiffened and Bonnie froze. She knew something was wrong.

"What is going on?" Caroline asked as she grabbed Bonnie's arm.

Bonnie's eyes widened.

"Damon," Elena said as she took a step back from him.

Damon continued to stare at Elena with amused eyes before he glanced at everyone in the room. Tyler who was on the couch a moment ago, now stood with one arm bracing the armrest. Matt and Jeremy were slowly walking towards them cautiously.

Bonnie didn't know what she did but when Damon looked at her, eyes trained on her, she knew something was wrong.

"It's me, Elena" Elena whispered.

"Elena?" Damon asked. He looked around the room. "Why are we back at Mystic Falls?"

Elena shook her head as she continued to step back before she bumped into Stefan's chest.

"Wait a minute. Are you telling me he doesn't remember anything?" Matt asked.

"If you're not Katherine then who are you?" Damon asked disappointed and then frowned. "Never mind, you're not Katherine. So, what do I care?"

Stefan tried to hold Elena in place as she shook.

"That's not Katherine. That's my sister Elena, Elena Gilbert." Jeremy said.

"What's the weird boy talking about, Stefan" Damon asked. "God, I'm hungry"

"Here's a blood bag," Matt said as he cautiously walked over before he threw it half way. Damon caught it and looked at the bag before rolling his eyes.

"Now, why would I eat that way? I'm vampire, idiot" Damon said.

One moment Damon was across the room and next he was in front of Bonnie. Bonnie jumped and clutched her chest.

"Jesus, you scared me" Bonnie cursed and then glared at Damon.

"How about I eat the hot chick instead?" Damon said and Bonnie's eyes went wide. She didn't know what surprised her more; Damon wanting to bite her or him calling her hot.

Before Bonnie's mind could linger on that thought Stefan grabbed Damon.

"What is wrong with you? Do you really not remember?" Stefan asked.

"What am I supposed to be remembering, little bro? There's a girl that looks exactly like the love of our life Katherine. And it looks like we're in a after school special. What am I missing here?" He asked Stefan and then glanced back over at Bonnie and winked.

She felt a tug at her sleeve. She continued to stare at the pale blue eyes that stared into her green ones before she turned to Caroline who tugged on her sleeve.

"What happened? Did something go wrong with the spell?" Caroline asked.

Bonnie glanced back over to Damon who was watching them and she shook her head.

"I don't know." Bonnie blurted out. "I did the spell the same way it's written in it book. It said it would bring him back from the other side. I don't know why he doesn't remember"

"You're a witch?" Damon asked. Bonnie ignored him as she tried to wrack her brain of what could have possibly went wrong. She followed every step.

"Bonnie," Jeremy said and she glanced over at him before shaking her head.

Everyone was looking directly at her including Elena whose eyes glistened with tears. She had been crushed when Damon was stabbed by Katherine who was giving her last final "fuck you" before she passed from old age after being turned into a human by Elena. When Elena came back to the Salvatore Boarding House to see Damon's cold body on ground she refused to move from his body. Bonnie couldn't imagine how she was feeling now to see that Damon did not remember her.

"You know, I kind have a thing for witches" Damon said as he walked over the blood bag that he threw on the couch. "It's something about all that hocus pocus soft that gets me all hot"

Bonnie watched as he drunk from the bag and she frowned in disbelief. Was he…

"Dude, are you flirting with her?" Tyler asked surprised. Bonnie was wondering the same thing.

"What's it to you, preppy boy?" Damon asked. "Are you her boyfriend?"

Damon's eyes danced with amusement but his tone said something else.

"Hey, that's my girl right there" He said as he pointed at Caroline who looked annoyed. "That's the boyfriend there"

Damon's head snapped over to see where Tyler's finger was pointing at and it landed on Jeremy. He laughed.

"Weird kid. Seriously? You have to have better taste than that, little witch."

"Omg," Elena kept muttering to herself repeatedly. "I have to go. This can't be happening. I can't watch this"

Elena hurried from the room and Caroline followed after her but not before glaring at Damon.

"What's her problem?" Damon asked as he threw the empty blood bag across the room.

"Elena's your girlfriend, Damon" Stefan said as he shook his head. Damon quirked his head.

"Seriously?" Damon asked. "I know I'm in love with Katherine but would I really go as far as dating someone who looks like her?"

Stefan continued to shake his head and turned towards Bonnie. Bonnie threw her hands up and ran them through her hair.

"I don't know what went wrong, Stefan. He shouldn't have lost his memories."

"It's okay. We'll find a way to fix this,"

"But Elena-"

"Elena will be fine. At least Damon isn't dead now-"

"Wait I was dead?" Damon asked now on his third blood bag.

"We'll fix this. Don't worry, Bonnie" Stefan said reassuringly as he grabbed her shoulders.

"Bonnie," Damon said. "Bonnie. Bon-Bon. I like Bon-Bon. I think I'm going to call you that"

Bonnie glared over at Damon. She would definitely find a way to fix him.