I'm so sorry for the long delay for this chapter guys! A lot was going on and I needed a little time before getting back into writing. Just to say this now, this story won't be much longer. Ranging from three to five more chapters at the most. Also, most of them will probably contain/center smut, like this chapter. When I first started this, I honestly didn't think it'd go past four : ). I thank you to all the people whose read this story! Let's begin!

Chapter 5: Trying something new

While Natsu was a little embarrassed to say, this had to be the first time he had ever entered Lucy's home past the doorway. Sure, she had gone to his home several times but not the other way around. A lump had lodged itself in the salmonettes throat, keeping him from speaking. Everything had slowed. From taking the first step into her living room to rove the well-kept home from the door creaking behind him until it finally locked. When that click hung in the air, time returned to its normal pace as did his breathing—which he forgot how to do for a moment. Man, he's so anxious, isn't he?

"Well... Welcome to my humble abode," Lucy said.

"Nice place," was all Natsu could say to refrain from being silent. He didn't want to give away that he was nervous. Not like the beads of sweat or the cracks in his voice told her or anything. Lucy simply laughed instead of poking fun at him, given that she understood how he felt. It was the same for her anytime she entered his home; though, it got easier the more did so. Although, for Natsu, he hadn't set one foot in her living room. The blond kicked off her shoes as Natsu followed, taking a seat on the couch per Lucy's instruction as she went into the kitchen to get them something to drink. Something Natsu desperately needed or he was going to overheat.

The man took a nice, deep breath in a feeble effort to calm himself, but all that accomplished was figuring out they used the same air freshener: vanilla. Natsu gave a defeated sigh before sinking into the leather couch he occupied closing his eyes for a moment to think back on the date they had earlier. Otherwise, from nearly getting kicked out because some asshat had the balls to flirt with Lucy right in front of him and Natsu being forced to shove all thirty-two teeth down his throat—the day had gone pretty well. Didn't sound like the day went well, did it? Trust me, it did. There weren't too many dilemmas during their evening out. He had the cash; he had the jokes; he had the spots. Had to thank Gray for that when he got the chance. Gray could be a pretty cool guy when he wasn't such a dick.

"Here you go," a light voice brought him from his daydreams as he found Lucy standing in front of him, brown turtleneck a bit tight on her—which he didn't mind of course. Dark skirt showing off those wonderful thighs he had the pleasure of getting between at least twice this week. Shit... Now, instead of being nervous, he was horny. Either one or the other. Might as well be horny instead of tripping over himself. Natsu just hoped she couldn't see his boner. Now THAT would make this shit awkward FAST. Natsu shoved those thoughts aside to retrieve his much-needed water from the blond who started to tap her foot waiting for him to take it. Natsu gave her a 'thanks' before downing nearly half of it in one thirsty gulp. Christ did he need that...

Lucy just laughed before making herself comfortable besides Natsu, her boyfriend. She internally giggled at the thought. Her boyfriend... Lucy repeated it time and time again and it never—and will never—get old. Trying to avoid being spotted, Lucy maneuvered her eyes to observe Natsu who was much tenser than normal. Guess being in her home as her boyfriend got him a bit scared. To see the usually outspoken and loud, obnoxious Natsu so simmered and quiet was a rare sight indeed. It gave her the time to marvel at how handsome he was. While his childish face is cute, the rare time he got serious showed her that he wasn't just some child, but a young man ready to head off to college. Speaking of college, Lucy didn't recall asking him which college he planned on attending. She already decided hers, which was Pegasus University to study fashion; she hadn't heard a peep about his future though.

"Hey, Natsu, what do you plan on doing after high school?"

"To be honest, I haven't thought about that. I was thinking that...I'd go to whatever school you went to and try to find something that interested me there." Natsu said; while the idea was sweet, she couldn't just say yes and thank you.

"Come on, Natsu, I know there's something you want. Well, besides me anyway," Lucy joked.

"And if there isn't anything else?" Natsu queried, giving her a peck on her forehead before saying, "I don't know what I want to do later in life. For now, I want to focus on the present and spend time with you. So, my goal is set up to attending the same college you'll be attending. Whichever one that is..."

Lucy pouted then. "Natsu, I told you at the restaurant...!"

"O-Oh, right! U-Um... Pentigus?"

"PEGASUS!" Lucy corrected, later huffing, "Honestly! It's like nothing you care about is food! Did you even LISTEN to me when I was talking? Or were you to busy stuffing your face."

"W-Well, I listened to at least some of it. You've gotta give me credit there." Natsu said with unbelievable pride.

Lucy sweatdropped. "Yeah, you definitely deserve a gold medal," she said with a wooden face."

"Oh, come on, Lucy—I'm sorry, alright? Don't be upset." Lucy just puffed her cheeks, crossed her arms, and turned away like a child throwing a tantrum. While Natsu didn't mind seeing this side of her—which he found incredibly cute—he didn't want anything to spoil their evening. Getting thrown out for starting a ruckus was enough—and it wasn't even his fault! Natsu just sighed and decided to wing it, turning Lucy's head to face her to place a soft kiss on her pre-puckered lips. For a few seconds, Natsu remained, parting to see her face had lightened a smidgen.

"Is that better?"

A pause.

"Maybe...just another one?" Lucy blushed. Natsu just laughed at the childish Lucy before pulling her in for a firmer kiss. The chocolate eyed blond relaxed then, kissing him for about a minute or so before they withdrew. As if in slow motion, their eyes open to find a twinkle in the others, more so in Lucy who had been meaning to request something of Natsu for some time now. But was not the best time? What if he said no? Lucy shuddered at the thought of Natsu being disgusted by her and wanted to just forget about it, but... She wanted to try it. She wanted to try it so bad just thinking about it got her searing and aching.

She gulped.

"Natsu, can we try something...a little different tonight?"

"Try something different? Lucy, I didn't bring any condoms with me so..."

"That's fine," Lucy's cheeks turned an even darker shade of red. "We don't need that tonight. I was thinking that tonight we could do it from the, uh, other...end."

"Other en—? You mean anal?" Natsu's eyes widen with fear in his voice when he asked, his heart racing when she nodded and ducked her head to avoid his gaze. "I-I'm not too sure about that Lucy. I mean...I'm not small and we haven't even done anything there."

"I know that, but I just...want to try it tonight," Lucy cupped his hands with hers. "Can we, Natsu? Please?"

Natsu would be lying if he said he never wanted to try the other hole. Just thinking about fucking her from the back got him all fired up, but... He knew that the first experience wasn't the most pleasant. Days ago he had brought it up to Gray who told him that it does hurt the first time and it will take time to get used to it. He also said it depends on size but he was just fucking with him with that diss. Lucy had also done her own digging around and asked the only person who had no problem divulging her sexual activities with her: Erza. Shame and Erza don't go together very well and mixed just about as well as oil and water. Someone like Erza wasn't a dime a dozen, but she still loved her all the same. The redhead went into explicit details about her first anal and she said, while it did hurt, she grew used to it during the coitus. Then again, this was ERZA she was talking about. Way tougher than her. Compared to Erza, Lucy was nothing more than an infant. Still, she trusted Natsu and wanted their relationship to develop. This would be the first step.

And with that gaze, he couldn't say no.

Natsu, clothes thrown along with Lucy's to the other side of the room, knelt behind the kneeling Lucy who's ass stared him in the face. While he had seen her in this position several times, the arousal he felt was different than before. It was no surprise Lucy liked being taken from the back, but he had never, not even once, stuck his finger or his dick into her anus. God, she had the nicest ass... So smooth, creamy, blubbery, and curvy in all the right spots. Soon, his cock began to ache as all he wanted to do was jam himself into her and fuck the sweet ass before her, but he knew he couldn't. The trust she had in him was heartwarming and irresistible; it made his cock ache. Even then, he refused to simply shove his cock into her without some kind of preparation. They didn't have any kind of lubricant either so he neede to take care of that bit himself.

The salmon-haired man gently peeled her cheeks apart and started off with some kisses and licks around her pucker, tender and passionate, relieved when she finally began to relax. Once Natsu's muscle found its way into her clenched hole Lucy bucked against him, rolling the sheets into her fists while she sighed in content to his kind licks, loving how he mimicked a cock sliding back and forth; however, a cock couldn't curl like his tongue did. The tangy flavor of her ass, while it took a bit to get used too, Natsu enjoyed it all the same. It tasted like Lucy after all. Natsu guided his trusty index and middle finger to please her clit, rubbing slow circles around her engorging button that made her flow like a waterfall before inserting his digits. Lucy moaned melodically to his movements, telling him she loved the way he treated her and that she wanted more. Hearing those gorgeous moans of hers caused his cock to ache and become unbearable. She had that kind of effect on him.

He retracted his fingers from her cunt and used the juices he managed to accumulate to lube her up for his entry. Natsu was careful when he inserted his fingers, halting even at the slightest squeal from Lucy until he finally reached his knuckles. His fingers slid smoothly along her fleshy corridor, concentrating to maintain his speed—and more importantly—not hurt her.

"Natsu...! Natsu! Ah...! Please, I need you inside me...!" Lucy pleaded. Natsu felt her anal ring clench around him, and from the sound of her voice and the flow of her pussy, her climax was nearing. He had her right where he wanted her. Natsu couldn't help but smirk a bit to the hot pleas of his girlfriend as he lined his cock up to replace his fingers. It took time, effort, and a lot of patience, but he succeeded in getting just the tip in. When Natsu attempted to proceed further, he came to a halt when she tensed up and waited until she relaxed to further insert himself into her posterior. This might've been the most constrictive he's ever had to do since his days in dance class.

"Oh...fuck!" Shit, he was enjoying this way too much. He nearly lost control of himself for a moment and bit the inside of his gum to remain sane.

"Natsu...all the way...! Push it all the way in...!" Lucy huffed, her sheets between her teeth, muffling her speech. At her command, Natsu continued to enter her almost instantaneously, inching in to fill her with his wrist width cock. A mixture of pain and pleasure poured from the moan of Lucy Heartfilia. When the pain began to overwhelm the pleasure in her voice Natsu stopped, only for Lucy to buck against him in order to finish the penetration. She didn't care if it hurt. What she wanted...

"Fuck me, Natsu, please..."

That begging... It was her pleading voice that made him cave. Natsu moved at her will, both hands holding onto her hips like a wheel, rocking her benevolently, gingerly, trying his damndest not to speed up which earned a hiss from Lucy, so he gave her what she wanted and went a bit faster. Natsu loomed over her, his chest against her back as he dropped a hand to the cunt he left unattended to finger her sweet cunt. Shit, she was so tight! Fingering her pussy and palming her saturated nub only caused her to clench around him. Unconsciously, his speed picked up a tad, just enough for the bed to rock a bit, but not too much to cause her any pain thank god. Natsu felt her tensing around him, working his fingers to the bone, fondling her wonderous breasts while simultaneously twisting and pinching her rock hard nipples, striving for an orgasm. Lucy's eyes rolled behind her head, the blond unable to prod herself up any longer as she fell onto the mattress, her ass still hoisted up in the air for Natsu to fuck as he saw fit. She moaned and grunted into the now saliva wet sheets, gnawing and stuffing some of the soft cotton into her mouth as he began to bulge.

Natsu cried out her name then as she did the same, the two nearly coming in perfect unison with Natsu being just a second late. Even while pumping his hot vanilla cream into her ass pipe and feeling their act of sex finally tax his physical strength, the speed of his digits only increased as he milked her drooling honeypot for her sweet nectar. He debated whether or not he should pull out yet, but this was the first time he had ever entered her without the use of latex. The urge to remain inside her and even enter her pussy roamed his brain, but after another moment of thought, Natsu pulled out. When he pulled out, an odd sound was made in the silence as his thick cream immediately drained out of her now stretched anus.

Lucy adored the heat that filled her asshole. This was the first time she ever felt his come...and it was a glorious feeling indeed. In fact, she might get addicted to this comforting warmth that made her feel so full. The blonds rear collapsed on the bed with her as she turned on her back, panting, chocolate eyes twinkling as she reached for him. Her lips moved, but she was much too tired to even speak, though, Natsu could read her lips and eyes and joined her, smothering her wet lips, muffling her moans and groans into his mouth. For what felt like ten minutes they laid there, her hands traveling along his broad, sweaty back while he shamelessly fucked her mouth, taking her mouth away from her several times to use for his own needs. Lucy dropped a hand to jerk of his semi erected cock that still leaked with the thick come that stuffed her ass, loving the moans she received when she rimmed his sensitive tip, finding it cute when his hips bucked to her action. A gasp left them both when they finally gave the other reprieve, the spit bridge formed snapped instantly when created and fell on their chins.

"Thank you, Natsu..." Lucy brought her boyfriend to lay beside her, lacing her fingers in her salmon hair.

"Don't mention it," Natsu smiled, removing the strands of hair that stuck to her clammy face, giving her one last peck on her lips before bringing her into his body. "I'd do anything for. I was a little worried, but it worked out. You took it like a champ."

"D-Don't say it like that," she whimpered.

"Alright, alright, don't get so bent outta shape," Natsu threw an arm around her, smiling, "I love you. I love you so much..."

"I love you too... You don't know how much, Natsu..." Lucy smiled, watching the man's eyes flicker before the snoring began. She leaned on her elbow and watched the man snooze away, absentmindedly running a hand along his arm. Now...they were one step closer. Maybe...they won't need any sort of latex anymore.

Hope my attempt at anal sex didn't bore any of you. Again, forgive me for leaving you all for such a long time. I've been busy. Also, thank you for the people who liked my other smut! I hope you enjoyed this one just as much as you enjoyed the last. Ciao! I'll try to be quicker—I promise!