Path 1: Vs Lucy and Cana

I don't own Fairy Tail; anything I use is property of its creator, Hiro Mashima.

As Natsu and Happy arrived on Tenrou Island to begin the first part of the S-class exam, they knew that they were in trouble. The goal of the first exam was to pick one of the paths that were on the island and deal with whatever was down that path. There were eight paths labeled A-H and each path would lead to 1 of 6 possible results. You would either have to fight one of Fairy Tail's S-class mages in Erza, Mirajane, or Gildarts. Two paths lead to fights between examiners, and a final path which was free. "Natsu, what do we do?" Happy said nervously as the pair arrived at the area where the paths were. Thanks to their fellow guild mates, Paths A, B, F, and H were gone leaving four paths remaining. Fortunately for Natsu he knew exactly which path to take.

"We're gonna take Path E, Happy." Natsu said confidently.

"Why?" Happy said in disbelief at the quick answer.

"Ain't it obvious, Path E for Erza." Natsu said happily as he made his way towards Path E.

'Natsu, that would be way too easy if path E was Erza. The master would never do that!' Happy thought to himself as he followed his impatient partner/father. Path E turned out to be a large cave with fireflies all over the place in order to light it up and rock formations all around. As Natsu and Happy made their way through the winding path one thing was fairly obvious.

"Aww man, Erza's not here." Natsu groaned as they came to the end.

"Yeah and I think this is one of the battle areas." Happy mentioned as they noticed the green sign with the symbol for battle on it.

"Yeah, I wonder who our opponent will be?" Natsu wondered innocently. There were 3 teams that he knew were ahead of him: Evergreen and Elfman; Levy and Gajeel: and Freed and Bickslow. What was odd was that he was pretty sure he beat the other teams so he was curious who the fourth to beat him to the island was.

"Either way you're in trouble, Natsu." Happy teased knowing his partner extremely well and some of his burdens that he faced.

"Yeah, you're probably right, Happy." Natsu sighed realizing that he was going to likely face somebody he didn't like. Putting aside Gray and Loke, which would be the best matchup he could ask for, the only possible teams left, featured people he really didn't wanna fight. He liked Wendy, so taking her out would be tough. Juvia is a tough matchup for him and Lisanna being her partner didn't help matters. Then there was Cana and Lucy, which was a mess in its own way. If Natsu was being honest, he'd rather fight Gildarts at full than face off against Cana and Lucy. Until his opponent arrived, Natsu decided to relax on the side of the wall.

(Scene Skip)

A few minutes later Natsu could hear the sound of footsteps coming which meant his opponents had arrived. Unfortunately for Natsu his hearing told him who his opponent was which made things even worse. "You gotta be kidding me!" Natsu groaned as he noticed who was arriving.

"What's wrong, Natsu?" Happy wondered. A few seconds later Happy got his answer when Lucy and Cana appeared. Lucy was in a white floral bikini while Cana was in bikini with green and orange stripes with blue armbands on her side

"We're fighting NATSU!" Lucy exclaimed. Since they were teamed up in virtually every mission Lucy was well aware of the power of her teammate and knew that she was helpless.

"Yeah, this isn't good." Cana groaned. Having known Natsu for as long as she had, she knew he was strong. He was probably their worst matchup of anybody in the group because he had the speed to deal with Cana's cards and Lucy didn't have a spirit that could beat him with Loke gone. Sure Aquarius could help but Aquarius was tough to deal with

"Damn, why did it have to be you?" Natsu groaned as he put his bag to the side so he could fight the girls. This was going to be a real pain.

"What do you mean by that?" Lucy said angrily.

"Nothing Lucy." Natsu groaned as he prepared to fight. This was

"Crap, what do we do? Natsu is too fast for most of my cards and none of your spirits outside of Loke and Aquarius are strong enough to beat him." Cana cursed.

"Cana, please give up. I don't wanna fight you." Natsu pleaded. Ironically enough it wasn't Lucy and her spirits that Natsu was bothered by but it was Cana.

"Natsu, she can't give up. Cana has to become S-class." Lucy pleaded with her friend and teammate.

'I know, Lucy.' Natsu groaned internally. He didn't know the best way to do this since he knew all about Cana's burden.

Lucy went straight for her golden keys and there was only one option. "Open Gate of the Golden Bull: TAURUS!" Lucy shouted out. Natsu looked on happily as the spirit of the Golden bull appeared. The large bipedal cow and his familiar axe appeared.

"Lucy, why are we fighting Natsu?" Taurus questioned. It was obvious that the Golden Bull would be surprised but then again Lucy should've prepared them for the battle better.

Lucy knew that it was going to be difficult but didn't have time to explain everything. Which meant it was time to use Taurus's weakness against him. "Come on big guy. I need you." Lucy teased emphasizing her large breasts. Taurus was a pervert so the act quickly got him fired up.

"MOOO! To protect these nice bodies I'll fight anybody!" Taurus shouted as he charged Natsu. It was a good thing that Natsu was perverted.

"Good job, big guy!" Cana shouted out. She knew that her only chance to get Natsu was when he was distracted by Taurus attacks.

"Nice idea Lucy." Natsu smirked as he charged Taurus equally. "But it's not gonna work against me" Natsu smiled as he quickly dodged the axe from Taurus and used his flames to quickly charge Lucy hoping to end the battle without too much damage.

"What the…!" Lucy exclaimed.

'Shit!' Cana thought to herself. Natsu was far faster than she realized.

"Sorry Lucy, but I know the weakness of a celestial spirit mage like you. All I need to do is attack you and directly and it doesn't matter who you use." Natsu smirked as he nailed Lucy in the stomach with a powerful magic enhanced fist. He didn't use his fire but the attack was enough to knock Lucy out in one hit.

"Dammit" Lucy cursed as she fell to the ground.

"LUCY!" Cana exclaimed as her partner fell to the ground.

Natsu quickly grabbed the unconscious Lucy and brought her to the other side of the cave so she couldn't get in his way. "It's your turn, Cana." Natsu growled. He really didn't want to hurt Cana but he had no choice in this case.

"I won't lose so easily, Natsu. Card magic: Lightning!" Cana shouted out.

Natsu easily dodged the attack. "Come on Cana. You know as well as I do you can't beat me. Just surrender." Natsu groaned.

"You're gonna have to knock me out like you did Lucy. I can't quit!" Cana shouted. "Card magic: Flood!" Cana shouted as a large flood appeared in front of her and charged Natsu.

"Fire Dragon's Roar!" Natsu shouted as he cocked his head back for his signature attack. As the attacks collided the room filled with stream and it provided Natsu an opening to knock Cana out the same way he did Lucy. Using his sense of smell he quickly found Cana in the mist and charged her hoping to end the fight with a single punch like he did Lucy. 'I'm sorry, Cana.' Natsu thought to himself as he came through the smoke and cocked his fist back.

"Shit!" Cana cursed realizing that Natsu had appeared from the smoke and was about to finish her. She couldn't use her card magic so Cana moved slightly hoping to use the only defense she had…. her boobs. Natsu's attack hit Cana's large breasts and sent her flying, but because of her girls she was still fine.

"Damn it!" Natsu cursed knowing that attack wasn't enough and that things were about to get very irritating.

"Geez Natsu, that hurt." Cana groaned as she got up unaware that her top was gone.

"Cana, your boobs are out!" Happy shouted out much to Natsu's annoyance.

Cana looked down and realized that she was exposed. "Damn it, Natsu! Did you have to do that?" Cana groaned.

"It's not my fault your boobs got in my way. I was trying to avoid hurting you. Why do you think I haven't used my magic the whole time?"

"What do you mean trying not to hurt us? We're in the middle of the exams!" Cana shouted as she prepared her next attack

Natsu groaned because it was a secret that he wanted to keep but maybe this was his only chance to end the battle peacefully. "Cana, I know all about you and Gildarts." Natsu admitted stopping Cana in her tracks.

"What! When did you find out!?" Cana exclaimed unaware that the secret was out.

"I found out last year after Mira's S-class celebration. I was the one who took you back to Fairy Hills and you were talking about it in your sleep." Natsu admitted sheepishly.

'Damn it. Of all the people to hear that it had to be Natsu.' Cana cursed internally. Cana started drinking a few years ago for multiple reasons but one of the major ones was the fact that she wanted to use the booze to hide her scent from Natsu. After all, nobody in the guild knew about her relationship to Gildarts outside of the master and even though Natsu acted dense she knew he was smart enough to figure it since he was so close to her father. "So why didn't you say anything to me?" Cana wondered.

"Because I realized how much you must hate me. I mean Gildarts is rarely here and when he comes back he spends almost all his time with me. If I were in your shoes I'd certainly be angry."

Cana tried to protest but couldn't deny that Natsu was right. "Natsu, I don't hate you. Yeah, it's hard watching my dad spend so much time with everybody else, but I understand it. Gildarts is like a father to not only you, but Gray and a few others. That's part of what makes Fairy Tail so great!" Cana said bashfully.

"No kidding, but now it's time for his real daughter to show what she can do. So I'm gonna forfeit this battle, Cana. Just promise me you'll become S-class in front of your dad." Natsu said happily. He wanted to be S-class but not at Cana's expense.

"Thanks, Natsu." Cana said happily as she walked over to the dragon slayer and hugged him. Of course it was at that moment that Cana remembered that her top wasn't on and that she had just squished her boobs against the dragon slayer's chest and her nipples were right against Natsu's. "Oh shit! Sorry." Cana said sheepishly as she moved back.

"It's okay." Natsu said bashfully failing to hide the blush on his face.

"Hey Natsu, why are you so red and what's with your pants?" Happy teased having noticed something odd about his adopted father.

"What are you talking about Happy? My pants are… shit!" Natsu cursed as he looked down and realized what happened.

"Do you have a boner, Natsu?" Cana said in shock.

Natsu was angry that Happy pointed it out but since he was trapped he had to admit the truth. "I can't help it, Cana. Any guy would get hard with your boobs pressed against them." Natsu groaned.

"Wait a minute, what about Lucy, Erza, and Lisanna? You see Lucy naked all the time and I'm sure you've bathed with Erza before. Plus Lisanna is your unofficial bride." Cana wondered. This was certainly something she didn't forget.

"Lisanna's boobs aren't as big as yours and I didn't know about girls as a kid, so I didn't think about Erza being naked." Natsu admitted bashfully.

"What about Lucy?" Cana wondered.

"Lucy's gorgeous and of course I think about her. Luckily for me I've seen Gray strip so much it's easy to force the images away till I'm alone in my house." Natsu admitted bashfully.

"So what about me?" Cana said bashfully. Of all the things she expected to deal with today, this was certainly not one of them.

"You spend all your time in a bikini and I have to carry you on my back with those knockers of yours late at night. What do you think, Cana?" Natsu groaned his boner twitching proof of his arousal.

Cana couldn't believe that she had this effect on Natsu and it stirred something else in her that she didn't expect. "Well, then as thanks for you forfeiting, how about I take care of that guy? I'm sure the trip must've been brutal." Cana said lustfully.

"O-Okay…." Natsu said in disbelief. Cana was right that the trip was brutal because of the girls in bikini's and he wasn't gonna turn down a chance for sweet relief.

LEMON START:

Cana went over to Natsu and started out by wrapping her arms around his waist and smashing her lips against his. Unlike the first time when her breasts pressed against him his time Natsu didn't hold back and clashed tongues with the tan skinned brunette. 'Man, who would've ever guessed this would happen?' Cana thought to herself as she clashed tongues with Natsu. After a few minutes the pair had to stop in order to get air.

"That was pretty good, Cana, and I'm glad you don't taste like booze for once." Natsu said with a smirk.

"Don't be a jerk, Natsu." Cana pouted a bit ashamed at how much beer she drinks.

"As tasty as your lips are, I want something a bit different." Natsu smirked as he reached down and latched onto Cana's left breast with his mouth.

"AHHH!" Cana moaned in pleasure as Natsu's tongue slid over her large melons emphasizing her nipples which quickly stood up with glee from Natsu's work.

"Now for the right one." Natsu smirked as he switched his tongue work to Cana's right breast eliciting a similar moan.

"How… did you…. get … so good?" Cana moaned as Natsu continued to play with her body.

"You can thank your dad." Natsu smirked deciding to simply fondle Cana's breasts as he kissed her collarbone and neck.

"Wh-AAAH!" Cana moaned as his efforts made her shiver.

"Once every few months I go buy your dad's house to dust it off and make sure that everything's in order. I found some porn mags of his a year ago and I decided to learn some things." Natsu smirked before resuming his work.

"Just… imagine… if he knew what you were doing with his little girl?" Cana teased hoping to get a chance to relax.

"I have a feeling he would approve." Natsu smirked as he continued to play with Cana's breasts with his tongue and slipped his right hand towards Cana's pussy.

"Wait a minute, Natsu. This is about your pleasure." Cana protested as the dragon slayer slipped his finger past her bikini bottom and into her pussy making her howl in pleasure.

"Well Cana, I'm making you feel good so when we really get fired up, I can feel really good." Natsu said with a grin on his face. While his fingers fondled Cana's pussy Natsu's tongue played with her breasts like they were his favorite meal. The brunette was helpless and after only a few minutes of fun she reached her limit.

"Natsu! I'm going to cum!" Cana screamed out.

"Good. It means we're close to the real fun part." Natsu smirked as his ministrations continued.

"I'm cumming!" Cana screamed a minute later as her juices flew into Natsu's right hand as the card mage slumped to the ground.

"Natsu, I think you overdid it. You do want her to pass right?" Happy teased.

"Oh. Right." Natsu said sheepishly. Remembering something he noticed while he played with Cana he made his way towards the other side of the cave to find a now conscious Lucy with her fingers inside her bottom no doubt playing with her pussy.

"Yo Luce" Natsu teased.

"Hey there, Natsu." Lucy said bashfully. She forgot about how good Natsu's nose was and now she was going to pay for it.

"How long have you been up?" Natsu teased.

"Around the time Cana mentioned your boner." Lucy said blushing. She was trapped and she knew it and was at the mercy of a suddenly amorous Natsu.

"Well I was gonna let Cana have some fun, but I realized that I have to leave her with some strength to finish the exams." Natsu smirked.

"What does that have to do with me?" Lucy said nervously. Her nerves grew when Natsu slipped out of his pants and shirt to reveal his naked form.

"Well I thought you could have a turn." Natsu said happily.

Lucy was torn and she knew it. She had a few fantasies involving her and Natsu since their friendship began and this was as good a time as any to act on them. "Okay." Lucy said sheepishly. Happy didn't seem to care and nobody else from the guild would know but them.

"Hey Happy, can you grab my sleeping bag?" Natsu said with a smile.

"Sure!" Happy replied from a few feet away

"Huh?" Lucy said in confusion wondering why he'd grab that.

"Well, you don't want your first time to be on a cave floor do you?" Natsu smirked. He also wanted to give Cana some time to recover.

"Oh. No I wouldn't." Lucy said frankly.

"Well aren't you a gentleman! But I'm going first." Cana teased as she appeared behind Natsu now completely naked.

"Works for me." Natsu said with a smile knowing that his plan had worked. Between watching Loki's antics and the books he got from Gildarts, Natsu could be a real gigolo if he wanted to.

"Here you go, Natsu." Happy said happily as he brought the bag over. "Don't take too long or the master will get worried." Happy teased.

"Yeah yeah, now give us some privacy, lil buddy." Natsu shrugged as he laid out the sleeping bag in order to have some fun.

"Since you want us both, how are we gonna do this, Natsu?" Cana teased.

"Cana why don't you lay down on the bed so we can have fun and I can get Lucy ready?"

Cana smiled since she realized what Natsu was up to. "Alright big guy, just don't get too distracted." Cana teased as she got down on the sleeping bag spread eagle for Natsu.

"What about me?" Lucy pouted.

"Give me a sec, Luce." Natsu smirked before giving Lucy a peck on the cheek. A blushing Lucy looked on as Natsu lined himself up with Cana's snatch before plunging inside and filling her to the brim.

"Oh, that feels good." Cana moaned as Natsu filled her to the brim. She had a few flings over the years but Natsu was certainly the biggest of the guys she'd been with.

"Oh yeah, I'm fired up now" Natsu smirked as he began moving inside Cana hammering her pussy with a fierceness that she had never expected.

"Aren't you forgetting somebody?" Lucy groaned angrily.

"Of course not, Lucy. Just take that top of yours off and come over here." Natsu said happily not losing focus on Cana.

"Geez, you're just as bad as Loki." Lucy groaned. Despite her protests she took off her top and leaned on Natsu's left side so he could play with her breasts.

"Yeah, but you wouldn't let Loki do this to you, would you?" Natsu smirked as he began to make out with Lucy. He was sure that whatever Loki and Gray were doing, it wasn't nearly as fun as what he was doing right now.

"Hey Natsu, don't forget about me." Cana pouted.

"Of course." Natsu smirked as he continued to pound Cana's pussy while he played with Lucy.

"Damn, you're good, Natsu." Lucy moaned as Natsu began to play with her breasts using his tongue as he pistoned in and out of Cana.

"Keep going, Natsu!" Cana moaned loving the feeling of Natsu deep inside her. The pattern continued for a few minutes until everyone reached their limit.

"Cana! I'm gonna cum!" Natsu shouted out.

"Cum inside me, Natsu! It's a safe day!" Cana shouted out.

"I'm cumming too, Natsu!" Lucy moaned out Natsu's ministrations having worked to perfection.

"Here we go, girls!" Natsu cried out before sending a stream of cum into Cana's pussy.

"I'm cumming!" Lucy cried out as her own release coated her wet swimsuit.

"Ahh, that was great!" Cana exclaimed as she felt her own release combine with Natsu's.

"It's my turn, Natsu." Lucy said happily. Hearing how good he made Cana feel made Lucy want Natsu for herself.

"Alright Lucy, but you need to get naked also." Natsu smirked.

"Just fuck me already, Natsu." Lucy groaned as she quickly took off the soaked swimsuit bottom and took her spot on the sleeping bag.

"Here we go, Lucy." Natsu smirked as he lined himself up with Lucy's snatch. Much like with Cana he slipped inside her in one quick motion piercing her womb and in this case taking her hymen.

"AHHHH!" Lucy cried out as she lost her virginity to the man who changed everything.

"Lucy, are you okay?" Natsu said nervously as he noticed the blood coming from her pussy.

"She's fine, Natsu. That's just what happens when you take a girl's first time." Cana said with a smile.

Natsu didn't realize that it was Lucy's first time and began to regret being as rough as he is, "I'm sorry Lucy, but…." Natsu stopped when Lucy leaned up to kiss him.

"Natsu, it's alright. It was probably better that you did it the way you did." Lucy smiled.

Natsu was relieved but he took a second to allow Lucy to relax. After a minute or so Natsu was ready to go, "Here we go, Lucy." Natsu said happily.

"How about I help you, Lucy?" Cana smirked as she moved to her right side and licked the blonde's breasts in order to make it easier for Lucy to enjoy Natsu's ferocity. Cana would never admit it but Natsu was an extremely rough lover and if his focus was all on Lucy his partner wouldn't be able to move.

"Hey Cana, that's unfair!" Lucy moaned as Natsu moved inside her.

"Unfair, was you horning in on my moment with Natsu." Cana smirked. She did have a reputation to keep up.

"Aww, I'm touched, Cana." Natsu smirked. "But you're not being left out of this one either." The dragon smirked as he snaked his hand behind Cana's back and fingered her pussy. Hey, he was aware that he was a rough lover, so in a way this was Cana's reward for being a good teammate.

"Hey hey! You're having sex with me, remember?" Lucy pouted

"Sorry Lucy." Natsu said before returning his attention to the blonde. For the next five minutes Lucy and Cana's moans of pleasure filled the room until the moment of truth had arrived.

"Natsu, I'm about to cum!" Lucy cried out.

"Okay Lucy, so am I." Natsu said happily.

"Me too!" Cana smirked.

"I want it inside like Cana!" Lucy cried out and a minute later Natsu obliged by sending a rope of cum into Lucy's snatch filling her to the brim.

"Damn, that was intense." Natsu said happily as he fell onto the ground.

"Yeah, that was definitely S-class worthy." Cana said with a cheeky smile.

"Why don't we get changed? I'm sure Virgo can get some clothes for us." Lucy said calmly as she summoned the maiden.

"Hello Princess! I guess you finally slept with Natsu huh?" Virgo said with a smile.

"What are you talking about Virgo!?" Lucy said with a blush.

"Something you wanna tell us partner?" Cana teased.

"Well…you see…" Lucy stammered.

"Mistress Lucy has a lot of fantasies about Master Natsu, and when she's not working on her novel she writes them down in a special diary." Virgo said bluntly causing all parties to blush.

"Damn it Virgo!" Lucy complained.

"Don't worry about it." Natsu said with a smile as he kissed Lucy on the cheek.

Cana smiled at the way the day had played out. She got her feelings about Natsu off her chest and she could still be an S-class wizard once the day was over. "Tell Virgo to get us some clothes so we can move on." Cana teased.

"Fine." Lucy pouted. A few minutes later the girls had new clothes and left to take their place among the rest of those who passed the first test. While nothing could prepare them for what would happen next, it was a nice moment for Cana and Lucy; two girls with father issues who wanted to become stronger because of the Dragon slayer they just left behind.

Thanks for reading this first chapter guys and i hope you liked it. There will be five chapters of this Unique Path Story.

1. Lucy Cana

2. Mira

3. Lisanna and Juvia

4. Free Path

5. Erza

As i said earlier this is non-negotiable and if you don't like it too bad. I do hope you stick around for the end regardless because some fun stuff is on the way.