Wilbur was walking down the sidewalk one day going to his favorite diner. He wanted to get out of the hotel after a big fight he had with his other siblings. He walked into the diner and not paying attention, ran into a werewolf girl. She fell to the floor and Wilbur looked down at her, helping her up. They locked eyes for a moment, and Wilbur felt the one thing he thought would never come for him, a zing.

"Sorry about that, I should watch where I'm going." Wilbur said.

"It's okay." The girl replied.

"My name's Wilbur by the way." He introduced.

"I'm Carrie." The girl said.

"I was about to sit down and have some lunch. Can I treat you? It's the least I can do after running into you." He asked.

"That would be great." She replied.

The two sat down at a table, ordered some food, and talked for hours on end. Wilbur checked the time on his phone after he was finished with his meal.

"Well, I should be going now. It was nice talking to you Carrie." He said. He was about to get up.

"Wait! Before you go…" She said.

"What is it?" Wilbur asked.

Carrie pulled out a scrap piece of paper and a pen. She wrote something on it and gave it to Wilbur.

"Call me sometime. I'd love to get to know you better." She said.

"S-Sure!" Wilbur said nervously. He got up from the table and left the diner. He was very happy about what just happened.

'I-I can't believe what happened! A girl gave me her number!' He thought to himself.

He was so happy he was singing and dancing while he was walking down the sidewalk. Eventually he returned home to the hotel. His mom and dad were waiting for him. They noticed immediately that he seemed very happy.

"You seem to be in high spirits hon." Wanda said.

"Yeah, what's going on?" Wayne asked.

"I met a girl named Carrie and she gave me her number! She might want to go out with me!" Wilbur said.

Wayne and Wanda were happy about the news.

"That's wonderful honey! I'm glad you finally found someone!" She said.

"Wow, my oldest son found a girl. Way to go!" He said.

Wilbur nodded and went to go find his younger siblings so he could apologize to them for earlier.

"What do you want Wilbur?" Winnie asked in a mean tone. Winnie and Wally were playing with Willie, Willa, Wanye, and Sunny.

"Whoa, I just wanted to say I'm sorry that I was mean to you guys earlier. That's all." He said leaving them after he apologized. Winnie and Wally were absolutely blown away.

"Wha?! Did Wilbur just say he's sorry?" Winnie asked in confusion. Wally nodded.

"Yeah, that's not like him at all." He said.

"Yeah! He's usually very mean!" Willie said. Willa nodded at what her younger twin brother said.

"Something's wrong with Wilbur! He's never nice!" Sunny said.

Winnie and the others were wondering what brought on this sudden change of heart, though they weren't buying it, except for Willie. He liked the fact that Wilbur was being nice for once.

*A few weeks later*

Winnie and Wally noticed that Wilbur was acting very strange. He was a lot happier than normal, and he was doing things that he wouldn't do before, like actually spending time with his siblings. The others were starting to believe Wilbur really had changed; however, Winnie and Wally weren't falling for it one bit. They also noticed Wilbur would go out late at night and wouldn't come back for a long time. Winnie and Wally decided to spy on Wilbur to see what was going on.

One night, Wilbur headed to his parents room with Winnie and Wally secretly following him.

"Mom, Dad, I'm going out." Wilbur told them.

"Okay, don't stay out too late!" Wanda said.

Wilbur nodded at them and went to the hotel entrance with Winnie and Wally following. Wilbur walked on the sidewalk that led into town while Winnie and Wally hid in bushes and kept following him. Suddenly, Winnie tripped on a rock and fell flat on her face.

"Oww!" Winnie said out loud. She and Wally quickly hid in their bushes as Wilbur looked behind him to find the source of the noise.

"Am I being followed? Hmm, must be my imagination." He said to himself. He continued walking and they followed. They eventually came to the diner and Wilbur went inside. Winnie and Wally stayed outside and watched from the windows. They saw Wilbur with a werewolf girl that he hugged and kissed, and the two sat down at a table.

"Wilbur has a girlfriend?" Winnie asked in shock. "Never thought that was gonna happen."

"Neither did I." Wally agreed. "That would explain why Wilbur's been so happy lately."

"He doesn't deserve to be happy! He always made sure we were miserable; we should get him back for all the things he did to us!" Winnie said.

"Yeah! We need to find a way for his girlfriend to see the real him. Then she'll break up with him!" Wally said.

With that, the two of them headed home and waited for Wilbur to come home. When Wilbur did come home, he called everyone to the lobby for an announcement.

"I invited Carrie over to stay for a couple days so she can meet everyone! There's only one thing I need." He said.

"What's that hon?" Wanda asked.

"I want everyone to be on their best behavior, especially you Willie." He said. That was because Willie had a tendency to misbehave.

"I promise I'll behave big brother!" Willie said.

"Good, that goes for the rest of you as well." Wilbur said to his other brothers and sisters.

Winnie leaned over to Wally and whispered "This is our chance! We need a way to mess up Wilbur's relationship!"

"Don't worry sis, I got the perfect plan." Wally whispered back to her.

*The next day*

Wilbur was introducing Carrie to everyone and everything was going well. Until Winnie and Wally enacted their plan for revenge.

"Carrie, can we talk to you for a minute?" Winnie asked.

"Yeah, it's important!" Wally said.

Wilbur and Carrie both looked at Winnie and Wally in confusion.

"Umm, okay. I'll be back babe." She said.

Winnie and Wally took Carrie aside.

"I can't believe you fell for someone like Wilbur!" Winnie said.

"Why is that?" Carrie asked.

"Wilbur is not what he seems. He's very mean! One time, he framed Willie for breaking a vase that he broke himself!" Wally said.

"He would never do something like that!" Carrie insisted.

"Oh yeah? There was the one time he took Wanye's toys and wouldn't give them back, the one time he took Sunny's makeup kit and wouldn't give it back, and the time he took Willie's detective kit and wouldn't give it back! Wilbur is a very bad person! You should break up with him!" Winnie said.

"I'm sorry, but I don't believe you guys. Wilbur seems too nice to do any of those things." Carrie said. She went back to Wilbur and they walked away. Winnie and Wally both growled in frustration.

"Dang it! That didn't work." Winnie said.

"Don't worry sis! I got an awesome plan b!" Wally said.

Winnie eyed him.

"Oh yeah? And what's that?" She asked.

"Making Wilbur look bad in front of Carrie." He said.

An evil smile spread across Winnie's face and she said "Let's do this!"

The two of them set about on their plan. However, no matter what they did, Wilbur had some way of making himself look good. Wilbur was starting to become increasingly annoyed with Winnie and Wally's behavior.

"What's gotten into you two? I asked you to behave for once and I can't even get that out of you guys!" Wilbur said.

"You don't deserve to be happy Wilbur!" Winnie said.

Carrie gasped at what Winnie said and even Wilbur was a little shocked.

"Look, I know we haven't always gotten along, but can't you see I've changed?" Wilbur asked.

"You're not fooling anybody Wilbur! You may have Willie and the others fooled, but not us!" Wally said.

Right after Wally said that, Willie came in with a glass of juice in his paw and wasn't paying attention. He tripped and spilled the juice on Wilbur's shirt.

"My shirt!" Wilbur said in annoyance.

Willie looked at Wilbur and said "I'm sorry big bro…"

"SHUT UP!" Wilbur screamed. "You always mess up everything around here!"

"Hey, calm down!" Wally said.

"Stay out of this Wally! Willie, you're a pest!" Wilbur said.

Willie was starting to tear up.

"A-A pest?" Willie asked shakily.

"Yeah, I don't know how anyone can put up with you! You're a bad excuse for a werewolf and a brother!" Wilbur said.

Everyone in the room went quiet for a few seconds. Willie began crying loudly and ran of the room while Winnie chased after him. Carrie went over to Wilbur and smacked him.

"Oww!" He said.

"You're an awful monster! I never want to see you again!" She said.

Wilbur was completely shocked with what had just happened and Carrie began to storm out of the hotel.

"Carrie, wait!" Wilbur said in desperation.

"We are through Wilbur! I never want to see your ridiculous face again!" She said storming out of the hotel this time. Wilbur watched her leave and felt tears form in his eyes. To Wally's shock, Wilbur actually began crying.

"I'll never be happy again!" He said tearfully.

For the first time ever, Wally felt bad for Wilbur and hugged him.

"It's okay big bro, she'll come back!" Wally said.

"No, she won't!" Wilbur said. He ran off to his room crying. Wally decided to check on Willie and the others.

Willie was crying loudly.

"It'll be okay Willie." Winnie said.

Willie sniffled and said "It's all my fault! Carrie hates Wilbur now because of me and it's all my fault!"

"Hey calm down! It's not your fault! Wilbur's the one who yelled at you!" Wally said.

"I spilled juice on his shirt!" Willie said.

"It was an accident!" Willa said.

"Everyone has accidents little bro!" Wanye said.

Willie was still crying.

"Wilbur's gonna be sad forever and it's all my fault! I'm the worst brother ever!" Willie said.

"No Willie! You're a great brother!" Sunny said.

Willie continued crying.

"I messed up everything." He said.

"We gotta fix this. Wally, come with me!" Winnie said.

"Hey, I'm the older sibling here! You come with me! The rest of you stay here and calm Willie down! Mom and Dad are helping Wilbur." Wally said.

"Good luck guys." Willa said.

Meanwhile Wilbur was done talking with his parents and decided to check on Willie. He was still crying.

"Is everything okay little bro?" Wilbur asked.

Willie sniffled and looked at Wilbur.

"It-it's my fault Carrie hates you! It's all my fault!" He said.

Wilbur went over to Willie and pulled him closer. For the first time ever, Wilbur hugged Willie.

"Shhh, everything's gonna be okay little bro." Wilbur said trying to calm him down.

Willie continued crying.

"A-am I really a sorry excuse for a brother?" He asked.

"No! Far from it! If anything, I'm a sorry excuse for a brother. You were the only one that trusted me, and I repaid you by yelling." Wilbur said.

Willie started calming down.

"You're an amazing little brother Willie. You don't deserve a horrible brother like me." Wilbur said.

Willie sniffled some more and Wilbur broke away from the hug. He handed Willie his stuffed snail.

"I'm gonna go for a little walk. I'll try talking to Carrie myself. I'll set things straight." Wilbur said.

Willie sniffled and said "Winnie and Wally are already doing that."

"Crap, I better hurry up before she slaps them!" Wilbur said

"Can I come with you?" Willie asked.

"No, this is something I have to do alone. You stay here with the others." Wilbur said.

With that, Wilbur left the hotel and started heading for Carrie's house.