Subaru's Isekai Dream

Hey, this is my first time ever writing fanfiction let alone a lemon. I'm taking inspiration from The author named guyNumber23. He has a really cool story called Sweet cute green obsession which is a style of writing that I haven't seen anyone else do as well as they have, basically making a lemon with a good plot. Anyways I chose to write about Re:zero one of my favorite animes and series in general, I'll try to keep the characters as close to their original personalities as possible but they might differ to add more "spicy" situations. I will probably add characters from the light novels but I'll try to keep spoilers low. I do not own Re:zero or any of its characters, So please enjoy. Rated M

Natsuki Subaru was your average shut-in teenager, all he did all day was read manga and sleep, one day when he went out to buy some simple groceries he was suddenly transported to an alternate world, he would soon find out that this world does not revolve around him as a protagonist and he would know true suffering.

It's been a few months since Subaru entered this world, but to him it's been a bit longer, besides that in his time here he has accomplished more than he is willing to admit. He saved Emilia from the bowel hunter Elsa, He saved the village's kids and village from the mabeasts in the forest, He organized and was indispensable to the subjugation of the white whale, Finally he was able to take down Betelgeuse and his fingers and tell Emilia how he felt.

Finally things were looking up for this man the only loose end he had was with rem (A/N: rem is alive and well in this) Back when he was ready to give up everything and run away rem confessed to him and gave him the strength to keep trying and eventually he succeeded with her help. Despite when Subaru said he loved emilia over rem he couldn't help but feel that in his heart he loved them both equally. At the end of the battle with the white whale he agreed that he would make rem his second wife if emilia was okay with it (A/N: yes that was an actual thing in the web novel) but ever since then he doesn't know how to act around her

Rem more or less seemed to have gone back to normal with being more affectionate towards Subaru, He actually doesn't mind and sometimes leans into her affection with happiness, at first it was subtle you could barely notice it but soon everyone began to notice that Subaru treated Rem with the same kind of affection he talked to Emilia with

[Rem] "Subaru-kun come drink with us!"

Currently the members of the mansion were throwing small party with the people of the village for subaru, of course subaru insisted they shouldn't but they did anyways, currently subaru was sitting a small table with emilia when rem came by with a bottle of wine and 3 cups

[Subaru] "Um i don't think i can legally drink yet"

[Rem] "Of course you can subaru-kun you and rem are the same age and Emilia-sama can as well!"

Rem enthusiastically insisted that Subaru and Emilia drink with her, by the looks of it she had already drunk a little bit herself evident by her blushed cheeks, Emilia on the other hand enjoyed alcohol when it was offered so it was no problem for her to partake in drinking.

[Emilia] "Come on subaru let's get drunk as a skunk!"

[Subaru] "Who even says drunk as a skunk anymore."

Subaru and emilia's constant banter were always a happy moment for subaru and her, with all the chaos that had happened recently and her big fight with him, he was happy that things were back to normal now and her smile always refreshed him

On the other side of the table stood Rem already pouring the drinks and slightly pouting from the lack of attention Subaru was giving her, but at the same time she enjoyed watching him be happy even if he wasn't directly being happy with her. She could remember the conversation they had back at the battle of the white whale and how they would talk to emilia about it but never had, well tonight was the night she would bring it up.

[Rem] "Here Subaru-kun drink up"

[Subaru} "I still dont think this is a good idea….ah what the hell"

And with that subaru had his first taste of alcohol which he immediately regretted due to the burning it had in his mouth and on the way down his throat, Instead of sipping it like you should subaru decided to gulp the whole thing down as a shot making him basically instant drunk.

[Emilia] "Oh wow subaru you must be tough to be able to drink wine like that, i can barely get more than a sip in and i love alcohol"

[Rem] "Wow subaru-kun i didn't know you could drink like that even though you always refused to"

Both emilia and rem voiced their thoughts and slight concern for subaru as he himself had an internal battle to try and stay conscious under the effects of alcohol, slowly he felt his vision blur and his whole body felt warm, it was almost the feeling he got when he is in the final moment of death but this time he felt happy and bubbly inside soon he blacked out and the females around him shed a look of concern.

[Rem] "It seems like subaru-kun cant hold his liquor."

[Emilia] "Yes it does but alcohol is sooo tasty!"

[Rem]"Emilia-sama are you already drunk?"

[Emilia] "Not completely but don't you think subaru's sleeping face is sooo cute?"

[Rem]"Yes indeed it is, its one of rem's favorite things about subaru-kun"

[Emilia]"Ne, rem-san you and subaru have been really close recently. Why is that?"

[Rem]"Rem and Subaru are very good friends and I confessed to him…" Rem said this with a huge blush on her face not from the alcohol, when rem said this emilia had a look of shock and confusion.

[Emilia] "You confessed to subaru? Like how he confessed to me?"

[Rem] "Hai, rem doesn't mean to take subaru away from Emilia-sama but i love subaru…"

[Emilia] "um rem-san i don't know if subaru likes you like that, i don't mean to speak for him but he said he really loves me so…"

[Subaru] "i love bot- *hic* of you guys"

Subaru suddenly said that while his head is still there on the table and his eyes still closed, he still looked like he was sleeping but he said that nonetheless shocking both the woman, rem's blush increased tenfold making her seem like the happiest woman in the world while emilia was so shocked that she nearly sobered up

"Could subaru love rem too? I did leave them alone for a few days so its possible they developed a relationship but...he said he loved me, i guess you can love multiple people" this is what emilia thought, she was very naive in the ways of love to a point where she doesn't even truly understand what subaru's love means so for her this was just a matter of learning.

[Rem] "at first when rem confessed to subaru he had denied me leaving me a bit sad inside but after the subjugation of the white whale subaru told me he loved me back and that i could be his second wife!"

[Suabru] "hehe *hic* yeah i did say that and i *hic* meant it, i love you both equally"

Subaru with his drunken self wrapped his arm around Emilia, pulling her close, so close that their lips almost touched…

[Emilia]" No! Subaru you had too much to drink im-im going to bed!"

Emilia who pushed Subaru off of her stood up and ran to her room, face flushed and is embarrassed by her sudden outburst. Subaru on the other hand stood there dumbstruck as he watched emilia storm off, with his emotions at an all time high subaru began to tear up until rem came from behind and hugged him, but the damage was done and emilia drew alot of attention to the table making rem feel even more embarrassed as she saw people look at her hugging subaru

[Ram] "rem what happened here and why are you hugging that pitiful man?"

[Rem] "well you see nee-sama emilia-sama screamed at subaru-kun and he looked sad so i tried to comfort him…"

[Ram] "i see, take him to his room so he can be pitiful there"

Ram with her constant berating of Subaru told Rem to take him away as she tried to defuse the situation with the guests, Subaru sat there teary eyed and drunk until Rem put his arm around her and lifted him up in assistance while beginning to make their way to his room.

[Rem] "subaru-kun are you alright?"

[Subaru] "not really, *hic* i think i just made emilia-tan hate me…"

[Rem] "Rem doesn't think so, subaru-kun just scared emilia-sama...look there's your room" Rem lead subaru to his room opening the door and sitting subaru down on his bed while she sat on a chair in front of him.

[Rem] "Subaru-kun, just for the record...Rem wouldn't be scared.."

Before subaru could fully process her words rem leaned in and kissed him, he was shocked at first not knowing what to do but soon he began to lean into it enjoying the warmth of her lips and the taste of her mouth, it was new sensation one that he had never felt before, her lips were so soft that he wished he could kiss them forever. She tasted like wine but had very little taste of the alcohol, only the sweetness that the wine provided, he wished he could stay like this forever, she smelled so nice and everything about her just filled up Subaru's mind.

Rem on the other hand, her mind was going crazy she kissed him on impulse and because of the influence of alcohol, her mind was racing, she couldn't think straight, and her heartbeat was going a million miles a minute, she intended it to be a quick peck and then she would run out but soon she noticed subaru wasn't so tense and that he was starting to move his mouth with her, when she felt that it felt like the world stood still, she was actually kissing her subaru-kun the only person she loved more than her sister. Ram would kill them if she found out but that wasn't what rem was thinking, in fact she wasn't thinking at all, just living in the moment

[Rem] "um….Rem is sorry for doing that to you subaru-kun, please have a good night!" Rem spoke as fast as she could as she tried to scurry out of his room only to be stopped by subaru's hand grabbing hers

[Subaru] "rem….i…"

Subaru at this point sobered up a little but he couldn't find the words to say to her, instead he acted, he pulled her close kissing her once again, at first they both were so tense it was just lips on lips no movement, no emotion just there, subaru had his eyes shut so tight they could burst while rem was stuck there eyes wide open in shock. They stayed this way for a few seconds until rem decided to kiss subaru back and soon the two began to have a passionate kiss. It was awkward at first but the two found a rhythm with their mouths, Subaru's hands found their way to her hips and back not daring to go further than that while rem's hands were wrapped around his neck, it truly looked like a scene straight out of a romance movie.

They probably were kissing for 30 seconds before they broke it to breath, not only that but subaru was beginning to get an erection, not wanting the situation to become awkward he sat down on the bed crossing his legs to hide up his situation

[Subaru] "...that was….nice"

[Rem] "rem is glad to hear that subaru-kun…" An awkward silence has fallen on them, both wanting to continue but not sure what to do next

[Subaru] "Rem….do you maybe….want to sleep here tonight? I don't want to be alone…" Subaru's face was beyond red and he tried his best to look up at her but his nerves wouldn't allow it, but he was able to get those words out which hit rem like a truck.

[Subaru] "ah i didn't mean it like that...its just after what happened with emilia…"

[Rem] "No its alright rem will stay with subaru-kun tonight to sleep"

Rem wore the brightest smile she could manage, she had never felt happier than she felt right now, despite his weird request rem didn't think anything dirty she only enjoyed the idea of being with subaru.

[Rem] "please wait here while rem gets her night gown" and with that rem does a small bow and walks out the room.

With rem gone subaru finally realizes the weight of the words he said, he immediately goes into a small panic attack, he is about to sleep with a girl even if no sex is involved this is still a big thing for Natsuki Subaru, he never even kissed a girl till a minute ago and now he was about to sleep with her…

Subaru decided to man up and live with this decision, hopefully emilia wont get upset, minutes later subaru got a knock at his door and there rem stood in her light blue nightgown bashfully looking at subaru with a light blush on her face, she looked beautiful thought subaru, he couldn't help but smile at her making her blush even more, soon after entering the room rem came and sat down on the bed next to subaru who was blushing madly along with her.

The tension finally broke with rem hugging subaru and giving him a small kiss.

[Rem] "we should get to sleep it's getting late"

[Subaru] "Yeah you're right, im feeling pretty tired" That was a lie subaru was more awake than he ever was despite still being a little drunk, he made his way on the other side of the bed and laid down, the bed wasn't exactly small so they had enough space to lay comfortably but it wasn't too big that they were far apart, if one person shifted too much they would be touching each other.

Laying in the bed with each other made both their hearts race, they were laying on their backs looking up at the ceiling when suddenly rem wrapped her arms around subaru making him face her, she looked so pretty Subaru thought how could someone be so pretty, there was nothing else but her in this world and with that he leaned in to kiss her while wrapping his arms around her too

Each second he kissed her he felt like it was heaven, Rem loved every moment of this as they made out their tongues clashing exchanging saliva and light moans, rem moved her hands to his intertwining their fingers together it felt like the perfect dream she thought, she wanted to be closer so she moved up a little but when she did she felt something poke her in her leg

Rem's knowledge of sex was brief but she understood the basics of it and if she wasn't wrong right now what poked her was subaru's erection…

[Rem] "Subaru-kun..is that…"

[Subaru] "ah, im so sorry, it just randomly happens sometimes and in a situation like this it was bound to happe-" Suabru was going into a frenzy of words while slowly scooting away before being pulled back in by rem silencing him with a kiss, their tongues clashing once again and suabru's new found erection was resting in between rem's thigh slowly being rubbed by hand

[Subaru] "rem….?" Is this really happening?! Rem was really rubbing his erection, before he could complete his thought Rem grabbed his hand and put it on her breast, instinctively Subaru started squeezing it, how could it be so soft? They weren't as large as Emilia's but they weren't small either, they were like the perfect size, before he could lost himself in thought Rem pulled his pants down revealing his covered manhood. Subaru knew he had a larger than average penis but it never got to shine with him never having a girlfriend, but before she could go any further subaru grabbed her hand

[Subaru] "rem are you sure you want to do this?"

[Rem] "Nothing would make rem happier than to make subaru feel good" with that said rem removed his underwear revealing his erection in all its glory, it took her a second to take it all in but once she resolved herself she began to slowly stroke him earning light moans from subaru as his hands explored her body, with one hand going under her gown and reaching up for her breasts and the other one holding her face gently they both gave light gasps while looking each other in the eye

[Subaru] "ah *fuck* rem"

[Rem] "Does it *ah* feel good subaru-kun?"

Both of them with their hands full felt in heaven, subaru loved the way her breasts felt and loved the way she stroked him

[Subaru] "um rem *ah* can you remove your gown?"

Without hesitation rem got up and removed her night gown while she was removing her gown subaru began to remove his clothing as well, when he looked up he saw rem revealing her pearly white skin, so soft and flawless he just wanted to touch every inch of her, he started by caressing her back and giving her ass a squeeze, it felt so soft yet firm in the right way, his hands may their way back up to rem's bra clasps and with a little bit a struggle he undid them revealing her perfect breasts with pink tips at the ends of them.

He couldn't help but stare making rem feel slightly embarrassed, after a few seconds of starring his hands made they way and started groping her breasts and twisting her nipples, rem was squirming under him indulging in the pleasure that her subaru-kun was giving her, it felt like heaven but it wasn't enough she started feeling hot between her legs, rem has mastubated in the past but she only found out about it recently and rarely did it at that so this feeling wasn't un familiar, she wanted more she lead one of subaru's hands that was holding her back, to her crotch.

Suabru could tell what she wanted as she resumed to jerk him off he felt could feel the little bit of pre cum drip onto her hand, subaru locked her into another kiss this time fiercely as he rubs the outsides of her panties, he can clearly feel it was soaked with her fluids and was begging to be rubbed and that's just what he did, he rubbed and pushed hearing the occasional squish, the room began to fill light moans and gasps as the two experience nirvana. Subaru feeling near his limit, slipped his fingers into rem's panties earning a large moan which was music to his ears, he started by slowly teasing her by rubbing around her hole and playing with her clit, rem was getting drunk off this pleasure she didn't think it could get better until she felt his finger enter her.

It was a wave of pleasure as she felt that she could cum just from his fingers going in and out like that but she wanted them to finish at the same time, so she began increasing her speed.

[Rem] "*ah* Subaru-kun is so *uh* big…*ah* your fingers feel so good"

[Subaru] "Thank you *fuck* you are good at this *ah* but ill make it even better"

With that said subaru leaned into her chest and started to suck on her nipples, he was so close to his limit he could barely hold it back and it seemed like rem was the same way, he gave it his all and sucked on her nipples the best he could and fingered her the hardest he could, rem noticing this trying not to get lost in the pleasure sped up her jerking him off.

[Rem]" *Ah* fu-fuck *Ah* Subaru-kun i'm going to…"

[Subaru] "*fuck* Yeah me too"

[Rem] "SUBARU-KUN"

Both of them came at the same time Subaru's cum shot up and caked rem lading on her breasts and stomach, Rem when she came her eyes rolled back and she appeared possessed for a second while her pussy squeezed the life out of subaru's fingers but he loved it, they both stayed there sitting up leaning on each other for a few minutes before laying back down facing each other out of breath and with the biggest blushes on their face, there was a mix of ecstasy and shame written on their faces but they were ultimately smiling and happy in what they did.

[Subaru] "so….um that was fun.."

[Rem] "yes indeed subaru-kun made rem feel so good!" They shared a little laugh at that comment and Subaru gave her a look that said "me too", he locked her into one final kiss.

[Suabru] "we should probably take a shower...I'll make sure the coast is clear then you go" With that rem gave him a small nod still blushing before he made his way up for the door while putting his underwear on. When subaru reached for the door and opened it he didn't expect on the other side of the door to be emilia

He was in awe for a second he could see that her face was flushed but she seemed upset, even when she was upset she was the cutest thing subaru thought...wait now's not the time subaru just got caught by emilia and in the corner she could see rem on the bed covering herself with a blanket. Emilia took one more look at subaru, before he could see her now teary eyes Emilia ran down the hall towards her room, he wanted to chase after her but in his current situation he couldn't….

Whoa i actually did it, and i don't regret it, i've been wanting to make this kind of story for a while now but never had the courage to, i don't know how prevalent the Re:zero fan base is on this website but i hope anyone picks up this story and enjoys it, like i said i want to make a lemon with plot like guyNumber23 and i hope i can achieve that, i hope you've enjoyed my story and leave a review if you want, ill work on a part 2 soon to continue this story, Take care, tatoes out!