I don't think this is as good as my other Glee story, because I'm not as good at writing about Finn and Kurt as I am at Quinn and Rachel. But I hope you like it, and if you do say thank's to when-the-music-fades because she's the one who asked me to write another Glee story.
Warning: gay guys, sorta. Nothing happens, sorry to disappoint any of you who wanted to see some Finn/Kurt action. But I suppose I should put the warning here, for those sensetive people who can't stand gay thoughts.
Too Far to Reach
Kurt walked up to Rachel. He was furious.
"How could you? You know it would hurt Finn!" he screamed.
"He had to know!" she yelled right back at him.
"But were you really thinking of that when you told?" his voice became soft and cold, "or did you just do that because you thought it would break them up."
Rachel glared at him for a second, "I wanted to break them up, but you of all people should understand!"
"Not if it hurts Finn."
"And it wouldn't hurt him when he figures out for himself?"
"It would, but at least I wouldn't be the one inflicting the pain on him."
"Kurt, i feel really bad about it, but I can't change anything now," Rachel said, her tone softening.
Kurt turned away, he didn't want to look at her anymore. But she was right, as much as he hated to admit it. But maybe there was something he could do.
Kurt showed up at Finns house wearing a designer sweater that almost came all the way to his knees and skinny jeans and freshly plucked eyebrows.
"Oh hey Kurt, what are you doing here?" Finn asked.
"Finn, you can't just laze around wearing sweatpants," he wrinkled his nose, "you have to get over Quinn, so we are going to go to Red Lobster and you are going to feel better, so go put on something decent."
"Wait, Kurt, are you asking me ou-" Finn started.
"You could call it that if you want, Kurt said, "but I thought you didn't think about me that way."
"I don't, but Kurt I don't really fee-"
"You won't ever feel like going out, if you don't do it, so go get dressed. And put this around your eyes, it'll make the redness from crying not so noticeable," Kurt interrupted Finn again, handing him some cream.
"I can't beleive I let you talk me into this," Finn whisper-yelled at Kurt.
"Why are you whispering?"
"I don't know," Finn admitted, watching Kurt sip his soda through a straw. It seemed like a really girly way to drink soda but when Kurt did it, it was almost... cute. Wait, what? He didn't think Kurt was cute! He was a guy! He didn't like guys like that. It's probably because I'm so upset about Quinn, he told himself, he didn't like Kurt. Not like that... did he?
"Finn, as wonderful as my complexion is, it's impolite to stare," Kurt said, pulling Finn out of his thoughts
"Oh, uh yeah, sorry."
"Is something wrong?"
"No..." he couldn't admit that for a second he had a crush on Kurt, he probably wasn't even interested. Kurt was doing something nice and here he was ruining it with thoughts like this.
Kurt watched Finn fidget in his chair, probably thinking about Quinn, God, he wanted to rip her head off, her head and Rachel's.
The waitress walked over with their food, she looked young, about their age, her name tag said 'Stacy'.
"Hi, if there's anything else you need just ask okay," she turned to Finn, "I'm not really supposed to do this but, will you go out with me sometime by any chance?"
Finn stared at Kurt, for some reason he wanted Kurt to stand up and tell here, 'no he's mine,' but Kurt wouldn't do that, this wasn't, after all, a date. it was just Kurt being nice. And Kurt had told Finn to move on, even though he wanted to move on with Kurt. Wait, where did these feelings come from all of a sudden? Probably just leftover emotions from Quinn, not sure where to go.
"Okay," he said to Stacy.
Kurt watched Finn say yes to Stacy, he couldn't help but feel disappointed, but what did he expect, Finn was heterosexual, and Stacy was pretty, although she did have a few split ends, and her complexion wasn't nearly as clear as his. If he couldn't be loved by Finn, then he'd have to do the next best thing, make Finn happy and if Stacy made Finn happy so be it.
"I'm off at ten," she told Finn.
"So did you have fun?" Kurt asked Finn after he'd made plans with Stacy for their date.
'Yes, but I wouldv'e had more fun if you had been the one to asked me out,' he wanted to say, but couldn't, instead he said, "yeah, I can't believe it, but I did."
"I'm glad."
Finn felt the sudden urge to kiss Kurt, but wouldn't.
Kurt felt the sudden urge to kiss Finn, but couldn't.
They both went to their separate homes and lied on their beds and thought about the other and wondered why the one you want is always close enough to want, but too far to reach.