MBAV Fanfic

True Identity

AN: I do not own My Babysitter's a Vampire… or any references to games, shows, books, songs, etc. However, I do own my character, Casey. This is my first fanfic, hope you guys like it.

Mrs. Morgan's POV

I hear the door bell and scurry to get it.

"Hi Sar- who are you?" I ask, as I find myself face to face with some unknown girl.

"Oh, hello, I'm Casey. I just moved in a couple houses down, and my mom suggested that I introduce myself to the neighbors" she says smiling slightly.

Politely, I invite her in. "Well it's nice to meet you Casey. I'm Mrs. Morgan, and this is Mr. Morgan." I gesture to my husband as he walks in. "Why don't you go introduce yourself to our kids? We need to get going, their babysitter should be here soon." With that, we head out.

Casey's POV

I sigh and turn around. In front of me is this adorable little girl!

"You're not Sarah", she states in a disappointed tone.

"Why no, I'm not. I'm Casey, I just moved in a couple houses down. Who might you be?" I ask, already positive of the answer.

"I'm Jane. Do you like Just Dance 2?"

I nod eagerly. A huge grin appears on her face as she walks over to their Wii. She puts the game in. "May I choose the song," I ask her. She nods. I scroll through the songs until I come across "Sway (Quien Sera)". As soon as we start, the two boys come partially down the stairs. Looking up, their jaws drop. This will be interesting.

Benny's POV

Ethan and I start to come down stairs when we see this beautiful girl dancing with Jane. I've never seen her before. She has shoulder length, golden brown hair. Her eyes are the color of the ocean. She's wearing a light blue and navy polka dotted tank top with short navy shorts and flip-flops.

As soon as she and Jane finish the song they plop down on the sofa. Jane's congratulating her for winning, while Ethan and I go the rest of the way down stairs. When she spots us she hops up and extends her hand out to me.

"I'm Casey, I just moved here, what's your name," she asks cheerfully as I shake her hand.

"Benny" I respond mesmerized.

Letting go of my hand, she turns to Ethan. "And you are," she asks as she tilts her head slightly.

Extending his hand he replies, "Ethan".

Not taking his hand, she nods, "nice to meet you".

"Let's watch a movie" suggests Jane

"What movie" Casey sweetly asks.

"Jurracci Time-Machine" I respond excitedly, pulling out my convenient copy. I hand the disk to Jane and she puts it in while we get situated. Ethan and I sit on the couch with Casey in the middle.

"I've never seen this movie before" Casey says with a sparkle in her eye, "Is it good?"

"It's amazing" I state casually as I place my arm behind her on top of the couch.

She giggles. Jane grabs a pillow and sits herself on the floor. About one minute into the movie the doorbell rings. Ethan gets up and answers it. Shortly after, Erica, Sarah, and Rory walk in.

Casey's POV

I tense as soon as the door opens. Benny looks at me with concern. I can't take it anymore. "VAMPIRES" I scream as I curl up into a ball in Benny's lap and cover my neck with my hands.

Erica speaks, "who's she?"

"This is Casey, she just moved in a few houses down, and I believe she's having a freak attack" Benny replies as he places a comforting hand in the middle of my back. What a sweet-heart.

"How does she know we're vampires" asks Sarah.

"I don't know" says Benny as he begins to slowly rub my back.

I sit up in his lap and whisper so only he can hear me "Erica's going to try to bite me."

He breaks my gaze and looks up at Erica, "don't you dare try to bite her" he states assertively.

"How did you know that's what I was thinking" exclaims Erica.

Everyone's eyes are on me. A stray tear runs down my cheek, before I begin to sob into Benny's shoulder.