TITLE: You Get What You Give Chapter 1: It's Different Between You And Me
PAIRINGS:
Pezberry
With some Faberry
And mentions of Brittana and Klaine
RATING: M (for a reason, trust me)
Synopsis: Santana and Rachel are roommates in college and Rachel has a thing for Santana but Santana thinks they're just friends until she sees Rachel with another girl (Quinn). Then she begins to realise maybe there could be a whole lot more than just friendship between them
WARNING: GIRL PEEN! AND HEAVY SMUT (if that's not your thing then don't say I didn't warn you)
A/N: Hey guys time for a new story, this is basically a one shot smut for now but I may add more chapters if you guys want more, so have a read and send me your sexy Pezberry prompts (basically there is some plot for the first chapter but future chapters if I chose to write any will probably end up being mostly smut with some possible plot)
This story was suggested by and therefore dedicated to pezberryfan88, hope you like the story and sorry again it took a while
Santana, Rachel and Brittany, and of course Lord Tubbington all shared an apartment in new York, they all went to colleges close by and Kurt and Blaine shared their own smaller apartment a few blocks away. Britt was back in Ohio for a few days visiting her parents. They had all lived together since leaving Lima, and they all got along very well.
Santana woke up alone in her bed, her whole body sweating and her bed sheet tangled around her feet, she couldn't believe it had happened again, she had had yet another sex dream about Rachel Berry. Santana cursed herself as she looked down at the bulge in her boxer shorts, and untangled her sheet, she was used to having sex dreams that matched her libido, hell she'd even had one about her old substitute teacher Holly Holliday. But having them about one of her best friends just seemed a bit strange to her, sure Rachel was hot but she never really thought about liking Rachel as anything more than just a friend. After all they were roommates and a romance would surely make their lives all that more awkward, right? So instead she spends most nights dreaming about the little diva and the mornings masturbating away the erection she causes
Rachel on the other hand wakes up with her own little problem, she seems to have her own habit of dreaming about Santana, but she doesn't find it as weird, in fact Rachel enjoys it. She likes Santana as more than just a friend but knows Santana doesn't feel the same way so she keeps her feelings secret and only acts on them in her nightly dreams, even if it means waking up with a major throb between her own legs and soaking wet panties to go with it. Rachel thought about just outright telling Santana how she felt but since they've only just gotten to really know each other she was afraid of ruining the good relationship they had built up between them.
Santana kept staring at her boner hoping it would go away, but as usual it just seemed to stay even when she thought about Will Schuster and Sue Sylvester making out on the choir room piano…in their underwear. She knew she would have to take matters in to her own hands once again. She pulled her boxers down to expose her 6 inch fully erect dick and gripped it tight with her left hand. She remembered a time she used to hate even looking at her not so ladylike part let alone playing with it but over the years she had just learned to live with it and accept the way she was born. The worst part was trying to hide it when it decided to spring to life at the most inappropriate times and places but other than that she didn't really have much of a problem with it anymore. She did however often find herself freaking out she was gonna end up getting a girl pregnant each time she slept with one but that's why she always had a good supply of condoms in her bedroom drawer, just in case.
Back when they went to McKinley she was much more naive about her 'condition' and the only thing on her mind normally was sex, when she would see Quinn or Brittany dancing around in their Cheerios uniforms it was hard for Santana to control herself, but now she's a little older she had become better with her self-control. As most people would predict Brittany took her virginity, it was a mutual thing and Santana just wanted to get her first time over with as quickly as possible and as Brittany was her best friend and had some experience with the male anatomy she decided to offer Santana a free ride as it were, one in which Santana was a little self-conscious over but once she got going it didn't seem as bad as she originally thought it was gonna be. After that she and Brittany started a sexual relationship and it helped her realise she was actually more attracted to girls then boys, she never dated Brittany, in fact she had never dated anyone, she had always been too afraid to be in a relationship with anyone because of her penis. Santana had managed to sleep with a couple of girls in college but other than that she wasn't as experienced as most people would assume.
Santana began to move her hand that was grasped around her shaft, she had always been rather proud of the way her penis looked, it wasn't too big nor too small and it wasn't too thick nor too thin, if she had to describe it she would say it was pretty perfect. She stroked herself slowly a few times before picking up the pace. "Oh god" she muttered to herself as her small hand caressed the sensitive skin of her dick. She started up a familiar rhythm and began to fantasise about the good old days when Brittany would spend the night at her house then wake her up with her perfect pink lips wrapped around her cock. The thought alone was enough to push Santana close to the edge, she pulled her sleeping shirt up and placed one hand on her abs and felt them tense up as her orgasm grew closer. She tried to keep her moaning down, not knowing if Rachel was up yet or not. "Holy shit" she gasped out as her hand gave its last few strokes and her whole body stiffened. She watched as her cum shot up and landed across her tanned skin, she collapsed back into the bed and caught her breath again. Once she had recovered she yanked her underwear back up cleaned herself up with a Kleenex and made her way to her ensuite bathroom to get dressed for the day.
Meanwhile Rachel had woken up with the same problem; she knew she wouldn't be able to concentrate on her daily activities if she didn't sort herself out. She could already feel how wet her dream had made her as she shuffled around in her bed. She decided to just go for it; her hand made its way down to her sleeping shorts and past the waistband till she felt the small patch of trimmed brunette curls. Her fingers explored further and her hips bucked slightly when the tips brushed her hardened clit "Oh Santana" she murmured clearly imagining her fingers were the Latina's instead. She began to rub her clit in tight circles, before wetting them with her own juices then entering herself "Oh yeah San, right there, fuck me so good" she whispered biting down on her own bottom lip. She brought her other hand down to take over rubbing at her clit, her hips bucking uncontrollably as her pleasure began to build, "Santana fuck you're so good, don't stop baby, make me cum" she moaned turning her head into her pillow, careful not to be too loud, but just as she was about to go over the edge there was a knock on her bedroom door, her hands quickly fled from their positions and into a less suspicious place as she wiped them off on her bed sheet "Um come in" she said as casually as possible.
Santana entered her room "Hey Rach, just wanted to let you know I'm heading out. I'm gonna meet Kurt and Blaine at the cafe" she informed, the gang had quickly found the perfect place to decide on as their new Lima Bean, it was a little café near Central Park.
"Oh ok tell them I said hi won't you" Rachel smiled hoping her face wasn't too blushed
"Well you can always come with us if you want?" Santana offered with a smile
"Oh no that's ok, I have something I need to finish off here but thanks for the offer" Rachel smiled back
"Cool, oh and I almost forgot, remember Quinn will be coming by later today, she's got her new motorbike she just has to show off" Santana said with a roll of her eyes
"Don't worry I haven't forgotten, anyway have fun with the boys"
"I will. Catch ya later" San winked and shut the door.
Rachel waited until she heard Santana leave the apartment before letting her hands wander back down and inside her shorts; they soon found their rhythm again. Rachel imagined what it would be like to have sex with Santana, it's not like she was a virgin but she had never been with anyone quiet like Santana before, and she knew it wouldn't be quiet the same as using a strap on dildo. She knew Santana had had a friend with benefits relationship with Brittany but what most people didn't know about Rachel was that she had had the same thing with Quinn Fabray since the last year of high school. They had kept it a secret as Quinn wasn't too sure about her sexuality at the time and if Rachel was to be honest she would say Quinn probably still wasn't sure what she was but it didn't matter to Rachel, she and Quinn had never had 'in love' feelings for each other, only sexual. Since leaving school their sexual relationship had decreased significantly but with the help of Quinn's metro passes she had gotten and now her brand new motorbike they were able to see each other occasionally and almost always had sex at least once during those times. But ever since Rachel had started to have feelings for Santana she had started to make an effort to see Quinn less and less, despite the fact she knew Santana wouldn't look at her twice in that way.
"So close" Rachel gasped as her little fingers rubbed back and forth on her clit, she was now so wet she could hear each time she entered herself with her fingers. "Oh I'm gonna cum, Santana!" she moaned loud enough that if said Latina was still in the house there would have been no way she didn't hear that. She felt her body tense up as she began to cum around her fingers, still rubbing her clit enjoying every last wave of pleasure she was able to give herself. "My god" she panted as she slowly pulled her fingers free once she had stopped clenching around them. She looked at the wetness that coated her digits and smiled with pride and satisfaction.
Santana walked into the café she had planned to meet Kurt and Blaine in, "Santana over here!" Kurt yelled out getting a few looks from the people around him and his boyfriend "We saved you a seat!" he continued and Santana smiled at the boys before making her way over to them
She sat down "Hey guys, how's it going?" she asked with a smile, she liked how she had gotten closer to Kurt and Blaine, it was one thing to be able to talk to them about being gay but she also found comfort in talking to them about her extra addition between her legs, and they had both offered her much needed advice over the time they had known about it.
"We're good, and we ordered you your usual already" Kurt explained "Now tell us how are you? Any new girls we need to know about?" he asked excitedly wiggling his eyebrows as Blaine shook his head
"Kurt come on, let the poor girl catch her breath before you start with the dating talk" Blaine reasoned
"No its fine. No there's no girl in my life right now" Santana smiled
"I still think you and Rachel should just hurry up and get it on already" Kurt said like it was the most obvious option on the table
"Kurt I've told you already, me and Rachel are just friends" Santana protested just as the waitress came over and placed three coffees on the table, they all thanked her before she walked off
"Oh come on Santana, you can't tell me you don't look at Rachel and not get any sort of feelings in your pants, I mean when that girl dances even I question myself…sometimes anyway"
"Yeah San you have to admit, that girl sure has grown up" Blaine added
"Ok I admit she is hot and I'd be lying if I said I've never thought about it, but we're roommates and she's one of my best friends, I don't want to go and ruin that. Besides she totally doesn't like me like that" Santana was sure
"Are you kidding? Of course she does" Kurt said almost too loudly
"And how do you know?"
"She told me"
"Bullshit Kurt, why can't you just leave this? I'm happy the way we are and I'm sure Rachel is too" Santana said
"All I'm saying is, she's single and you're single and you're both hot" Kurt shrugged
"Kurt I'm sure if Rach and Santana were meant to hook up it would happen" Blaine suggested, trying to calm his boyfriend down
"Yes thank you, at least someone sees sense" Santana gestured to the boy
Kurt was about to admit defeat but he had one more point "Well what about your sex life?"
"What about it?" Santana wondered
"Well when was the last time you had sex?" he raised his eyebrows
"Why do you want to know so badly?" Santana smirked
"I don't, it's just…well you're a young adult and therefore have urges. I mean me and Blaine try to do it as often as we can and I'd hate to think you're missing out on that connection"
"Are you offering your services?" Santana laughed
"That long huh?"
"It's been a few months I guess but that doesn't mean I have to fuck the next thing that walks by. I want to have a real relationship with somebody but until I find that person I guess I'll keep waiting"
"Well what kind of person are you looking for?" Blaine asked
"You know just the usual stuff, a kind, caring girl. Someone who can be herself, who's honest and faithful and the biggest thing is, it has to be someone who can love me even with a dick" Santana said almost sadly
"That sounds a lot like Rachel if you ask me" Kurt said
"Anyway enough with sappy girl talk, we've got our coffees, now let's go hit the stores" Santana smirked, they could use a little retail therapy and with that said the trio gathered up their stuff and headed out to have some fun.
Back at the apartment Rachel was preparing for Quinn's arrival, she knew the blond would be there soon and she didn't want to delay the evening by not being ready. She tidied her room and made sure all her dirty clothes were off the floor and in the laundry basket. Once everything was in order she looked at the clock to see Quinn was already ten minutes late, not that Quinn ever turned up on time in any case.
Eventually there was a knock at the door and Rachel ran to it excitedly, she opened it to see Quinn standing there. "Hey Rach, long time no see" she smiled before walking into the apartment
"Quinn you do realise you're late again don't you?" Rachel informed
"Well blame your neighbourhood, it's a bitch trying to find somewhere to park my bike" Quinn said looking around the apartment "Did you clean?" she smirked
"Well Santana keeps having a go at me for leaving stuff lying around the floor, so I gave it a once over" Rachel shrugged
"Where is Santana?" Quinn asked as she sat down on the couch, gesturing for Rachel to come over
Rachel slowly walked up to the blond till she was standing in front of her "She's gone out for a bit, she's with Kurt and Blaine, so we're completely alone" she smiled down at the girl as she climbed on top her straddling her hips. Quinn smirked up as Rachel leaned in to capture the girl's lips with her own. Quinn's hands instantly reaching around to grasp at the diva's ass.
Quinn pushed Rachel back a bit to stop her "Rachel I need to tell you something" she whispered
Rachel just kissed her again and replied "Tell me after" she stood up and took Quinn by the hand before leading them to her room. Once inside she pushed Quinn down on her bed and straddled her once more, she reached for the hem of her shirt and pulled it up over her head, revealing to Quinn she had 'forgotten' to put a bra on this morning "You like?" she teasingly asked as Quinn's hands instantly reached up for the girl's breasts and began to palm at them as her lips found Rachel's neck.
"Oh god Quinn, I've missed this" she admitted, completely aware she was picturing Santana the whole time she was speaking
Quinn stopped herself and took off her own shirt, throwing it behind her somewhere, her hands landing back on Rachel's legs and creeping under the girl's skirt. "Someone's wet already" Quinn smirked when her fingers reached Rachel's panties and she could feel a sizable wet patch appearing on the crotch
"I've been horny all day" Rachel admitted pushing Quinn back down on the bed and crawling off of her. "Undo my skirt for me" she said and Quinn grabbed the skirt, ignoring the button on the side and just yanked it down Rachel's legs, surprisingly leaving it unbroken. Rachel smiled and before she could even attempt to help Quinn out of her pants the blond had already got them down to mid-thigh "Someone's eager" she giggled
"Well you're not the only one who's had a lady boner all day" Quinn laughed kicking off her pants and pulling Rachel back down on top of her, now both girls were in nothing but their panties. "God I wanna fuck you so hard" Quinn husked against the brunette's lips
"Then what's taking you so long?" Rachel replied with a smirk of her own growing on her face. "Hurry up and fuck me" she ordered flipping them over so Quinn was now on top.
"Ok well you asked for it" Quinn leaned down and kissed Rachel's lips before moving down to nibble at her neck, one hand finding its way back to her breast and pinching an erect nipple. Quinn's lips kept moving south, she licked her way down the valley between Rachel's breasts and down to her stomach, then she got to the top of Rachel's panties. She bit them and looked up at Rachel who was far too aroused to see straight right now, Quinn tugged on them with her teeth and Rachel got the message, she lifted her hips for Quinn to rid her of the garment. Quinn pulled them all the way down her short yet sexy legs and tossed them to the side. Rachel was now on full view to Quinn but she wasn't shy like she used to be, she eagerly parted her legs further for Quinn to get a better look.
Quinn leaned in and immediately let her tongue swipe over Rachel's clit "Oh yes Quinn, lick me" she pleaded, fisting the sheets under her. Quinn smirked up at the girl who had her eyes tightly shut and her mouth hung open a little, she gave Rachel another lick and let her nails scratch up and down her sensitive thighs as she worked. "Oh god yes, fuck me please" she whined. Quinn didn't want to tease so she moved her tongue down to Rachel's entrance and pushed it in as far as it could go, causing Rachel to whimper in pleasure, then she placed two fingers over the girl's clit and continued rubbing it while she tongue fucked her pussy. "Yes, Quinn, so good" she growled through gritted teeth.
Quinn pressed down with more pressure on Rachel's clit as she began to rub faster, her tongue also picked up pace as she darted it in and out, savouring the taste of Rachel. Rachel's body was shaking almost uncontrollably as she grew closer to her orgasm. Quinn could recognise the signs of Rachel on the edge of climax and she knew it wouldn't be long, so she pulled her tongue out in one quick motion and replaced it with her fingers then wrapped her lips around Rachel's lonely clit. "Oh my god" Rachel gasped out at the sudden change. Quinn's fingers walked up Rachel's body until they found her breasts, she began to gently pinch her nipples, Rachel gasped from the extra sensation.
Rachel arched her back off the bed and pressed closer to Quinn's face as her orgasm rushed through her body "Fuuuuck! Oh yes Santana!" Rachel moaned forcing Quinn to halt her tongue and fingers and pull back. She stared down at the diva.
"What the fuck? Why did you just say Santana?" Quinn asked rather confused
Rachel quickly scrambled up as Quinn wiped off her face "Um I didn't, you must have heard wrong. I said Quinn, that's you" Rachel desperately tried to lie
"Rachel come on, I've known you for years now, and this isn't the first time we've fucked, I know when you're lying. Plus I have ears, I heard you say Santana" Quinn explained
"I'm sorry Quinn, I didn't mean to, I hope I didn't hurt your feelings" Rachel said apologetically, even if they were just fuck buddies, she still felt bad
"It's ok I guess, it's more of my pride you hurt. I mean you just said another girl's name as I was making you cum, it's not exactly the ideal situation" Quinn said
"I'm so sorry Quinn, is there anything I can do to make it up to you?" Rachel asked smirking slightly as her hand landed on Quinn's thigh
"Rachel why don't you just tell her?" Quinn asked
"Tell who, what?" Rachel replied pretending she had no idea what was going on
"Tell Santana that you like her as more than just a friend"
"Why would you think that?"
"Oh come on Rach, its completely obvious. You always talk about her, I've seen the way you look at her and you clearly were just imagining it was her tongue between your legs" Quinn said wisely
"Ok so maybe I do like her but it's not like I can just tell her that" Rachel said covering herself with her pillow
"Why not? I think you two would make a cute couple. Is it because she has a…?" Quinn gestured downwards
"No, that's not it at all, it's the fact that we're roommates and she just thinks of us as roommates, and I don't want to ruin our friendship" Rach explained
"Well maybe she would be into it, it's not like she has a girlfriend or anything. I say just go for it, be honest with her, I mean you never know until you ask right?" Quinn smiled
"Maybe you're right, I mean the worst she can say is no, right?" Rachel smiled back
"That's the Rachel I know, the optimistic diva" Quinn joked, causing Rachel to playfully smack her on the shoulder
"Anyway despite the fact I called out Santana's name I did enjoy the orgasm that you gave me" Rach assured
"That's good because I put a lot of effort into that one" Quinn laughed again
"Wait what was it you wanted to tell me anyway?" Rachel wondered
"Oh that. I don't think we can do this anymore, like the sex thing" Quinn gestured between them
"If this is just over the whole Santana thing, I said I'm sorry"
"No, no it's not that. I kinda started seeing someone back at Yale, and I think I really like her, she's totally turned on by my bike. I mean we're only starting out right now so it could go any way but I just don't think starting a relationship off is good when you're still having sex with someone else, so it's best if we stop that's all. And anyway if you and Santana get together that might be a bit weird" Quinn explained happily
"Well that does make sense and I guess if you've got a girlfriend we should really stop, I don't want to be the reason she hates you before you really get going" Rachel joked
"Thanks and…" Quinn stopped suddenly after hearing a noise "Wait was that your front door?" the blond wondered, her eyes widening
"Hey Rach, I just saw Quinn's bike outside, is she here?" Santana asked opening Rachel's bedroom door, her eyes also widening when she saw Quinn and Rachel in bed…together "Holy crap, fucking hell, shit" she said before turning right around and walking back out. She never expected that at all, but seeing Rachel with somebody else in that manner made her think and feel things she thought or at least pretended she didn't. She felt jealousy
Santana wondered what she had really just seen, was Rachel dating Quinn? Quinn was a lesbian? Well actually she could have guessed that one. But she had no idea those two were hooking up and how long for and the biggest question was why?
"I guess I should maybe go talk to her" Rachel suggested as they both sat there slightly embarrassed
"Good idea, but I'd put some clothes on first" Quinn warned
"Right" Rachel got out of bed and began to collect her clothes from around the room, redressing as she went, Quinn remained in bed until Rachel was fully dressed then decided she should probably leave and let Rachel and Santana talk so she too quickly redressed and both her and Rachel left the bedroom. Santana was sat in the living room and Rachel headed over to her
"I'm gonna go, give you some time to talk. I'll come back another time" Quinn said and Rachel nodded and watched as Quinn left the apartment
"I didn't know you two were…dating?" Santana said still confused herself
Rachel sat down next to Santana on the couch "We're not dating; me and Quinn are just friends"
"Friends don't fuck Rachel"
"Well you and Brittany did" Rachel countered
"That was different"
Rachel frowned "And how is that different?" she asked angrily
Santana decided to ignore the question "How long have you been doing it with her and why?"
"We started back in high school, we did it because we were both figuring things out and so it seemed like the best thing to do" Rachel explained not really understanding why Santana cared so much
"So you were like experimenting with her?" San asked like she was insulted by this
"Yeah I guess you could say that, why are you so weirded out by this?"
"Because if you wanted to try a girl you could have just asked me Rachel, I mean I thought that would be an obvious choice, I am gay after all. We are meant to tell each other things" Santana continued almost angry at the diva for being able to pick Quinn but not her
"What you don't think I thought about it, of course I did but I couldn't ask you, it's different between me and you than it was between me and Quinn"
"Why because I have a penis?" Santana sighed
Rachel took Santana's hand sensing her uncomfortable state "No Santana it's got nothing to do with that, I don't have a problem with that. I don't care what you have; I can assure you of that"
Santana locked eyes with Rachel, her lip pouting slightly "Then why didn't you want to ask me, you know I'd help you if you just asked"
Rachel sighed herself "I didn't ask you because I like you, I like you more than as just a friend and I was afraid of ruining that and I was also afraid that if we did anything that I'd want more and you wouldn't" Rachel confessed
"What makes you think I wouldn't be into that?"
"Well I know you see us as just friends and I respect that but it's getting hard to because I seem to be falling for you more every single day, I think I'm in love with you" Rachel hesitantly admitted
"Are you serious?" she seemed genuinely shocked, though at the same time not so much
"Don't worry you don't have to say it back, I know you have trouble with that sort of thing" Rachel accepted
"I never really thought about us in that way, but I have to admit I do like you Rach" Santana smiled, realising maybe she did like the girl a lot more than just as a friend and Kurt and Blaine were right after all, as were her many warning dreams
"Well that's enough for me" Rachel smiled back before leaning in and pressing her lips against Santana's in a sweet kiss, at first Santana was a little taken back but she soon got into it. Her hand quickly reached around to Rachel's neck to hold her in place
Their lips moved against each other as the embrace grew heated; Santana nudged Rachel back on the couch till she was laying down and Santana was practically on top of her. Rachel's hands had a mind of their own as they ran down Santana's body to cup the Latina's ass through her pants, surprising the girl slightly. Santana moved down Rachel's body, her lips traveling down her neck biting gently at her sensitive skin. "Oh god San" Rachel gasped, enjoying the sensation
Santana stopped altogether, got down on her knees in front of the other girl and took some time to look into Rachel's eyes before she ran her hands up the diva's legs and under her skirt till she located her panties. Her fingers hooked inside and began to tug at them; Rachel soon got the idea and lifted her hips for Santana to complete the job. She rid the girl of her underwear then gestured for Rachel to sit on the edge of the couch; the smaller girl didn't hesitate to take the order. She shuffled her butt to the edge of the seat in front of Santana who rested her hands on her knees.
Santana moved Rachel's skirt out of the way so she was faced with the girl's aroused sex, she could see Rachel was still wet from earlier but was also becoming increasingly more wet from what they were about to do. Santana locked eyes with Rachel, the aroma of Rachel's excitement drifting between them "You're so gorgeous, you know that?" Santana said sincerely before bringing Rachel down for another kiss and nibbling on her bottom lip as she pulled away.
Rachel relaxed back into the couch as Santana parted the girl's legs. Santana's hands grasped at Rachel's butt, her thumbs gently massaging her thighs. She leaned down towards Rachel's pussy and took a long lick up her slit. "Oh fuck!" Rachel couldn't help but moan out. Santana instantly smirked from the reaction, she knew she was good at going down on girls, and now she knew she had to be better than Quinn. She took another lick up Rachel's sex, getting a taste of Rachel's flavour on her tongue.
"You taste fucking amazing Rach" Santana's smirk grew wider, her hot breath brushing over Rachel's clit. Santana darted her tongue out and flicked the bundle a few times, Rachel's hips bucked into her face. Santana moved her hands from Rachel's ass to her hips to help hold her down as her tongue continued to attack the diva's clit.
"Oh that's so good San, don't stop" Rachel insisted, not that Santana had any intention of stopping anytime soon. Rachel gripped Santana's hair in an attempt to stay calm and guide the girl but it seemed Santana knew what she was doing and where she had to hit to get the best reactions. If Rachel had to admit it she would say Santana was rougher with her tongue but that wasn't such a bad thing, in fact she kinda liked it better than Quinn being so gentle with hers.
Santana could feel Rachel's thighs trembling slightly so she knew she was getting close to climax, she wrapped her lips around Rachel's clit and began to suck on it as her tongue continued to flick its tip, then she took one hand and pushed two fingers easily inside of Rachel's wet pussy. Rachel couldn't speak; she could only gasp at the welcome transition "God Rachel your pussy is so wet" Santana commented before instantly going back to the girl's nub.
Rachel tugged, possibly a little too hard, on Santana's hair, her orgasm quickly building to the point of no return. "Santana you're gonna make me cum" she warned but her comment only made the Latina speed up as her fingers pumped in and out of Rachel and her tongue abused her clit. "Holy fuck. Shit. Fuck. Santana fuck me, I'm cumming!" she panted as her whole body stiffened and her hips bucked involuntarily into Santana's face as she came over the girl's fingers.
Santana let Rachel's orgasm pass before she stopped sucking her clit, once the smaller girl was collapsed on the couch Santana pulled away, she slipped her fingers out and sucked them clean, completely aware Rachel was watching her under hooded eyelids. Then she went back down and lapped up all of Rachel's juices "Wow Rachel, you're really sexy when you cum" she smiled
"Thanks" Rachel panted still recovering "Your tongue is super talented" she giggled
"I've done it enough" Santana shrugged, pulling Rachel's skirt back down to cover her up
"Brittany?" Rachel inquired
"Uh huh. So was I better than Quinn?" Santana asked smugly
"You're both amazing in different ways, I couldn't possibly compare you"
"Well you could, you're just too nice to do so" Santana smiled
"Somebody has gotten cocky"
"Sorry I didn't mean to" Santana apologised
"Speaking of getting cocky" Rachel nodded downwards towards Santana's newly formed bulge in her pants
Santana followed Rachel's line of sight to see it, her hands quickly covered it from habit "Oh my god, sorry it has a habit of making itself known when I go down on a hot girl"
"Don't cover it" Rachel said pulling Santana's hands away from her crotch "It's a part of you and you've seen me and I want to see you, I want to see all of you. I want to have sex with you"
"Like actual sex, as in this…" she nodded downwards "…inside you?" Santana asked a little stunned Rachel was so eager
"We don't have to if you don't want to" Rach assured
"No, I want to, are you sure you want to, I mean it's a little different than getting naked with Quinn" Santana warned
"It's not like I haven't had sex with a penis before"
"I know but I bet it will be the first time you would have sex with a girl with a penis" San replied sadly
"You're still a girl, and I still like you the way you are and I want us to do it" Rachel said as her hand drifted down Santana's body and cupped the girl's hardening dick through her pants as she captured Santana's lips in a kiss full of renewed passion and heat. "All I ask is we go to your room because this couch is hurting my back" Rachel whispered against Santana's lips
"Let's go" Santana replied and picked Rachel up who wrapped her legs around San's waist and re-joined their lips as they headed to the Latina's bedroom, leaving Rachel's panties on the floor in the living room. Once they got to Santana's room they both fell on her bed still kissing, Santana's shirt was half tugged off as was Rachel's skirt. "I'll close the door" Santana said running over to it and locking it, Brittany was still in Ohio but this was New York, their friends had a habit of coming out of nowhere. Santana turned back to Rachel to find she was completely naked- other than her bra- on her bed, man this girl really worked fast. Santana decided to join her and tugged off her own shirt the rest of the way and dropped it on the floor. She walked back over to Rachel who had her eyes set on the girl's breasts as she wasn't wearing a bra. "Are you sure you wanna do this? You can still say no" Santana asked as Rachel's hands brushed up her sides
"I'm sure, now get those pants off" she replied. She watched on as Santana unbuttoned her pants and slid them down her tanned legs, revealing her boxer briefs and the ever growing bulge inside them. Rachel cupped it again almost causing Santana to stumble backwards, but Rachel quickly pulled on her boxer's waistband forcing the Latina to fall back on top of her on the bed "You still wanna do this though right?" Rachel asked back as Santana hovered over her
"I don't think I could stop if I wanted to" she smiled down at the diva
"Then fuck me" Rachel smiled back
Santana suddenly found a surge of confidence as she sat up and pulled her underwear down and got rid of them, letting Rachel see her naked for the first time. Santana closed her eyes waiting for Rachel to freak out but instead she just felt a small hand grip around her cock forcing her eyes back open
Rachel was smiling as she looked at Santana's erection, it was pointing up and the tip was pressing against Santana's abs. "Do you have a condom?" Rachel asked casually
Santana nodded "Yeah hang on" she said as she reached over to her bedside unit and opened the top drawer "I still have some left over from when me and Britt…well you know" she explained and pulled out a single condom, she pulled it open with her teeth and attempted to take it out of the packet it was sealed in but Rachel's hands stopped her.
"Here let me do it" she offered and she took the item from Santana and easily pulled it from the wrapper, then proceeded to roll it expertly onto Santana's penis.
Once the protection was in place Rachel wrapped her arms around Santana's neck and pulled her back down on top of her, spreading her legs for San to fit in between them. She could feel Santana's boner prodding her in the stomach as they continued to make out. Rachel knew she would have to make the first move to take the next step so she took hold of San's dick and pressed the tip against her entrance, parting her legs further. "I need you inside me" Rachel said, taking Santana by surprise slightly, she had never seen a side to Rachel like this, sure she had matured more since finishing school and moving to new York but this was something else on a whole new level and Santana loved it.
Santana took hold of her cock leading Rachel to remove her hand; she ran the tip up and down Rachel's wet slit being sure to bump her sensitive clit several times, making the smaller girl gasp with pleasure. "Oh San, please just fuck me" Rachel pleaded and Santana's signature smirk took over her lips
San brought her dick back down to Rachel's entrance and slowly pushed the tip in, Rachel whimpered from the eventual penetration. Santana watched on as she pushed her hips into Rachel's and the girl's pussy slowly swallowed her member inch by inch, she wasn't that big so it didn't take long for her whole self to be submerged in Rachel's warm, wet tunnel. "Oh my god Rach, you're so tight and hot" Santana commented as she shifted to get into a good position for fucking, being sure to not hurt Rachel "Are you ok?" Santana wondered with concern as Rachel's face scrunched up
"Yeah I'm fine, it's just been a while since I've had something so big inside me, I'll be ok in a second" she assured the Latina who patiently waited for Rachel to accommodate her length. After a minute or two of waiting and more shifting around on the bed Rachel smiled up at Santana "Ok, I'm good. You can move now"
"Are you sure?" Santana asked just to confirm Rachel wasn't trying to rush herself
"I'm certain, I need you" Rachel smiled again and nodded her certainty and Santana took this opportunity to lean down and capture her neglected lips in a deep kiss.
Before the kiss ended Santana began to thrust gently into Rachel, feeling her shaft move within Rachel's warmth, creating perfect friction between them. Both girls began to pant and moan into each other's mouths as their kiss continued, and tongues met. "Oh god" Rachel said, the first to break the kiss. She threw her head back and clutched tight around Santana. San's lips latched on to Rachel's neck, sucking on the soft flesh, biting down gently, neither caring much if she left a mark.
As Santana grew more confident her thrusts became more determined, she picked up the pace soon finding a comfortable rhythm, wanting nothing more than to make Rachel feel as much pleasure as possible
"Fuck, Santana you feel so fucking good"
"So do you Rachel, you're so warm around my cock, I can even feel you through the condom" Santana said as she continued to plunge deep into Rachel
Rachel squealed as Santana began to hit her most sensitive of spots inside her "God you're so deep" Rachel exclaimed
Santana smirked; she couldn't help it, her confidence and ego shooting through the roof. She reached around Rachel's back to unclasp her bra and rid her breasts of the restricting garment then leaned down to take one of Rachel's exposed nipples into her mouth. She sucked it wildly as Rachel bucked underneath her, her nails digging into heated skin. Her tongue swirled around her hard bud, scraping her teeth over it. "Oh my god you're gonna make me come so hard" Rachel announced as she reached one hand down between their sweating bodies to start working on her clit
Santana's arms were trembling as she held herself up above the other girl, her abs burning from the exhaustion of pounding into Rachel, but it felt too good to stop or to slow down. The room was full of the sounds of skin slapping together along with various pants, moans and whimpers, the smell of sex and sweat engulfed their noses.
Rachel wrapped her legs tightly around Santana, digging her heals into the Latina's ass, bringing her closer and forcing her in deeper, making each and every thrust harder. "Oh fuck me Santana, I wanna feel all of you, just fuck me, harder" Rachel whined as she used two fingers to rub tight hard circles on her clit. She was so wet she could feel it seeping from her and most likely making a nice sizable wet patch on Santana's bed, she would feel kinda bad about staining the girl's sheets if said girl didn't feel so fucking good fucking her.
Santana looked down between their bodies; the glisten of sweat on both hers and Rachel's abs. the sight of Rachel fingering her clit almost sent her over the edge instantly. Rachel used her free hand to reach up and palm at Santana's breast, squeezing it and moulding it between her fingers.
Both girls were quickly getting close to orgasm, Rachel's fingers were running back and forth over her clit so fast she could barely see them anymore. "I'm gonna cum San, fuck, I'm so close. I can't hold on" Rachel warned and Santana knew she was close to cumming too
"That's ok baby, just let go, I wanna feel you cum around my cock so badly Rach" Santana panted, her body aching all the more from her movements.
Rachel gave a few final flicks to her clit before pinching it to send her sailing over the edge, her eyes clamped shut and her jaw dropped open, her legs tightened around San's body so hard she was probably hurting the girl but she wasn't complaining and Rachel couldn't stop even if she wanted to "Oooh fuuuuck!" Rachel screamed out, gripping onto Santana's sheet underneath her as her orgasm ran through her body like a wildfire
Santana watched Rachel's face screw up in intense pleasure, that alone along with the tight clenching of Rachel's convulsing pussy around her cock was enough to force her to her own incredible climax. "Oh shit Rachel, I'm cumming so hard baby, all for you" she stated as her thrusts began to slow and she shot rope after rope of cum into the condom wrapped snug around her shaft. Both girls felt like they were never gonna stop exploding "Oh yeah" Santana finished as she felt the last spurt of semen leave her body.
By now Rachel was a sweaty, gasping mess under her. Her chest rising and falling deeply, her eyes only cracked open to watch Santana ejaculate. Her hands ran up and down Santana's arm as the girls came down from their highs.
Santana instantly collapsed on top of Rachel, struggling to regain her breath as she buried her face into Rachel hot neck. After a good minute of just lying there Santana leant up on her elbows, still inside of Rachel, she placed a soft and gentle kiss on the diva's neck before placing another on her lips.
They exchanged huge dorky grins with their 'just fucked' looks still very much in play "That was amazing" Santana whispered, she tried to say it normally but her voice cracked before she could get a word out, due to still being so spent so a whisper would have to do.
"It really was" Rachel's hand still played with Santana's back, drawing light random patterns and shapes on the flawless skin
"You get what you give, I suppose" Santana sat up slightly and carefully pulled out of Rachel, both girls whimpering at the loss of contact. She rolled the condom off her now softening penis and was handed a Kleenex by Rachel which she then used to clean up the wetness that was smeared across Rachel's lower lips, then she folded it over and used the other side to dab the excess cum that had gotten on herself. Rachel couldn't believe after such rough and heavy sex Santana could be so gentle with her clean-up process, Rachel smiled at the refreshing thought
Santana saw her smile and smiled back before getting up on shaky legs and stumbling over to the trash can- only to be subjected to Rachel's shameless checking out-, where she dropped the used condom and tissue into the garbage and returned to Rachel in bed.
"Hey" San said innocently as she crawled back on the mattress and back on top of Rachel and pulled the sheet up over their naked bodies, then kissed Rachel dead on the lips once more.
"Hey" Rachel smiled once the kiss ended
"So, I was wondering, if you wanted, maybe you and I could like…what I'm trying to say is…" Santana stumbled on her words; something that Rachel hadn't really seen before "You know, maybe we could…" Santana shrugged and it didn't look like she was going to be finishing her sentence anytime in the next century
Rachel grinned; she knew what Santana was trying to say "Santana Lopez are you trying to ask me out on a date?"
"Maybe, maybe not, that depends on what you're about to say I guess" Santana tried to play it cool
"San I'd love nothing more than to go out with you"
"Well I guess maybe we could go out" San shrugged coolly "You know I'd have to check my schedule but if I've got nothing else to do maybe I could make some time for you I guess" she teased
Rachel rolled her eyes, nice to know sex hasn't made things awkward between them, she playfully slapped Santana in the shoulder "Just as long as you're gonna pay because I'm gonna order the finest vegan platter imaginable" Rachel joked
Santana shook her head with a laugh and silenced Rachel with her lips against hers
"Quinn's not gonna beat me up now, is she?" Santana joked
"No, I think you're safe…for now" Rachel joked and smiled before starting up yet another heavy make out session with the Latina
A/N: Ok so once again not entirely sure if this will stay a one shot or if I'll add more chapters, it's basically down to if you guys want more, any future chapters will be mostly smut with some plot, so send me your Pezberry sexy prompts and any ideas what you'd like to see happen next if anything?
Please leave your reviews, and ideas or you can PM me