Author's note: Hello everyone! So last week's episode "Guilty Pleasures" inspired a new story for me. Definitely going to be multi-chapter but not sure how many yet. Someone requested on one of my other stories that I do a Blam pairing so this is my response to that. This is just my interpretation of where the last scene with Blaine and Sam could have gone, I do not own the rights to Glee nor do I own rights to the characters, everything belongs to Ryan Murphy and this is nothing but fiction. Enjoy! Oh, and just so there is no confusion:

Sam's thoughts are formatted like this

Blaine's thoughts are formatted like this

Chapter 1:

Sam walked into the April Rhodes Auditorium and smiled when he saw Blaine sitting at the piano center stage. "What are you doing?" Blaine looked up from what he was doing and smiled when he saw Sam, "I wanted to do one last Phil Collins song before they make us put our guilty pleasures back in the closet." "Who says we have to put them back? Why not just live with our guilty pleasures?" Blaine chuckled, "I don't think that's such a good idea. Guilty pleasures can be pretty embarrassing." Sam smiled, "Dude you don't have to be embarrassed. Look, I know...you're guilty pleasure is me and you know what it's cool. Frankly if you weren't attracted to me I would be pretty offended." Sam was surprised he just said that out loud but found himself smiling when he saw how big Blaine's eyes were, "You're...not freaked out?" Sam laughed, "Dude no of course not. Actually the attention is kind of nice, it's flattering." Sam smiled coyly at Blaine, "Come on man, hug it out!" Blaine hesitated for a second but stood up to hug Sam, Sam always felt safe when he hugged Blaine, 'is that normal?'

As they pulled out of the hug Blaine smiled up at Sam, 'shit he has pretty eyes' Sam thought, it was normal to find another guy attractive right? Sam had always noticed how handsome Blaine was but had never really thought past that, 'I wonder what it would be like to kiss him?' Blaine tilted his head to the side slightly, "Sam? Are you okay?" Sam shook his head, "Yeah, I'm fine. I just...fuck it." Sam lunged forward and smashed his and Blaine's lips together. Blaine hesitated for maybe a split second but then he was kissing back just as passionately as Sam, 'Holy shit Blaine's lips are soft, this is way better than making out with Brit. Wait, what?'. Sam broke the kiss and looked at Blaine, "Are you okay?" The amount of concern in Blaine's eyes made something happen in Sam's chest, "Yeah. That was just, awesome." Blaine's eyes went wide, "Really?" Sam just nodded before pulling Blaine back into another kiss, Blaine moaned and it sparked something in Sam. He pushed them back until Blaine was pushed up against the side of the piano. Sam licked Blaine's lips and he opened his mouth to let Sam in, the kiss immediately became more heated and Sam realized his hands were cupping Blaine's ass, now he understood why everyone always made a big deal about Blaine's ass, it was nice. 'Wait, Brit. I can't do this to her or Blaine." Sam broke the kiss and stepped back from Blaine, "I'm sorry." Blaine looked confused, "What are you sorry for?" "For kissing you, I shouldn't have done that. It was a douchebag move and I shouldn't do that to you or Brit." "Sam, I'm not going to pressure you. But I would be lying if I said this didn't make me more excited than I've been in months. However, I agree that this is wrong to do to Brittany so if you want to drop this that's fine." Sam was always shocked by how nice Blaine was, "Thanks man. I just don't want anyone to get hurt." Blaine smiled slightly, "In situations like this that's impossible but it doesn't mean it was wrong. I'm glad I got to kiss you even if it was just this once." Sam laughed, "Was it worth all the build up?" Blaine smiled widely, "Oh yeah." Sam had to fight the urge to lung at Blaine again, 'What the hell is going on with me? Do I...no that can't be it. I'm just curious is all.' "Look Blaine I have to go. I'm taking Brittany to breadsticks but can I come over to your house later and hang? There's one more number I want to do in Glee club this week and I wanted your imput." Blaine's eyes lit up a little, "Sure! Just text me when you want to head over." Sam smiled, "Sounds good. See ya later!"

Blaine found himself watching after Sam dreamily as he left the auditorium, 'No Blaine. Don't get ahead of yourself, it was only one kiss. He obviously regretted it right away. We are just friends. Friends. Friends. Friends.' After saying it to himself at least a dozen more times Blaine seemed satisfied and grabbed his bag and left the auditorium. He had to rush home to get his house ready for Sam to come over, luckily his parents were out of town as usual, so he wouldn't have to ask for their permission for Sam to come over. 'Benefits of being a neglected child I guess.' Blaine was used to being in the house alone but lately Tina had been coming over a lot more so it was a little better, but Sam had never been there before so Blaine needed the house to look perfect. As he ran around like a mad man to get his house clean Blaine couldn't help but wonder what had come over Sam in the auditorium, 'Maybe he's just curious? That happens right?' Blaine knew he would just drive himself crazy if he couldn't figure it out. 'Should I just ask him?' Blaine scoffed, 'Yeah right, nice Blaine. Hey Sam, why did you make out with me today?' But as he thought about it more he decided he should ask Sam, if for no other reason than to preserve their friendship.

As he finished cleaning up his room he heard a knock at the door, Blaine rushed downstairs and opened the door to see Sam standing there, "Hey Sam. What happened to texting me?" Blaine laughed but stopped when he saw how Sam was looking at him, "What's wrong?" Sam was just staring at Blaine, "I...broke up with Brit." Blaine gasped, "Oh Sam I'm so sorry. What happened?" Sam shook his head, "I don't know. We were eating and then I realized I didn't want to be there with her. I wanted to be here with you." Blaine's eyes widened, "Sam, what are you saying?" Sam shrugged, "Dude, you're guess is as good as mine. All I know is I haven't stopped wanting to kiss you again since I left the auditorium and I ended my relationship with this awesome girl all so I could come here to do it again. Fuck, did I just say that out loud?" Sam looked down at the ground not knowing what else to do, he jumped a little when he felt a hand cupping his chin, "Sam," Blaine raised Sam's face so he could look into his eyes, "If you want to kiss me you can. Kurt and I have made amends and he just wants to be friends so there's nothing stopping me. But are you sure about this?" Sam looked into Blaine's eyes, he loved how warm they were, "I'm not sure about anything, I don't know if I'm into dudes or what, but I want you."

Sam stepped into Blaine's house and closed the door behind him, "Are your parents home?" Blaine shook his head, "Good." Sam quickly wrapped Blaine into an embrace and pulled him in for a kiss. Sam deepened the kiss and dug his fingers into Blaine's hips making him groan, "Do you want me to stop?" Sam asked as he ran his hands up and down Blaine's sides, Blaine laughed slightly, "God no! I love kissing you." That was all the encouragement Sam needed, "Do you want to go to your room?" Blaine knew what Sam was asking, "Are you sure?" Sam nodded, Blaine took his hand and led him upstairs to his room. Once they were both in the room Sam closed the door and attached his lips to Blaine's neck pushing him back towards the bed, "Sam" Blaine breathed out, "Say it again," Sam groaned, "What?" Sam lifted his head to look at Blaine, "Say my name like that again." Blaine smiled widely and pulled Sam into another kiss, when he felt the back of his legs hit the bed he spun Sam around so he fell backwards onto the bed so Blaine was on top of him, Blaine began to grind his hips into Sam, "Sam," Blaine moaned against Sam's lips, "God it's so hot when you say it like that." Sam propped himself up so he could wrap his hand around the back of Blaine's neck to pull him deeper into the kiss, he used his other hand to pull Blaine's shirt out of his pants, they separated just long enough for Blaine to take off his cardigan and shirt as Sam took off his own shirt, they just looked at each other for a second.

Sam had seen Blaine without a shirt before but this was different, he looked...hot! Sam ran his hands up Blaine's chest making Blaine shiver, "You're so sexy." Blaine laughed, "Yeah right, I'm nothing compared to you." "Well then I guess I'll just have to prove how hot I think you are." Sam smiled widely and flipped so now Blaine was underneath him on the bed, Sam began kissing along Blaine's neck and began sucking. "Sam" Blaine ran his hands along Sam's shoulders just enjoying the attention he was getting. "So now do you believe that I think you're hot?" Sam smiled against Blaine's skin as he continued to mark him, "I don't know," Blaine teased, "I think I may need a little more convincing." Sam looked up at Blaine and smiled mischievously, "Really? I'll just see what I can do." Sam leaned down to capture Blaine's lips in another heated kiss and let his hand travel to the button on Blaine's jeans. He made quick work of unbuttoning Blaine's jeans and he slid down the zipper, 'Ok. Let's see how this goes.' Sam slid his hand underneath the waistband of Blaine's underwear and wrapped his hand around Blaine's pulsing cock. "FUCK!" Blaine's hips bucked up into Sam's hand, Sam began to build a steady rhythm and Blaine slowly became more undone. His panting and groaning were doing strange things to Sam, 'Wow. Brit was never this vocal. I could get used to this.' "God you are so fucking sexy when you are like this," Sam reattached his lips to Blaine's and tightened his grip on Blaine's cock causing Blaine to moan loudly into Sam's mouth.

"Ho-how...are you so good-at-this?" Blaine was having trouble talking, Kurt was never this talented at giving hand jobs. Sam chuckled, "If you think I'm good at this you just wait until the real fun starts." Blaine moaned, "I don't think I can. Sam, will you fuck me?" Sam's eyes darkened at Blaine's words, "Are you sure?" Blaine laughed, "I think I'm the one that's supposed to be asking you that. I have done this before." Sam smiled, "Well then where's the lube baby?" Blaine groaned at the pet name, "Bedside table." Sam reached over to get the lube and a condom out of the drawer. Sam would be lying if he said he wasn't nervous, but at the moment he was too turned on by Blaine to care. "So what should I do?" Blaine smiled, "Just come up here and give me the lube, I'll do the rest." Sam handed the bottle to Blaine and laid down next to him, Blaine moved from his position and adjusted so he was now straddling Sam. Blaine lathered up his fingers before he leaned down to kiss Sam, as they kissed Blaine began working his hole. "God, I can't wait to have you inside me. I want you to fucking pound my ass." Sam moaned as Blaine's ass brushed against his cock, "Fuck you're so hot baby. Please let me in Blaine." That was the moment Blaine lost it, there was no way he could wait any longer, he unwrapped the condom and worked it over Sam's cock and then put more lube on his entrance.

Blaine looked to Sam and smiled slyly, "Ready?" Sam pulled Blaine down and smashed their lips together, "Fuck yeah." Blaine positioned Sam's cock at his entrance and began lowering himself onto it. "Fuck you're so tight baby," Sam had his eyes shut and head thrown back, 'Fuck this is amazing! Why didn't I fuck him sooner?' "Fuck yes, Sam, fuck," Blaine now had all of Sam's cock inside him and began to rock his hips, "You like that? You like my tight ass?" Sam moaned, "Yes baby, so good!" Now Sam was the one having trouble finding words, he had never felt like this during sex before, it was so...'right'. Blaine raised up so almost all of Sam's cock was out of his ass and then slammed himself back down, "Yes!" Blaine hadn't ever been like this before, he didn't normally bottom while he was with Kurt, 'Fuck he is going to turn me into a little bottom bitch in no time. Shit his cock is huge.' Sam spread his legs and bent his knees slightly so he could thrust up into Blaine, after one thrust Sam brushed up against something, "Holy shit! SAM!" Any self-restraint Sam had now was gone, he quickened his pace so Blaine was basically impaling himself on his cock. They were both a broken mixture of moans and screams at this point, they were covered in sweat but neither showed any signs of slowing down, this was the best sex either of them have had. Sam continued to thrust into the spot that made Blaine scream, 'Damn I love seeing him like this. I want to make him sound like this all of the time.'

After what seemed like hours of heated fucking Sam felt a heat begin to grow in his stomach, "Blaine. Not going to last much longer." Blaine moaned, "I'm not stopping until you cum in me." As Blaine slammed himself down on Sam's cock again he rolled his hips in a circular motion that drove Sam crazy, Blaine only had to do it a couple more times before Sam was gone and exploded inside of Blaine. "FUCK! BLAINE!" That was all Blaine needed for him to reach his climax, he unloaded six hot streams of cum onto Sam's chest and one landed on his cheek. Blaine leaned back as he rode out his orgasm, he stayed that way until he heard Sam moan, he looked to see that Sam had scooped up the cum from his cheek and tasted it, "God that's hot." Sam looked to Blaine and smiled, "Just wanted to know what it tasted like. You taste like peaches." Blaine laughed, "Haven't heard that one before." Blaine slowly removed Sam's cock from his ass and took off the condom and tied it before throwing it on the floor and then flopping down on the bed. "That was amazing," Sam rolled on his side to look at Blaine, "I would have to agree." Blaine smiled, "Really? I was half way afraid you would rush out of here the second it was over." Sam raised up and brought his hand up to stroke Blaine's cheek, "Hey, you should know I wouldn't do that to you. Granted I have no idea where this sudden change came from but shit that was the best sex I've ever had." Blaine blushed, "No arguments here." Sam smiled, 'He's so cute when he blushes. Wait, did I just call him cute?' "So..." Sam was jolted out of his thoughts by Blaine's voice, "What happens now?" Sam chuckled, "Not a clue. But I will be honest, I'm not exactly ready to come out to the entire school just yet." Blaine laughed, "Yeah, that might cause some problems. But, we are going to do this again right?" Sam leaned in to kiss Blaine, this kiss had a sweetness to it that made both of their stomachs flutter. Sam looked into Blaine's eyes and smiled warmly, "Definitely."

They just laid there for awhile kissing lazily, finally Sam got up to get ready to leave, "I should head back. My dad's going to be home from work soon and I want to shower so I don't smell like sex." Blaine chuckled, "Good idea. I'll probably just order pizza or something for dinner." Sam's expression dropped a little, he had forgotten Blaine would be by himself once he left. "Hey, you doing anything later tonight?" Blaine tilted his head to the side, "Not really. Why?" Sam had to suppress a giggle, 'He's so cute,' "Well after I hang out with my dad for a bit how about I come back over here and we watch a movie or something?" Blaine smiled widely, 'He's never wanted to watch a movie with me before!' "Sure! That sounds great!" Sam smiled, "Great. I'll text you when I'm on my way back over! I'll even see if I can talk my mom into making us some cookies." Blaine laughed, "Oh, chocolate chip! Those are my favorite!" Sam chuckled, "I'll see what I can do."

After making sure he had everything Sam walked over to Blaine who was still on the bed and gave him one last kiss, "See you in a bit." With that he was out the door, once he heard the front door shut Blaine began laughing like a little school girl, he had no idea what had just happened but all he knew was that Sam was coming back over later just to spend time with him, which he had never done before. 'Does this mean he likes me? No, no that's stupid. We just had sex. Right?' Blaine was so confused, the last time he felt like this was with Kurt, but was he really ready to move on from that relationship and pursue something with Sam? If that was even an option. 'Don't get ahead of yourself Blaine, you just got over what happened with Kurt. No need to break your heart again so quickly.' He knew Sam would never intentionally hurt him but could they really have anything together? Blaine shook his head in frustration and decided he needed to shower. As the hot water ran down his skin Blaine thought about what it would be like to be with Sam. He thought about his beautiful green eyes and soft lips, and the way he always knew how to make Blaine laugh with one of his impressions, he was so kind and considerate. Blaine found himself smiling as he thought about it more, maybe it was time to give something new a try. Part of him still wished he could be with Kurt but he knew that was over, Kurt had told him so himself countless times now. Plus how could he pass up the chance to have sex with Sam again? He knew this could all go horribly wrong, but at that moment, he didn't care.

I really hope you enjoyed the first chapter! Please review and let me know if you think it is worth continuing! Thanks for reading! :)