AN: I literally just posted Feels like the First Time this morning and I'm already starting a sequel. I only had one review on the story, but it did gain a couple followers as well. Finals are coming up pretty soon so I'll try to update all of my stories as much as possible, but it's going to be difficult so just bear with me please. I hope you guys enjoy this one!

When the auditions for the Barden Bellas roll around, I find myself making my way to the auditorium. Chloe and Aubrey, after our sexcapade a few weeks ago, have decided to keep me around. Spending so much time around them has given them the perfect opportunity to pester me about joining. Although, it has been more Chloe than Aubrey. I think Aubrey is just content to have me around. I glance down at my phone and realize I'm running late. Fuck, Aubrey is going to kill me! I tuck my phone into my back pocket and take off at a dead sprint to the auditorium.

Chloe spots me at the side of the stage as auditions are coming to a close. She smiles brightly and nudges Aubrey. Aubrey arches an eyebrow and shoots me a small glare. I shrug and mouth 'sorry' to my girlfriends of three weeks.

"Wait, there's one more," Chloe points out.

Everyone's eyes are suddenly on me as I nervously make my way onto the stage. "Um, I didn't know we had to prepare that song."

Aubrey's jaw clenches slightly and Chloe just smiles. "Sing whatever you want," Chloe tells me.

I drop to my knees and crawl towards the table. Aubrey and Chloe's eyes darken in lust and I try not to smirk.

"May I," I ask, pointing to the cup on their table.

Chloe waves me on and I retrieve the cup before starting my audition. I set the cup down after I'm done and look to my girlfriends. Aubrey looks like she's still slightly pissed because I was late and didn't know the audition song. Chloe looks like she's just ecstatic for me to be anywhere near her.

"I'll just leave then," I mutter under my breath. I wave at Chloe and Aubrey before taking my leave.

I huff as Chloe shoves a burlap sack over my head. This is so ridiculous. Chloe's hands slide down my front and I growl low in my throat.

"Fine. I'll just take you to initiation then," Chloe mumbles.

I roll my eyes and pull the sack off my face to connect my lips with Chloe's. Chloe moans and pushes me up against the nearest wall. I push my thigh between her legs and let her grind against it. I smirk against Chloe's lips before I pull back and replace my burlap sack.

"We need to get going. Aubrey is already upset with me for being late to auditions and not knowing the song."

Chloe chuckles and presses a kiss to my shoulder. "Upset may be an understatement, but don't worry. I'll help you out."

The girls move into the area for Hood Night celebration. I stand next to Fat Amy towards the top. I can feel Aubrey's glare from where I am and I search for her. I find her towards the bottom of the pit and offer a small smile. Her eyes narrow slightly and I know I'm in for it later.

"Becaw! Becaw!"

I look towards the voice and see Jesse making his way towards me. Fat Amy has abandoned me and I'm on my own. Jesse has basically been crushing on me since we arrived at Barden. He doesn't seem to know how to take a hint. I look to Aubrey and shoot her a pleading look. Her glare turns to Jesse and I watch her grab Chloe and begin making her way to me.

"Do my eyes deceive me? Or are you a Barden Bella? You're one of those aca-girls and I'm one of those aca-boys and we're going to have aca-children. It's inevitable."

I force a smile and comment on how wasted he is. I tease him for awhile before he offers to go get me a drink.

"I'm going to get you a drink. You need to get on this level."

Jesse stumbles off right as Aubrey and Chloe reach me. Aubrey pulls me to her protectively and I nuzzle her collarbone. Regardless of the fact that I have the penis, Aubrey definitely wears the pants in this relationship. Chloe's fingers catch my belt loop and pull me slightly into her.

"Is he bothering you," Aubrey asks in a protective tone. I move my hand in a 'eh' kind of motion.

"I mean he basically just talked about how we were meant to be together."

Aubrey's jaw clenches and I can even see a hint of jealousy in Chloe's cerulean orbs.

"I'm going to end him."

I chuckle at Chloe's statement because it's so not Chloe. That's something Aubrey would say. Chloe's lips brush my temple and I sigh at the contact.

"Do we have to be here," I ask my girlfriends.

Chloe shoots me a sympathetic glance and Aubrey nods. "As captains, we have to be here until this all clears up. I have to make sure none of our girls get treble boned tonight."

I laugh outright at Aubrey's statement and she narrows her eyes at me playfully. I place a kiss on her lower jaw before pulling away.

"Wow, Beca. I didn't know you liked to hook up with girls when you started drinking. That's kind of hot."

I feel Aubrey tense and even Chloe's jaw clicks into place. I turn around and meet Jesse's gaze. Typical teenage boy mentality.

"First of all, I don't do hook ups. I play for keeps. Second, I like girls all the time. You're just dense. I've been rejecting you for a reason."

Jesse looks shocked, but I don't think he can process a whole lot in his drunken state. He just stumbles off and I roll my eyes at the thought of working with him tomorrow.

"I'm going to go. I don't feel comfortable here anymore. Text me when you guys get back and I'll come to your room."

Chloe and Aubrey both nod. Aubrey presses a quick kiss to my cheek and Chloe pulls me into a tight hug. "Be safe," she whispers as she pulls away. I nod and cast one last glance at my girlfriends before taking my leave.

I get a text around two in the morning from Chloe, letting me know that they're back. I slip out of bed and pack some things before sneaking out my door. The walk to Chloe and Aubrey's room isn't far. However, it's far enough for me to run into Jesse on my way there. He seems to be intoxicated still and from the looks of things, he's heading to my room.

I duck into the bathroom and dial Aubrey. She answers after a couple rings and I beg her to come get me. She acquiesces and tells me she'll be there soon. I hear Jesse banging on my door and hollering my name. He'll be dealing with Kimmy Jin soon if he isn't careful. Aubrey and Chloe are suddenly both entering the bathroom. Chloe looks like she's coming down from her alcohol high. Aubrey looks like she did when I left a couple hours earlier.

"Are you okay," Aubrey asks in a concerned tone.

I nod and grab her hand. Aubrey rubs circles into the top of my hand with her thumb. Chloe grabs my other hand and pulls me against her side. I watch Aubrey look out the door to assess the situation at hand. I can still hear Jesse, but it sounds like he's meeting the wrath that is Kimmy Jin. I feel Aubrey tug on my hand and let her pull me from the bathroom.

We arrive at their room without any further hitches. Jesse never spotted us sneaking down the hall. At least I don't think he did anyway. I let Chloe lead me to the bed and drop into her lap. Chloe nuzzles my neck and I can't help but smile. Her hand is suddenly cupping me through my shorts and I'm finding it hard to breathe.

"Chlo," I groan breathily. She's drunk. I really shouldn't do this. But if she's my girlfriend then does it really matter? I shoot Aubrey a look and she just smiles slightly at me.

"Chloe is much more affectionate when she's drunk."

Chloe hums against my neck in agreement. I chuckle as I feel her hand slowly loosen. I look down and see that she's fallen asleep. I lie her down on the bed before moving over to Aubrey, who pulls me into her lap.

"Are you still mad at me for being late to auditions and not knowing the song?"

Aubrey chuckles and kisses my jaw. "No. I'll admit, I was a little upset at first. But then Jesse started coming onto you and I realized it was ridiculous for me to be upset with you."

I smile and turn to connect our lips. Aubrey's kiss is more gentle than usual and I realize it's probably because of the Jesse situation. I deepen the kiss and push closer to Aubrey.

"Thank you for saving me," I mumble against her lips.

Aubrey just smiles and lies back on her bed, pulling me with her. "Well, you're my girlfriend. I'll always protect you. I've been protective of Chloe since before we started dating. It's just in my nature. Now, you should probably sleep because you're going to classes tomorrow."

I groan and dramatically throw myself back on her bed. Aubrey is definitely the one that holds me responsible in this relationship. "Fine, but I better get a reward for it."

Aubrey's eyes twinkle mischievously as she nods. I smile and shake my head, curling into Aubrey's larger body. I'll wait to mention that I have to work with Jesse tomorrow. I don't know what Aubrey can possibly do about that.