A/N: This is the sequel to the story Truth or Dare. You should be able to get by without having read it, but it would definitely make a lot more sense if you did.
It was Kol Mikaelson's birthday and he wanted to do something fun… So of course he thought that the appropriate choice would be to invite over all of the people who had been over to play truth or dare on Rebekah's birthday, along with a few others, to come play a new game. Klaus, Rebekah, Elijah, Elena, Jeremy, Bonnie, Matt, Caroline, Katherine, Stefan, Damon, Tyler, Hayley, Alaric, and April were all invited.
He didn't want to play truth or dare again since he figured that there had been too many good dares that were already taken… He thought that it might be a little too repetitive and he was sure that there would be major jealousy problems considering how bad they were before people had coupled up.
So instead he decided on the drinking game of Never Have I Ever. The rules were simple, they go around in order and each person would say 'Never have I ever' and then something that they hadn't done. Anyone who had done that had to drink.
Kol had just finished explaining the rules, mostly for Elijah's benefit, to everyone in the room.
"I'll go first since it's my birthday," Kol told them.
There was an awkwardly long pause before Katherine asked, "Well are you going to go or not?"
"I'm trying to think of something that I haven't done," Kol responded causing Katherine to roll her eyes. "Never have I ever gotten drunk enough to make out with Nik."
Stefan rolled his eyes as he and Caroline both drank.
"Never have I ever died," Hayley went next.
Kol, Elijah, Klaus, Rebekah, Katherine, Stefan, Damon, Elena, Jeremy, Alaric, Tyler, and Caroline drank.
Kol silently thought that it was a very good thing that he had revealed the whole vampire thing to April a few weeks beforehand… She was still getting entirely used to the news though.
"Never have I ever…" Tyler began before a smirk formed on his lips as he thought of something good. "Gotten drunk enough to throw up all over my girlfriend's parents."
"Not cool," Matt muttered as he drank.
"Neither was hurling all over my dad," Elena told him with a smirk.
"If I remember correctly you threw up about one foot to the left of him immediately after," Matt pointed out. It was his turn, so he thought for a second before adding. "Never have I ever cheated with a ghost."
Clearly he did not want to be the only one singled out.
Jeremy unhappily drank as he glared over at his friend. April seemed a little confused, but didn't bother asking.
Rebekah thought about what to say for a second before she said, "Never have I ever killed my own parent."
Klaus and Stefan both drank at that.
"Never have I ever given someone the profound dating advice of 'Boy likes girl, girl likes boy. Sex'," Elena said as she smirked over at Caroline.
"What? When did I ever say that?" Caroline asked.
"I was there," Bonnie pointed out. "It was right after you went on a long complaining rant because she hadn't slept with Stefan yet… Back when he first came to town."
Caroline glared for a second longer as she tried to figure out what they were talking about before she remembered it.
"Oh," She said quietly before taking a drink.
Klaus seemed amused as he silently wondered where he had been when that had been her attitude… Although he preferred her the way that she currently was and he had admittedly enjoyed the challenge of getting her.
"Never have I ever been pregnant," Stefan said.
Katherine rolled her eyes as she drank.
"Never have I ever…" Klaus said, seeming to have to try as hard as Kol had to think of something. A slight smirk formed on his lips as he said, "Drank from a rabbit."
Stefan rolled his eyes as he drank. Damon also ended up drinking since he had forced himself to try out his brother's diet a few times before, very unsuccessfully.
Since Elena had given one to single Caroline out, Caroline decided to return the favour.
"Never have I ever been adopted," Caroline said.
Hayley took a drink.
"Thanks," Elena said sarcastically before taking a drink. "I see that we're playing this game again."
Caroline simply smiled back innocently at her friend.
The pair had a history of getting into battles of trying to give worse things to the other in games like that.
"Never have I ever dared someone to make out with their brother," Jeremy spoke up.
Caroline took a drink as she had to smirk a little at the memory of getting rid of Elena's limits with dares that she knew the other girl would never perform.
"Never have I ever had sex with a Salvatore," Bonnie said proudly.
Elena, Katherine, Rebekah, Caroline, and Alaric all drank.
All eyes instantly focussed on Alaric in confusion.
"It wasn't with me," Stefan spoke up.
"This isn't awkward at all," Alaric muttered under his breath as he thought to himself that he could benefit from being at least a little more drunk at that point.
"How did that even happen?" Elena asked.
"Well I could go into detail if you want," Damon replied suggestively. "But long story short, he didn't believe that I was that good in bed. So I proved him wrong."
"You are such a dick," Alaric commented although he couldn't correct Damon.
Damon ignored the comment as he said, "Never have I ever called Damon 'some magical sex god sent from above as a gift to this world'."
Alaric had said that sarcastically before they had slept together, but of course Damon didn't feel the need to mention that.
"Such a dick," Alaric repeated as he as took another drink.
A/N: Please read and review! I hope that you guys liked the chapter and thanks for reading. :) Suggestions for what some 'Never have I ever's is certainly welcome. Oh, and just to explain, Elena is not a vampire. The death being referred to is from when she was sacrificed.