Great chapter!

Oh, Sigrid...I hope she can get out of this situation somehow.

Got to love Kili for still haveing some hope that the be able to change Thorin's mind. Or even if he doesn't have any hope that they will be able to change Thorin's mind he still not willing to gave up. I KNEW that seeing Fili so unhappy and knowing he is (Thorin) behind it was eating at Thorin from with in. And the fact that somthing other the his true soul that he can't form any thing to stop it form happening unless he go against the good of people and belive it to be righ is also eating him up. If ony he I see that it

Here's Bard to save the day...well at less the best that he can he does have to deal with Thorin and we all know how stubborn he can be. Hopefully Bard can change Thorin's mind even with all that stubbornness. Inknow it may be a long shot but, one can hope right? Plus to quote Aragorn "There is always hope" so I'm going to hope that Bard is able to change Thorin's mind abot all of this. Bard us a good dad he us everyone should have a dad like that. Loved that Arne and Soren pretended to be Fili and Kili for they do so much mace me think that that how Fili and Kili would have acted when they were that age.

I was right (as I knew I would be)it is depresse because he can't help out Fili like the way he wanted to so he gong to have to see Fili being so very unhappy. Ihope that Tauriel is right Ihope that they will be able to change Thorin's mind about all of this I really really do. Loved Kili's and Tauriel's cuddlin that the one happy thing abot this drpessing chapter just as the other chapter'have been sance Fili's and Thorin's talk (not complaining just say the truth) so ver very sad I hope it gets happer soon. So glad that Tidal did let go of asking Sign what was bothering her until she finally said it for I truly believe that that help eas her pain somewhat, it us all ways good to talk about what bothering you even if you (like Sigrid) only talk about some of it and not all. I hope that Tidal is able to get Sigrid on her own again and have her talk more about it or at less the Bard for maybe he be able toget more out if Sigrid then she can. I can help n but think that Tails remind me a lot of Kili just now.

Very kind and not at all saprizing of/for Kili to strep I on Fili's behalf. Kili (like me) just wants everyone to be happy and no more sacrifice's to be mad especially (I believe) Fili fir he made so many aready and nearly died because of some if the such as the journeyto reclaim Erebor, the battle of the 5 army's, and others too. Why does he have to make this one why? It is NOT selfish for Fili to what to be with Sigrid. Why is Thorin doing this to himself, (yes I said himself) he hurting himself too for he is having someone he cares deeply (yes I know he cares for both Fili and Kili, never doubted that) to go through the same pain that he gas and see us going through, he nearly had Kili di the same thing but. Thank goodness Des didn't let that happen and I KNOW she would have dune the same for Fili if she was still alive. I really do feel sorry for Thorin for I believe that it is hurting him a lot by having Fili break things off with there us Kili who see the unhappiness in both of Fili and Thorin and really not able to stop it, that right there have to be hard. It us sad that so many are hurt by this not just Fili, Sigrid and her boys so very very sad.

Soooo happy that everyone mange to came out if the Wargs attack in one piece with just a few cuts and scraps. I was bit worred about Tilda but thankfully she woke up and us okay. Poor Fili and Sigrid it just so sad they love eachother so much and they just can't be together. Sigrid is right it NOT fare not at all. How can Fili been good king when his hart is so broken? How can he be a good king when he is being eaten from the inside out with the gilt of hurting Sigrid? How can he be a good king wan he is so very very sad and lonely? I just what to cry for him and gave him a hug. It's just not right what he's going through, nore Sigrid fir that matter she been in a loveless marriage for years then when she was free from it she finally found someone that made her fill like she was special and amazing (which she is) and now it is taking away from just as sh was thinking if how lucky sge was to have found it. There us also Soren and Arne who are going to be hrut by this for they love Fili so that much bee clear sance the 3rd chapter
he was there friend and so much more. Have Thorin wake up and see truly see what this is doing to Fili and have stop it not only for Fili's sake snd Sigrid and her boys but for both Erebors and Dales people.

I was KNEW this to happen not being attacke by wargs but the way Fili's and Thorin's talk went. Why?...Why?... Why does Fili have to gave up Sigrid? How is it betrayin his people by loving her and wanting her in his lifefor good? He loves her and she him, what's wrong with that? How can Thorin make Fili end things with Sigrid wen he once when through the sam thing? How can he have Fili go though this kind of pain? Why did he have to bragup Kili for?Especially in the manner that he did, it seemed like he his blaming Kili for somthing and is looking down at him for it. Is't Kili's marriage to Tauriel doing good for both the Elf's and the Dwarves. Another thing why doesThorin have to call her she-elf her name is (Thorin you GIT) Tauriel. WHAY can't Thorin use his HEARTas well instead of just his head?
Doesn't he know that you truly need to use both to be a good not only for the kingdom and its people but there there allys too? You and your cliffhanger's (so many many cliffhanger's) really do get aggravating attime, did you know that? I really hope everyone is not to hrut ir worst dead. By the way you still didn't tell us how Tilda got to Erebor. For I remember reading that she wave good by to Sigrid and the others when they left to go to Erebor. (I'm not complaining really I'm not I'm just curious is all) I really hope that Thorin thanks this over abot Fili and Sigrid like he short of did (only saying short of because of the way he machine Kili) with Kili and Tauriel with Dis help of course. If she was still here she would so Thorin how much of a GIT he is being about just like she did wit Kili and Tauriel. Poor poor Fili I would very much like to gave him a hug.

Kili was rightSigrid dose like Kili (no saprize there) I do so very very very very very very much like Fili Sigrid, and her boy outing it was ver very sweet and fun. Fili is right Sigrid is not simple she is so much more then that,and it was a great shame and so very very worng that ger husband never showed her that she was. Ihope that her and Fili can hove more of this outing some with the Arne, and Soren and some without. I'm glad that Sigrid was able to have Fili finally truly cry over the lost of Dis. Crying us so ver much a part of grieving, it is NOT I repeat NOT shameful to cry, it is very much needed. Ihope Fili talk with Thorin go's wel Ihope that Thorin will see how happy Fili is and gave Fili his blessing. Ihope I really really do but I'm afraid that it not going to be that easym it wasn't for Kili and Tauriel si I don't think it's going to be for Fili and Sigrid eather. Sad I know but I can't help but believe it true.

I'm glad that Soren has been getting a little bit better thoughout out the day, I was so worried that Soren would be blind or have a permanent problem of not being able to see clearly. I'm glad that that doesn't seem to be the case. I like reading about Kili taking of Fili it usually the other way around it was a nice change. It was so sad when Filia awoken the with Kili mopping his brow with a cool rageand telling Kili that he dreamed of me is dieing of a fever. Not knowing that it really happened and asking for her. It was sad not only for him but for Kili too of course. So very very happy that Fili has gotten better by the end of this book. I really with at he stop with the gilte trip apon himself. Hopefully with Sigrid saying it's not hi fault for the second tim he now stop it for good. Of course Arne and Soren like Fili look at all he did for them and Sigrid not to manchen hus really cool and very kind dwarf. HATE whatmFili betrothed did to him to case him so much pain. I hope that Sigrid can clear his mind of those things and thought soo,n. Please let his not being able to sleep because of his thoughts be good ones and not bad please.

See Fili Thorin was right Sigrid didn't blame you for Soren. So would you please lessen to her, Kili, Thorin, and Oin (and any one else how said as much)and STOP blaming youself.
Plus Soren is awake. So that a good sign right?
************************************************************* I REALLY hope that Soren will get better and be back to himself as soon as possible. I know he won't be 100% to himselfright away but please have it be soon. I also hope that Fili get over his sicknes soon and that he stop it with feeling giltey for he aready injured and now he sick adding never ending blame will have him get even worse. Loved Fili snd Sigrid little moment . I hope they have more of them, with an uninjured and unsinkable Fili and a happy and playfull Soren as well as a happy and playful Arne. Awww YeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeePeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee are they are going to have an outing how sweet.

Poor Fili (that nigapoop) HEAT that he is blaming himself for Soren. Kili, Oin, and Thorin are right this is NOT his fault he did what he couldwith the little amount of time that was Gaven to him. Those boys are alive because of him Arne just has a few cuts and whatnot and Soren may be unconscious but he is alive and because of he has a chance to wake-up, a change that he would not have if it wasn't for Fili. I really like Torino and Fili talk it shows us a side of Thorin that we (sadly) don't get to see that much. Kili may gave been a little harsh but that I believe is because he seen what Thorin gilt had dune to him and he can't stand Fili doing the same thing to himself that Thorin has and (sadly) probably still is doing to himself. And Thorin was also right in saying that Sigrid will not blame Fili for Soren. I believe that she will think him as soon as she see him for saving her son's for that is precisely what he did save them. There us no way that Sigrid Wil blame Fili for Soren unconsciousness no none at all that isn't like her.

Poor little Soren I really hope that he wakes up soon with out having any permanent damage dune to him. Arne is a very good older bother to little Soren I can see whow tge boys remind Fili of himself and Kili. Indeed Arne is very much like Fili and apparently Soren is a lot like Kili. I hope that Fili as well as Arne don't blame themselves fir what happened to little Soren for it us no one fault. Okay granted they should have not been out in the mines nor should the have creap out of their's and Sigrid room to go there but the bothpayed for it, so please do not gave Arne be blaming himself. As for Fili well he did everything ge could to protected those boys until Kili came to the rescue and ge still protected from the falling bits of rubble that fell as Kili was moving the rock's to free them. Oh and just in case Kili is blaming himself gave him stop it for its no one's fault, the same go's for Sigrid children will be children it's very hard to all ways keep a eye out on you kids with out losing them once in a wile.

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
Please let the Fili and the little ones be aright please. Poor Sigrid, she already be through a lot a lot a lot and she already sceartthat enough having something bad or worse happening to them would destroy there Kili he aready like Sigrid been though so much and he just lost his mother, you serious can't kill Fili no j you just can't nor seriously injured. There is also Bain Bard and Tilda (speaking if Tilda how did she get to EreborI thought that she was in Dale) who would be at a loss if anything BAD happen to the little ther Thorin he again been though so much and he just lost a sister and a dear one at that, then there is Tauriel for whatever effects Kili effects her plus she Fili is her friend, and you know what? Having anything truly bad or worse happen to eather one of the will be no good to any one it just won't soooooooo pretty pretty prety prety pretty PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
Don't have any thing bad happen to them please pretty please.

I HATE IT that people MAN in protickerly believe that crying weakness especially doing it in front of others. It is part of a emotion that usely come with sadness and grief. I wish that Fili would have aloud himself to openly cry in front of Sigrid and also aloud himself to have done the same thing when Kili did when they were with Dis when she died. I wish that Thorin and Kili would have also the same, at less Kili did when he was in he room her, Thorin, and Fili. I Gant believe that other would consider it a weakness they all lost someone near and dear to them. As if losing Dis is not enough now they have to have a Cave in not good no to good at all and what even worse is that Arne, and Soren are missing oh dear oh dear oh dear not good no no no no no.