This was such an awesome tear jerker fanfic!

I was really afraid this would have a sad ending. And it kind of did, with Sandy being really dead. But the ending still managed to make me smile. Yay for Jack to choose his family!

I'm sad that Sandman is gone but it's reeeeeaaally good... pleeeaaase update soon!

I cried soooo much in this chapter.

NO! nononononononnonono!
I REFUSE TO FFEEL SORRY FOR PITCH!
WHAT HAVE YOU DONE! PITCH IS THE BADGUY!
YOU HAVE RRUINED MY LIFE! (Let's out a dry sob and collapses to the floor)
I'm sorry. That was a bit too dramatic.
see you on the other side-TA

the twins along with Sandy smiled huge as they gave a thumbs up

I THOUGHT SANDY WAS DEAD

Ah, Bunny will always be the toasted marshmallow. Crisp on the outside but all soft and gooey on the inside (after all he is a fluffy rabbit anyways). A new beginning for the reunited four Guardians.. I like this ending. It was sweet :) This was a good story.

(Why did I take a whole decade to get back to this and review I don't even know oh my blob I'm sorry) This was so bittersweet. The descriptions of the way the Guardians felt and the guilt of Pitch was sad. I'm still upset that Sandy's gone but... obviously I know it DID say in the title that he's permanently gone here, but still. I'm so glad Jack returns safely and they can all go home :') But there's still one chapter I gotta read, so it's not over yet for me, woo! Anywho. :)

that was good, I liked it

omg the feeelllssss T-T Jack! noooooooooooooooooooooooooes!

OMG crying here. The feels! Great story!

Very good ending! Very sweet and nice. I'm happy for them all (although, I did start singing Let It Go in that last paragraph with the Guardians). Hehe.

That is the absolute perfect last line. I loved your story. It was creative and different. I'm glad Sandy is still watching though.

How come in part of that, Sandy is there? 'Til next time

Ooh, that was a horrible cliffie. Thanks for not ending it there!
Yay, happiness. Jack's back! So, you said the next chapter would be a prologue type thing. Are we still going to see Jack explain what happened? Maybe some bonding?