This made me really sad :'(
It was brilliant, but sad... WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU!? :'( Messing with my feels, bro

This was a very good and well written story!

I am SO glad this story is still around, you have no idea (you probably really don't have any idea; you're probably off doing other things in real life, but whatever... I'm off on a tangent). I want the world to know that I don't have an original bone in my body. The very root of my Elf/Uruk stories goes back to Enros' fanfiction - there is nothing new under the sun - and gods bless this beauty of a fanfiction. I'm only so sad now that in retrospect, it's so short. But damned if it wasn't enough! I'm saving this and printing this for perpetuity.

This was so startlingly, exquisitely beautiful, that it simply blew my mind. Outstanding work.

Brava! this is a beautiful story and a joy to read. Good work!

Wow. Um. How did you do that? You actually wrote an ElrondxUgluk and it worked.

Beautifully written. Loved the characterization.

Well who would have thought that Elrond/Uruk hai pairing could actually work? Well u apparently ;)

So yes. It was beautiful and presented Uruk hais in a new way.

I first thought it would be more believable if instead of Elrond there would have been a younger elf, but maybe not. Elrond for he has lived so long and seen so many things, might just be able to understand Ugluk.

Btw u should change the story status to complete :)

This is...strange, and moving at the same time.

I kept seeing this story and didn't read it because I figured it would just be goofy. Wow, was I wrong, this was fantastic ! So glad I gave it a chance, what a great little story, thanks !

AHH elrond ! i luv elrond fanfics! luv this story! u r a great riter!

This is beautiful... extremely good. It's hard to find not smutty slash nowadays. I really appreciate your work.

I love your portrayal of Ugluk. You gave him a more humane side. One thing I find lacking in Tolkien's works (one of the VERY few p) is that his creatures of 'evil' are very "flat"...as in, they don't change, they have no personality, et cetera. Probably because they don't play a big part, but still... oh well nevermind, I'm rambling again, and probably no one will understand me. Gaah.

Anyway, really good, excellent, beautiful fic, as you said. _~.

Although I'm slightly biased maybe...I love Elrond, but my friends think he's an ugly old fart...sigh.

I adore your fic! It's brilliant! )

~Sremla

He would turn in his grave I admit ! * laughs* I loved the Disclaimer!

This was pretty good, I liked reading it,even tough I don't know how much compassion an Uruk-hai can have , but it was good.

~Damage

Interesting pairing...I loved it!

Well written and great dialogue. Interesting insight on both elf and Uruk.

Jen

x

That was indeed beautiful!

It's surprising -and refreshing- when people discover magic in things that are-not-nice.

We are made to believe that Uruks are mindless killing beasts and here you present a whole new theory. It really made me think about them under a whole new light.

The story was inspired, the slow prossess from hate to uncomfortable trust and then to affection was sensational.

Needless to say, I loved every word of it.

I'm so glad you reposted this. It's such a beautiful story.