shige por fa

Just saw your update.
Do whatever you feel is right, but if you want my opinion, it'll make matters more immediate if you start with Revenge of the Sith

Your the one writing so its your call but yeah revenge of the sith would be better i think, but again your fic your call

Is it just me or are most of the masters dicks, at most of the time?

I admit having Anakin and Padme react to themselves in a movie was awesome. Would love to see more if you have the time. Just take the time you need.

I would really love to see more of this story I think its a great story if you feel up to writing it

Howdy, if ypour inspiration lies in moving to RotS, then I say go for it. I would like to come back to Attack of the Clones though, while the whole movie may not be up to snuff there are some moments I think the group should see, or more accurately, I would like for them to see.

Everything with Anakin and Padme on Tatooine, cause I always thought that scene where he tells her he killed the sand people was powerful.

Of course the end, showing their wedding, for Obi-wan.

Any lightsaber fighting for Luke, cause I find the thought of him comparing himself to the Jedi of the Old Republic kinda funny. Like, he'll be the most critical of himself, maybe Obi-wan can offerntonspar to try and cheer him up?

I wish youd let him continue still, you've had this fic up for 5 years, and only 2 chapter of content, atleast he had a better work ethic and update record

ROTS is a very good idea !

I feel you should imply that they finished AOTC and then jump into ROTS. Because without AOTC or even phantom, Obi-wan and even Han and Leia won't see Anakin's growth as a person, and how he used to be good and was torn apart by his mother's death and his relationship with Padme. Then again, I suppose ROTS touches on that. So if you wanted to leave AOTC untouched and focus only on Revenge, I think that'd work too. But they may need the context of Anakin's emotions in AOTC.

If you would rather start with Revenge of the Sith, then go for it. I’m gonna read it either way :)

By all means go with revenge of the Sith. Please

You might want to start with a youtube video or something explaining Vader's fall and then show the movies, otherwise the story of Anakin will not be complete with just episode 3. I can't see the Jedi reacting that well to episode 3 without that background, if you decide to include any, and it is important information for preventing the fall in the first place so it is needed. There are some amazing ones out there that explain it better than probably the writers ever thought possible.

I think changing the film is for the best, and I agree the attack of the clones isn’t integral to the story line. My father once told me that in every trilogy, the middle installment is meaningless. Whatever happens in it will be recapped in the final installment and honestly has no bearing on anything, being simply filler. But anyway, I hope your classes go well! Good luck on getting that BA!

Thank for what you have written i have enjoyed it so much.

But if you find yourself not the biggest fan of this star wars movie and that being one not all (for I understand real life before fun). Not all reasons but one of them, that makes it's so hard for you to write the story I would like you to move on to revenge of the sith please.

If it help you writing muse? because there just arwnt enough of this types of fanfiction and So I enjoy them.

You story also has some through behind it and written really well. So what everyone you more passionate about I say write that one.

Either way you go weather with finish attack of the clones or not and moving on to revenge of the sith. I will continue reading them.

Thank you