James and Sirius 4lyf! I don't care if Lily ends up with Snape or Aragog for that matter, but you can't just break up James and Sirius. Blasphemy.

This is a fantastic story, with a believable growth for all of the characters in it. That it's got so little response is just criminal.

Very awesome au story

Neat idea! And a very fun story to boot!

amazing story :) good job with the prompt :)

Wow! It's one of the best oneshots I've ever come across!

Every aspect of the story was unique and the ending I especially loved. I liked the way you developed James and showed how he grew and matured, and the dynamic between the four friends and their reconciliation just made everything that much sweeter.

Looking forward to more!

Really cool fic and I loved the friendship between the four :)

Very original

Wow. This was amazing. I seriously could not have written anything like this and you pulled a 10K epic from out of nowhere. This was incredible. There were no typo's as far as I saw, and the only little thing I would pick at was the fic that there was no James/Lily. :( Still, I don't really care because everything else was wonderful. It would be very interesting to read a sequel, and how James being in Slytherin would affect Harry and his perceptions of his father.

Again, amazing story. :)

This was unique and very well done. Everyone was in character, but you let them develop with the change in circumstances, and it worked.

I wonder what would change because of these changes... Severus would never hear the prophesy, if there was one. Lily's child would be a Snape. No animagi, because the Wolfsbane potion took its place as the gift from one of Remus' friends. I wonder if Peter would be targeted for conscripting into the Death Eaters, since he is not connected to the powerful Marauders.

So many small and large differences.

I'm glad James and Sirius will get another chance in the Aurors.

I'd love to read a sequel.

K

I love it! A great AU of what could have happened if The Maruaders weren't fully united and saw past the prejudice. They all got happy endings too, especially Snape!

That was a pretty good story. :) Thumbs up.

I like it :3

I really enjoyed this one shot. Many thanks for sharing :)

That was absolutely amazing. I'm a Slytherin myself at Pottermore so I appreciate that you showed that Slytherin can produce great, NOT evil wizards. Also the Snape plot was totally captivating. To me he will always be a jerk, but I really liked how you made him check out the Dark Arts and let him come back later. The only thing I have a problem with is lack of Jily. I understand that friends don't date their friends' crushes, but still. You should let Snape date, say, that Mandy or make him understand that James and Lily completely complement each other, because they do, or something like that. But at least you didn't make it Snily. THAT I wouldn't stand. So, yeah. Long live you and all that. Bye!