Who the Hell is this psychopath? Is he another Jedidiah "Leatherface" Sawyer, Victor Zsasz, Doctor Hannibal Lecter, John "Jigsaw" Kramer, Anton Schott the Dollmaker, Lazlo "Pyg" Valentin, Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb, Francis Dolarhyde the Great Red Dragon, Mason Verger, Vaas Montenegro, Walter Sullivan, or Adrian Chase AKA Prometheus?

I don’t mean for this to sound like hate, but you’re sick. Seriously, that was insanely sick and twisted and omg it actually made me puke multiple times.

I really don't know what to say...
It was refreshing to read a complete AU without wendigos or where Josh wasn't the "bad guy", but on the other hand it was a horrible experience for the group anyway :0
Of course I can't say that I liked all of them being tortured by this sick psycho and it was gruesome what they had to go through, but I have to admit that you had some nasty ideas about the plot and the different torture scenes that were really unique!
I would have liked for the police to get the bastard or for a sequel where the gang help the investigation and catch him (and of course more JAM moments for this little fangirl here :D), but that's for you to decide. Anyway, I hope that you continue writing these great stories and keep the (JAM) spirit alive :)
PS: poor Emily, I'm so devastated by her demise but it makes me a tad bit happy that her feelings for Matt were sincere. Still, she did not deserve this gruesome death (although it got your point across nicely) :(
PPS: seems like I'm not the only one watching too much Criminal Minds from time to time ;)

First off, thank you so much for the sweet review you wrote for UWMA. I really appreciate you taking time out of your life to read and review my weird story! And as for this story, wow... this was such the bittersweet ending. I have read every word of this beginning to end, some chapters more than once, and I just have to say that this is an impressive addition to this small fandom.

I really love how you didn't make the ending all sappy and sugarcoated like a lot of other people do with their epilogues. This was raw, and it was a rollercoaster of emotions from beginning to end. This ending really tugged at my heartstrings- with Emily, and the mentions of Hannah and Matt. At the same time, I am relieved that Chrashley, Jossam, and Mike/Jess (they need a short ship name likeeee come on) all still exist after everything that happened. Like I said, a very bittersweet ending that ties it all together perfectly.

I have absolutely zero regrets (why would I have any?) for checking this out way back in August, and I can promise you that I'll be returning periodically just to read over this again and again. Wonderful job!

What a fitting conclusion. At the beginning they were your typical teens, at the end they were people who knows what life is really like. Amazing story. Thank you and have a nice day.

OMG I love this story so much, the final chapter is awesome and omg my babies Em and Matt :( Also I was wondering when are you going to update Fairy Lights bc it's a great story so far :)

Everytime you post a new vhapter, i go back and read from the beginning because i want all the feels with every chapter.

Oh god, I love Jessica so much, and this chapter was so heartbreaking to read. At least they're finally safe and sound, and at least she and Mike are still together. I will always ship those two.

Nice chapter, as always. I don't know how it's going to end though. Thank you and have a nice day.

*claps hands loudly while crying like a baby*
Yes, yes, yes! This chapter, once again, killed me. Beth is probably always gonna feel awful that she couldn't save her twin sister... really a heart-wrenching chapter. Awesome job writing :'(
Moving on to happier news... I am so excited for an update on While the World Crumbles! I love that story just as much as this one. I'm so ready to read all about a Chrashley wedding! Yaaay.

Well look at this they found their friends, but so far that asshole has gotten away. Have you ever heard of the "Lovely Bones"? If you haven't I don't blame you, but if they never catch him, how about you put a years later part where he looks older and then out of nowhere he dies from something

Wow. I didn't expect a chapter so soon. So far so good. Thank you and have a nice day.

Please continue this story, I hope poor Ash survives

Oh, wow... this killed me a million times over. I can't even imagine how Ashley must feel after this :(
On another note, I loved your comparison with beast and prey. Considering how I strongly headcanon Ashley as a writer (or did they say she was a writer in canon?), I can definitely see her mind painting her awful situation in that creative light. Wonderful job! And welcome back :)

YES! This story is back. But damn, The psycho is doing that to Ashley. I'm so glad that you haven't forgotten about this story. To be honest, I have no idea on how it will end. Hopefully, you can finish it. Thank you and have a nice day.