Reviews for Harry Potter and the Hermetic Arts
TianYi chapter 31 . 7/25
Dude, this is the best HP fic power twist that ive read!
WarChicken chapter 10 . 7/21
Coal. And he turned it to Diamond?! woot!
Ezmerelda chapter 31 . 7/13
Very creative use of game lore. It's been attempted by others before, but none as good as this. Thanks for writing.
Bearmauls chapter 29 . 7/9
I do feel Hermione freaked out a bit much over Harry killing Quirrelmort. I mean, this is the same person who almost got her killed by releasing a troll, and is also hosting/merged with the dark wizard who murdered and tortured countless people including Harry's parents, AND has made it pretty clear he is going to kill Harry and Hermione as well. That's not murder, that's justifiable homicide due to self-defense. It actually feels like a very clear-cut example of self-defense too.
Bearmauls chapter 27 . 7/9
That was unexpected, but hopefully a fun ongoing plot thread.
Bearmauls chapter 25 . 7/9
Fay is clearly the most competent first year, aside from Harry.
Bearmauls chapter 24 . 7/9
I've always imagined potions to be more like a magical ritual, where the mage making the potion is imbuing their own magic through the brewing process, to reshape the magic present in the ingredients. The problem when it being all ingredient-based, is that you could potentially automate the magic, which just seems wrong somehow, aside from how it would completely break the potterverse.
Bearmauls chapter 20 . 7/9
I lose some respect for Harry for being so uninterested in wand magic. Yes, it certainly has some limitations in comparison to his own magic, but it also lacks some limitations his own magic has. Wouldn't it be better to know both? Nobody ever complained about being able to do too much magic :P
Bearmauls chapter 19 . 7/9
Fay is a bright girl.

Poor Harry, accidentally breaking his emotions.
Bearmauls chapter 18 . 7/9
Harry seems strangely unconcerned about his seeming inability to use wand magic. You'd think his head of house would be talking to him about it at this point.
Bearmauls chapter 17 . 7/9
The interaction with Cho was rather hilarious. Ah JK and your odd need to have alliterative names.
Bearmauls chapter 16 . 7/9
Harry might be a little too suspicious. Yes, people might be out to get you, but properly recovering from injuries is also a good idea if people are out to get you.
Bearmauls chapter 15 . 7/9
I love stories where protagonists tear apart the house point system :)
Bearmauls chapter 13 . 7/9
Huh, so even his custom wand doesn't seem to do anything. That could be a problem in classes.
Bearmauls chapter 12 . 7/9
It didn't even occur to me that Harry's tattoo would block the Sorting Hat! That's actually pretty funny. The way Dumbledore kept trying to work Gryffindor-traits into his interview questions was hilarious.
1,193 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »